Steve Satullo talks about films, video, and media worth talking about. (Use search box at upper left to find films, directors, or performers.)
Saturday, May 06, 2006
Notre Musique
Jean-Luc Godard divides his film like the Divine Comedy: Hell is a montage of clips from movies and newsreels, of warfare in all ages and all places. Purgatory (the bulk of the film) is set in postwar Sarajevo, where a writers’ conference is supposed to aid reconstruction, but mainly serves to offer up the litany of appropriated citations that usually make up a Godard script, some actually delivered by JLG himself. Heaven is a weird construct, sort of a riverside hippie haven guarded by U.S. servicemen (as the Marine Corp Hymn predicts.) It’s been a long time since I considered Godard an essential filmmaker; from Weekend on, my admiration has been distant at best. After ignoring his whole Maoist phase and after, I’ve been struck by how visually lovely, if sometimes horrific or incoherent, his recent films have been. There is an inherent fascination to his window on Sarajevo, and there are snippets of significant comment on the dim possibilities for reconciliation both in the Balkans and the Middle East, but the insights are fragmentary and sometimes preposterous. I wonder whether the heaven sequence betokens Godard’s posthumous reconciliation with Truffaut (my main man), after their split back in ’68, since it is reminiscent of the end of Fahrenheit 451, and the camera lingers on someone reading a novel by David Goodis, the source of Shoot the Piano Player. (2004, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-77.)
The Tales of Hoffmann
This Michael Powell & Emeric Pressburger follow-up to The Red Shoes did not charm me as much as other work from “The Archers,” but does have its proponents and will fit neatly into a film series at the Clark next fall. An adaptation of Jacques Offenbach’s operetta of the poet’s misadventures in love, this film melds music and dance with design and camerawork into a spectacle that will captivate some and impress all. Richard Rounseville is the title character, and dancer Moira Shearer and others reappear from the earlier film. (1951, dvd, n.) *6+*
Sunday, April 30, 2006
Dear Readers
Your numbers are not legion, but your response has been appreciated. I will resume writing for you, and not just mumbling to myself. In fact I will be grateful to have an ongoing outlet for my own voice, now that I’m embarking on a project to compile and edit a book of essays by Tom Krens, director of the Guggenheim and friend of mine since freshman days at Williams forty years ago.
I’ve just posted my filmlog for April, much of which was devoted to films ranked high in the Village Voice critics’ poll of 2005. Soon I will post my response to the poll as a whole, and thereafter resume posting film by film, striving for concise completeness instead of simply recording my opinion. But I confess I’m unlikely to proceed with technical refinements to this website that I have long contemplated. Yet I hope my film commentaries offer some service, and that you will bookmark this site and return periodically.
Thank you for your attention and your responses. Further comment is welcome: ssatullo@clarkart.edu
I’ve just posted my filmlog for April, much of which was devoted to films ranked high in the Village Voice critics’ poll of 2005. Soon I will post my response to the poll as a whole, and thereafter resume posting film by film, striving for concise completeness instead of simply recording my opinion. But I confess I’m unlikely to proceed with technical refinements to this website that I have long contemplated. Yet I hope my film commentaries offer some service, and that you will bookmark this site and return periodically.
Thank you for your attention and your responses. Further comment is welcome: ssatullo@clarkart.edu
Filmlog for April
4-4-06: 2046. *6+* (2005, dvd, n.) Wong Kar-Wei is definitely something; I’m just not sure what. His latest is a quasi-sequel to In the Mood for Love, and my admiration remains distant. This critical darling (#2 in Village Voice critics’ poll for best of 2005) is lushly designed and shot, heavy with atmosphere, light on coherence. Tony Leung is excellent as ladies’ man pulp writer, and the ladies -- oh my! -- are the likes of Ziya Zhang and Gong Li, so the film is easy to watch if hard to make sense of. (MC-78.)
4-9-06: Gunner Palace. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) Not as coherent as Occupation: Dreamland, but nearly as essential in coming to terms with just what American troops are being asked to do in Iraq. This film follows an artillery unit bivouacked in the half-wrecked palace of one of Saddam’s sons and going out on raids and patrol in Baghdad; it’s more exclusively from the perspective of the Americans than the other doc, but still it puts you there, where we so clearly should not be. (MC-70.)
4-10-06: Head-On (Gegen die Wand.) *7* (2004, Sund/T, n.) L’amour fou among Turkish emigres in Hamburg, Germany. Just like the lead actress, Sibell Kekilli, this film from young director Fatih Akin makes you ponder whether it is just interesting-looking or profoundly beautiful. Adrift between worlds, two attempted suicides meet cute in a mental institution. She latches onto him (Birol Unel) as the Turkish husband who will placate her traditional Islamic family, and in a platonic marriage of convenience allow her to continue her pursuit of sex, drugs, and rock’n’roll. Of course they fall in love, but nothing else about this film is pat or predictable. Its a sympathetic glimpse into strange but familiar lives, recommended if you’re willing to take the journey. (MC-78.)
4-11-06: Neil Young: Heart of Gold. *8* (2006, Images, n.) Shows what a concert film can be. Not just a record of a performance, but a visual narrative in its own right. Jonathan Demme already has Stop Making Sense under his belt, but this rivals Marty Scorsese and The Band’s Last Waltz for best rock film ever. I didn’t go in as a big Neil Young fan, though inevitably he is part of the soundtrack of my life, but he definitely made the sale with me, premiering his “Prairie Wind” album at the Ryman in Nashville, and then going on to reprise some of his more famous hits. Backed by his wife and Emmylou Harris, and a gang of old buddies, as well as horn and string and gospel choir sections, Neil Young gets across his straightforward but incantatory lyrics in an intimate and impassioned manner, with the camera perfectly framing his storytelling and preacherman ballads. Soul-stirring and completely satisfying. (MC-85.)
4-15-06: Paradise Now. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) While it is certainly worthwhile to get an even-handed Palestinian view from the West Bank, the mixture of elements in Hany Abu-Assad’s film do not quite cohere. There are some fascinating documentary street scenes, but more than anything this is a fairly glossy ticking-bomb thriller. Will they or won’t they? Two lifelong friends are selected for a suicide bombing mission; they are not wild-eyed religious fanatics but young men interested in women, hookah-smoking, and Arab pop music. One grew up in a refugee camp and feels the need to erase the family stain of his father’s collaboration with the Israelis. The other values the posthumous celebrity the mission may bring him, though his farewell videotape is comically bungled. But they both have plenty of room for second thoughts, and debates with a pretty young women on what options they have for responding to the continuous humiliation of occupation. Everything hangs in the balance till the very last frame, but ultimately we don’t come out understanding any more than we did going in. (MC-71.)
4-17-06: Kings and Queen. *6+* (2005, dvd, n.) I am partly won over by critical acclaim, partly by the appeal of the actors, and partly by director Arnaud Desplechin’s hommage to Truffaut in his dvd interview with Kent Jones, but watching this film was not for me the joy it is for many cinephiles. Its idiosyncracies did not speak to my own. Emmanuelle Devos and Mathieu Amalric lead a large and largely convincing cast, who seem believable even amidst the gaps and twists of the story. She’s a gallery owner, but is she at the mercy of, or merciless toward, men? He’s a musician tossed into the loony bin, but is he crazy or not? Once they were married, or at least together -- one dumped the other, but which? At any rate, she now wants him to adopt her son by a previous “husband” -- who may have killed himself, or she him? -- so she can marry a sugar daddy. Does her doe-eyed demeanor betoken fragile strength or carnivorous deceit? Are we to sympathize or recoil in horror? Laugh or cry? Truffaut or Hitchcock? The only truthful answer is all of the above. (MC-84.)
4-20-06: Code 46. *6-* (2004, dvd, n.) Filling out the prolific Michael Winterbottom filmography, this sci-fi romance about genetics is not as good as Andrew Nicoll’s Gattaca, but does conjure a plausible future out of contemporary Shanghai, Dubai, and India, well-suited to his on-the-fly filmmaking. Tim Robbins is palpably uncomfortable with such a guerrilla shoot, though Samantha Morton does get with the program. There is little chemistry between them, however, in this quasi-Oedipal drama. Code 46 is a regulation prohibiting incest in a world where cloning and in vitro reproduction are common. Turns out the woman he falls for is genetically identical to his mother. There’s “eternal sunshine” memory erasure, “empathy” viruses, and other futuristic apparatus, but the central love story does not grip. (MC-57.)
Last Days. *5* (2005, dvd, n.) You have to give Gus Van Sant credit for sticking to his guns. He’s definitely a filmmaker who follows through on his conception, whether inspired (Drugstore Cowboy, To Die For) or cuckoo (shot-by-shot remake of Psycho.) This follow-up to Elephant, his dreamy evocation of Columbine, quasi-documents in long shots and long takes the last days of Kurt Cobain in a decaying lakeside mansion. If you cared about Nirvana (and personally I couldn’t identify “Smells Like Teen Spirit” if you played the whole song for me), maybe you could fill in the state of mind of the protagonist as he drifts through slow and pointless scenes, albeit with a certain drugged loveliness to the cinematography and Michael Pitt’s performance. I note that Manohla Dargis of the NYTimes called this film “indisputably great” and it ranked #10 in Village Voice critics’ poll for 2005 -- but me, I hit the fast forward button to keep from falling asleep. (MC-67.)
4-23-06: Tropical Malady. *NR* (2004, dvd, n.) Here’s another film that defines my taste as not very highbrow, upper middlebrow at best. Thai filmmaker Apitchatpong Weerasethakul (who wisely goes by the name of Joe) takes us on a meandering path through fields, forests, and city streets, whose strangeness and beauty keep us watching through the slow and enigmatic twists of the tale. At first it seems like a rather sweet gay romance between a soldier and a country boy, who engage our interest; we want to see how their love goes. But then the film breaks, and the two actors reappear, the soldier the same but on patrol alone at night in the forest, and the boy become the wandering naked spirit of a tiger. The soldier stalks, sights, and finally confronts the tiger/boy. This may be a film that needs the immersive effect of watching on the big screen; the night scenes in the forest seem pretty on a tv, but may be overpoweringly magical on the big screen. There is bound to be some metaphoric payoff between the two halves, but the film was paced too slow for me to keep paying attention. I’d hit FF and then not be sure what speed the film was showing at, since the framing was so static. (MC-78.)
4-26-06: Trees Lounge. *6+* (1996, Sund/T, n.) As an actor, Steve Buscemi always infuses his characters with authenticity, humor, and pathos, and here he does the same as writer and director as well, in an apparently autobiographical story of life in a working-class dead-end town on Long Island, centered on the nondescript concrete-block bar of the title. He gathers a lot of friends and familiar (or not-so, or soon-to-be) faces to people the little community he depicts, from Chloe Sevigny to Samuel L Jackson. There’s no story as such, just a series of incidents that gradually fill in a group portrait. Nothing is underlined, but a picture emerges nonetheless. If you liked the book, The Tender Bar by J.R. Moehringer, you would like this film -- or vice versa. Both setting and sensibility are similar.
4-28-06: Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle. *6+* (2004, dvd, n.) Frankly I’ve been a bit wearied by my steady diet of good-for-you critical favorites, and craved a bit of junk food. As such, this was quite a tasty combo of gross-out humor and stoner comedy, with a special sauce of multiculty flavors. Danny Leiner is crude but effective in his direction of the appealing Korean-India duo of John Cho and Kal Penn, entry level financial analyst and reluctant med school applicant respectively, hardcore tokers both. An attack of the munchies sends them on a nightlong quest through the wilds of New Jersey. Of its kind, this buddy pic is about as good as it gets. (MC-63.)
Working that same vein, I took a look at the first disk of the only season of Undeclared, Judd Apatow’s follow up to the similarly beloved-but-cancelled TV series, Freaks & Geeks. I’ll definitely watch the rest. Though it is a half-hour sitcom rather than the latter’s hourlong multi-layered dramedy, it does advance a similar group of characters (and actors) from high school to the first year of college. This is shameless TV you can enjoy without shame.
While on the subject of highly watchable TV, let me give a big thumbs up to three HBO series I am currently enjoying immensely: the current seasons of The Sopranos and Big Love, and catching up with the second season of Deadwood, in anticipation of the third coming soon. With these and Bleak House and The Best of Youth, my favorite viewing these days is long-form, novelistic series.
4-29-06: Cafe Lumiere. *6* (2004, dvd, n.) Taiwanese director Hou Hsiao-Hsien offers this as a centenary tribute to Japanese director Yasijuro Ozu. There are recognizable elements of Ozu in this story of a young woman (played in low-key naturalistic style by Japanese pop idol Yo Hitoto) separating from her parents; maintaining distance from her closest friend, a bookseller with a passion for trains and a knowledge of Maurice Sendak; and refusing even to consider marrying the unseen boy in Taiwan who has gotten her pregnant. There are many transfixing shots of Tokyo trains, but it’s the interior shots that seem to refuse intimacy, that keep us fixed for prolonged periods at an awkward angle, unable to get close to the characters or even see their faces. There’s a slow tempo one has to adjust to in Ozu, but there’s also a directness, which is frustratingly absent in this film. It took me three tries to make it through.
4-9-06: Gunner Palace. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) Not as coherent as Occupation: Dreamland, but nearly as essential in coming to terms with just what American troops are being asked to do in Iraq. This film follows an artillery unit bivouacked in the half-wrecked palace of one of Saddam’s sons and going out on raids and patrol in Baghdad; it’s more exclusively from the perspective of the Americans than the other doc, but still it puts you there, where we so clearly should not be. (MC-70.)
4-10-06: Head-On (Gegen die Wand.) *7* (2004, Sund/T, n.) L’amour fou among Turkish emigres in Hamburg, Germany. Just like the lead actress, Sibell Kekilli, this film from young director Fatih Akin makes you ponder whether it is just interesting-looking or profoundly beautiful. Adrift between worlds, two attempted suicides meet cute in a mental institution. She latches onto him (Birol Unel) as the Turkish husband who will placate her traditional Islamic family, and in a platonic marriage of convenience allow her to continue her pursuit of sex, drugs, and rock’n’roll. Of course they fall in love, but nothing else about this film is pat or predictable. Its a sympathetic glimpse into strange but familiar lives, recommended if you’re willing to take the journey. (MC-78.)
4-11-06: Neil Young: Heart of Gold. *8* (2006, Images, n.) Shows what a concert film can be. Not just a record of a performance, but a visual narrative in its own right. Jonathan Demme already has Stop Making Sense under his belt, but this rivals Marty Scorsese and The Band’s Last Waltz for best rock film ever. I didn’t go in as a big Neil Young fan, though inevitably he is part of the soundtrack of my life, but he definitely made the sale with me, premiering his “Prairie Wind” album at the Ryman in Nashville, and then going on to reprise some of his more famous hits. Backed by his wife and Emmylou Harris, and a gang of old buddies, as well as horn and string and gospel choir sections, Neil Young gets across his straightforward but incantatory lyrics in an intimate and impassioned manner, with the camera perfectly framing his storytelling and preacherman ballads. Soul-stirring and completely satisfying. (MC-85.)
4-15-06: Paradise Now. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) While it is certainly worthwhile to get an even-handed Palestinian view from the West Bank, the mixture of elements in Hany Abu-Assad’s film do not quite cohere. There are some fascinating documentary street scenes, but more than anything this is a fairly glossy ticking-bomb thriller. Will they or won’t they? Two lifelong friends are selected for a suicide bombing mission; they are not wild-eyed religious fanatics but young men interested in women, hookah-smoking, and Arab pop music. One grew up in a refugee camp and feels the need to erase the family stain of his father’s collaboration with the Israelis. The other values the posthumous celebrity the mission may bring him, though his farewell videotape is comically bungled. But they both have plenty of room for second thoughts, and debates with a pretty young women on what options they have for responding to the continuous humiliation of occupation. Everything hangs in the balance till the very last frame, but ultimately we don’t come out understanding any more than we did going in. (MC-71.)
4-17-06: Kings and Queen. *6+* (2005, dvd, n.) I am partly won over by critical acclaim, partly by the appeal of the actors, and partly by director Arnaud Desplechin’s hommage to Truffaut in his dvd interview with Kent Jones, but watching this film was not for me the joy it is for many cinephiles. Its idiosyncracies did not speak to my own. Emmanuelle Devos and Mathieu Amalric lead a large and largely convincing cast, who seem believable even amidst the gaps and twists of the story. She’s a gallery owner, but is she at the mercy of, or merciless toward, men? He’s a musician tossed into the loony bin, but is he crazy or not? Once they were married, or at least together -- one dumped the other, but which? At any rate, she now wants him to adopt her son by a previous “husband” -- who may have killed himself, or she him? -- so she can marry a sugar daddy. Does her doe-eyed demeanor betoken fragile strength or carnivorous deceit? Are we to sympathize or recoil in horror? Laugh or cry? Truffaut or Hitchcock? The only truthful answer is all of the above. (MC-84.)
4-20-06: Code 46. *6-* (2004, dvd, n.) Filling out the prolific Michael Winterbottom filmography, this sci-fi romance about genetics is not as good as Andrew Nicoll’s Gattaca, but does conjure a plausible future out of contemporary Shanghai, Dubai, and India, well-suited to his on-the-fly filmmaking. Tim Robbins is palpably uncomfortable with such a guerrilla shoot, though Samantha Morton does get with the program. There is little chemistry between them, however, in this quasi-Oedipal drama. Code 46 is a regulation prohibiting incest in a world where cloning and in vitro reproduction are common. Turns out the woman he falls for is genetically identical to his mother. There’s “eternal sunshine” memory erasure, “empathy” viruses, and other futuristic apparatus, but the central love story does not grip. (MC-57.)
Last Days. *5* (2005, dvd, n.) You have to give Gus Van Sant credit for sticking to his guns. He’s definitely a filmmaker who follows through on his conception, whether inspired (Drugstore Cowboy, To Die For) or cuckoo (shot-by-shot remake of Psycho.) This follow-up to Elephant, his dreamy evocation of Columbine, quasi-documents in long shots and long takes the last days of Kurt Cobain in a decaying lakeside mansion. If you cared about Nirvana (and personally I couldn’t identify “Smells Like Teen Spirit” if you played the whole song for me), maybe you could fill in the state of mind of the protagonist as he drifts through slow and pointless scenes, albeit with a certain drugged loveliness to the cinematography and Michael Pitt’s performance. I note that Manohla Dargis of the NYTimes called this film “indisputably great” and it ranked #10 in Village Voice critics’ poll for 2005 -- but me, I hit the fast forward button to keep from falling asleep. (MC-67.)
4-23-06: Tropical Malady. *NR* (2004, dvd, n.) Here’s another film that defines my taste as not very highbrow, upper middlebrow at best. Thai filmmaker Apitchatpong Weerasethakul (who wisely goes by the name of Joe) takes us on a meandering path through fields, forests, and city streets, whose strangeness and beauty keep us watching through the slow and enigmatic twists of the tale. At first it seems like a rather sweet gay romance between a soldier and a country boy, who engage our interest; we want to see how their love goes. But then the film breaks, and the two actors reappear, the soldier the same but on patrol alone at night in the forest, and the boy become the wandering naked spirit of a tiger. The soldier stalks, sights, and finally confronts the tiger/boy. This may be a film that needs the immersive effect of watching on the big screen; the night scenes in the forest seem pretty on a tv, but may be overpoweringly magical on the big screen. There is bound to be some metaphoric payoff between the two halves, but the film was paced too slow for me to keep paying attention. I’d hit FF and then not be sure what speed the film was showing at, since the framing was so static. (MC-78.)
4-26-06: Trees Lounge. *6+* (1996, Sund/T, n.) As an actor, Steve Buscemi always infuses his characters with authenticity, humor, and pathos, and here he does the same as writer and director as well, in an apparently autobiographical story of life in a working-class dead-end town on Long Island, centered on the nondescript concrete-block bar of the title. He gathers a lot of friends and familiar (or not-so, or soon-to-be) faces to people the little community he depicts, from Chloe Sevigny to Samuel L Jackson. There’s no story as such, just a series of incidents that gradually fill in a group portrait. Nothing is underlined, but a picture emerges nonetheless. If you liked the book, The Tender Bar by J.R. Moehringer, you would like this film -- or vice versa. Both setting and sensibility are similar.
4-28-06: Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle. *6+* (2004, dvd, n.) Frankly I’ve been a bit wearied by my steady diet of good-for-you critical favorites, and craved a bit of junk food. As such, this was quite a tasty combo of gross-out humor and stoner comedy, with a special sauce of multiculty flavors. Danny Leiner is crude but effective in his direction of the appealing Korean-India duo of John Cho and Kal Penn, entry level financial analyst and reluctant med school applicant respectively, hardcore tokers both. An attack of the munchies sends them on a nightlong quest through the wilds of New Jersey. Of its kind, this buddy pic is about as good as it gets. (MC-63.)
Working that same vein, I took a look at the first disk of the only season of Undeclared, Judd Apatow’s follow up to the similarly beloved-but-cancelled TV series, Freaks & Geeks. I’ll definitely watch the rest. Though it is a half-hour sitcom rather than the latter’s hourlong multi-layered dramedy, it does advance a similar group of characters (and actors) from high school to the first year of college. This is shameless TV you can enjoy without shame.
While on the subject of highly watchable TV, let me give a big thumbs up to three HBO series I am currently enjoying immensely: the current seasons of The Sopranos and Big Love, and catching up with the second season of Deadwood, in anticipation of the third coming soon. With these and Bleak House and The Best of Youth, my favorite viewing these days is long-form, novelistic series.
4-29-06: Cafe Lumiere. *6* (2004, dvd, n.) Taiwanese director Hou Hsiao-Hsien offers this as a centenary tribute to Japanese director Yasijuro Ozu. There are recognizable elements of Ozu in this story of a young woman (played in low-key naturalistic style by Japanese pop idol Yo Hitoto) separating from her parents; maintaining distance from her closest friend, a bookseller with a passion for trains and a knowledge of Maurice Sendak; and refusing even to consider marrying the unseen boy in Taiwan who has gotten her pregnant. There are many transfixing shots of Tokyo trains, but it’s the interior shots that seem to refuse intimacy, that keep us fixed for prolonged periods at an awkward angle, unable to get close to the characters or even see their faces. There’s a slow tempo one has to adjust to in Ozu, but there’s also a directness, which is frustratingly absent in this film. It took me three tries to make it through.
Thursday, April 06, 2006
Dearest Reader
Perhaps you don’t exist. To judge by the response to my Tinkerbelle plea, no one reads this blog (or almost no one.) And if no one is reading it, I have to ask myself if there is any sense to my writing it.
Let me be less metaphoric -- I will resume Cinema Salon (and endeavor to enhance the service) when some number of people (at first I thought twenty, but the gratification of getting just one response makes me sure I could live with less) have identified themselves as readers by sending an email to: ssatullo@clarkart.edu. One word of confirmation (e.g. “Yes.”) is all that’s required, though comments and suggestions would be most welcome. Think of it as signing up for a free subscription to a film reviewing service. Rest assured that you won’t be signing up for more spam.
There’s no reason not to post my personal filmlog periodically, even if I am merely talking to myself, but if I get the sense that there is an actual readership for my observations on film, then I will endeavor to make Cinema Salon more reader-friendly.
Your humble scribe,
Steve
Let me be less metaphoric -- I will resume Cinema Salon (and endeavor to enhance the service) when some number of people (at first I thought twenty, but the gratification of getting just one response makes me sure I could live with less) have identified themselves as readers by sending an email to: ssatullo@clarkart.edu. One word of confirmation (e.g. “Yes.”) is all that’s required, though comments and suggestions would be most welcome. Think of it as signing up for a free subscription to a film reviewing service. Rest assured that you won’t be signing up for more spam.
There’s no reason not to post my personal filmlog periodically, even if I am merely talking to myself, but if I get the sense that there is an actual readership for my observations on film, then I will endeavor to make Cinema Salon more reader-friendly.
Your humble scribe,
Steve
Filmlog for March
Even without much response elicited by my appeal to readers, I will keep posting my filmlog, out of which this blog developed. It will be more a memoir to myself, rather than an attempt to tell you in capsule all you need to know about whether to see a film or not. (BTW, MC-score represents numerical consensus from metacritic.com) Here’s a sample:
3-7-06 Way We Laughed. *7-* (1998, dvd, n.) Gianni Amelio’s film does not have the amplitude or the warmth of The Best of Youth, but it covers some of the same ground. Two Sicilian brothers out of their element in Turin from 1958-64, caught ellipitically on six separate days within that span. Close-mouthed, they keep secrets from each other and from us. They -- and the film -- fail to connect despite deep connection. To appreciate this film, you need to forego traditional narrative satisfactions and resolutions. Everything happens in the gaps and under the surface. The surface, however, is quite handsome. (MC-63.)
3-9-06 Bamboozled. *6* (2000, dvd@cai, r.) As usual with Spike Lee -- too much. Almost all his films would be better 20-30 minutes shorter. The implicit history of the minstrel show and Negro caricature in popular culture is novel and multi-layered. But the satire is uncertain of tone, and when the bullets start to fly the movie goes off the rails. (MC-50.)
3-10-06 Oliver Twist. *6+* (2005, dvd, n.) Stately rather than Dickensian, Roman Polanski’s mounting of the familiar story is neither funny nor pathetic enough. Beautifully designed and shot, but emotionally inert. None of the characters pop off the screen. (MC-65.)
3-13-06 The World. *6+* (2004, dvd, n.) Jia Zhangke’s film has garnered international praise for the young Chinese director, but I found it slow and meandering, albeit full of interesting observation. Set in a Beijing theme park that recreates world sites in dwarf size -- Pyramids, Acropolis, St. Peter’s, London Bridge, Eiffel Tower, Manhattan skyline complete with Trade Towers, etc. etc. -- the film follows a group of provincials who have come to the big city to work as performers (and sometimes prostitutes), security guards, and construction labor. But far from being free and cosmopolitan, they are more trapped and isolated than in the countryside. This is a multifaceted look, incorporating wacky flights of animated fantasy, into the largely unknown world of modern mainland China, both insulated and globalized. The long-shot, long-take aesthetic probably requires a large screen to immerse oneself. More interesting to think about afterwards than to watch. (MC-81.)
3-15-06 Tristram Shandy: A Cock & Bull Story. *8+* (2006, Images, n.) After the misfire provocation of 9 Songs, Michael Winterbottom is back on form as one of my favorite younger directors. Wild and woolly, yet seamless in its rapidfire ricochet through time and levels of reality -- depicted, acted, “real” -- this remains an adaptation of both the spirit and the letter of the book, while also being a classic movie about the making of a movie, plus a backstage reality tv sit-com. Will bear repeat viewing on dvd, with subtitles a help to catch off-hand dialogue of overlapping British accents. Steve Coogan is great, as usual, but the whole cast of familiar and unfamiliar faces works beautifully together. (MC-80.)
3-17-06 My House in Umbria. *6-* (2003, HBO/T, n.) This HBO adaptation of a William Trevor novella was pleasant enough, what with the Italian locations and Maggie Smith’s performance in the central role, but skippable unless you’re a big fan of one or the other.
3-18-06 The Real Dirt on Farmer John. *7+* (2005, B-10, n.) Well put-together documentary on maverick Midwestern farmer who finally saves the family farm through Community Supported Agriculture. An obsessively filmed life leads to an effective film biography, which offers a cultural as well as a personal portrait, helps answer the question, “Whatever happened to the Sixties?” Post-film talk with folk from two Berkshire CSAs and responsive full-house audience at MassMoCA made this an excellent community event.
3-20-06 Occupation: Dreamland. *6+* (2005, Sund/T, n.) This intimate documentary from Ian Olds and Garrett Scott follows a squad of 82nd Airborne, as they try to subdue Fallujah in early 2004. It gives you a real “you are there” feeling, even if you don’t want to be there. Fleshes out just what the word “occupation” means. Demonstrates implicitly that the only way to support our troops is to bring them home.
3-21-06 Cache (Hidden.) *8* (2005, Images, n.) Puts the viewer through Hitchcockian paces, but not at Hitchcock’s pace. Very European, very intellectual, with long, long shots that force you to think about what you are looking at. And if you like your psychological thrillers tied up at the end, forget about it. The last lingering shot of the film is a touchstone: for some it offers the final piece of the puzzle and the picture clicks into place; some cannot even see the action taking place in a distant crowd; me, I saw it but couldn’t figure what it meant. Like much in this film, you are not meant to “get it,” in the sense of having certain knowledge or an easy explanation. Michael Haneke’s frequent gruesomeness is pared down to a single instant of shocking violence, though terror permeates all. Daniel Auteuil and Juliet Binoche are a perfect Parisian bobo couple -- he has a popular book show on public tv and she works for a publisher -- but their complacent, slightly paunchy existence is disrupted by receipt of mysterious videotapes that reveal they are under constant surveillance. The stress fissures their relationship and reveals faultlines buried beneath the surface and in the past. Despite some very slow stretches, the film is riveting, and offers lots to think about. I’d put it in a category with The Vanishing and With a Friend Like Harry, highbrow gothic from the EU. (MC-83.)
3-23-06 The Son’s Room. *8+* (2001, dvd@cai, r.) Nanni Moretti directs and stars as a psychoanalyst who experiences a family tragedy. Chastely heartbreaking, this film stands up well on second viewing. Overwhelmingly sad, it is still understated and funny withal, precisely observed and psychologically acute. (MC-73.)
Reconstruction. *6* (2003, Sund/T, n.) A decent Danish mindtwister from Christoffer Boe, this is an overtly constructed and deconstructed romance about a man who loses his way between two women, played by the same striking actress (Maria Bonnevie.) Stylish -- with neon colors, deep shadows, intense two-shots with lots of swirling smoke -- this film has its Dogme elements, but is most reminiscent of Wong Kar-Wai’s In the Mood for Love. (MC-60.)
3-24-06 The 40-Year-Old Virgin. *7* (2005, dvd, n.) Manages to mix raunchy humor with a sweet spirit and some genuine wit, under the hand of Freaks & Geeks (see it on dvd!!!) alum Judd Apatow. Steve Carrell is surprisingly good as the title character, and Catherine Keener is reliably engaging as the “hot grandma” he falls for. The gang of guys is fun too, and even the women are a bit more than caricatures. Way, way better in every respect than The Wedding Crashers in the adult comedy category, though not the “Best Picture” candidate some made it out to be.
3-25-06 A History of Violence. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) Not as bad as with Munich, but I had with this film the same refusal to suspend disbelief. Despite the surface plausibility and filmmaking skill on view, I kept seeing this as the comic book it originally was. Viggo Mortenson infuses the film with some humanity, and frankly, Maria Bello can dress up in a cheerleader costume for me anytime. Ed Harris is excellent as usual, especially in the best, scariest scene in the movie, when the hitman takes an avuncular interest in the little girl at the mall. No guns, no bloodshed, just palpable terror. William Hurt has a few minutes of fun as the mob boss, brother to Viggo, who has escaped his feral Philly past into small-town Indiana rectitude. And right there, let me note the sort of detail that threw me right out of this film -- I can assure you that there is no roadsign in the Indianapolis vicinity that says “Philadelphia: 680 miles.” David Cronenberg is famously explicit with his gore, the violence meant to be antidote but actually more anodyne. He may make it genuinely ugly, but he’s still making it entertainment. And I’m not buying it. Despite it’s #1 rank in Village Voice critics’ poll best of 2005. (MC-81.)
3-26-06 Through the Fire. *7-* (2006, ESPN/T, n.) Though not nearly as deep or as broad, Jonathan Hock’s documentary plays as a worthy sequel to Hoop Dreams. What is lost in the whole family and community context is made up in hardcore game action, as we follow Coney Island schoolboy phenom Sebastian Telfair through his senior year, in pursuit of a third straight NYC championship and in a quandary over whether to go to Louisville or enter the NBA draft. An Isaiah-sized guard who slices through defenses like a hot knife through butter, Sebastian has the telegenic smile and carefully-groomed demeanor to make himself a marketable commodity, which along with his undeniable hoop skill gets him on the cover of SI, and a shoe contract that negates his college prospects and puts him at the mercy of the draft. The film hardly questions the system or ethos of professional sports, but within its limits offers an honest portrayal of one of those mythic escapes from the projects that fuel the dreams of so many. (MC-64.)
3-28-06 The Wild Parrots of Telegraph Hill. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) This pleasant, if light as a feather, documentary, well-shot by Judy Irving, focuses on a San Franciscan flock of birds and the long-haired fellow who feeds and observes them. The birdman opposite Alcatraz, as it were. The film goes on some amusing and appealing flights of ornithological fantasy, but the parrots are not quite as anthropomorphized as the penguins on their march. On the other hand, there’s not much of a story line, just Mark Bittner’s observations, visual and verbal. The cute ending is a bit of a cheat, coming out of the blue. A better film would have foreshadowed it. (MC-80.)
3-29-06 The Shape of Things. *5* (2003, dvd, n.) Like Closer, this is another four-hander making the transition from stage to screen, only to be seen through, revealed as hollow. Neil LaBute adapts his own play, and the actors follow. Something with Rachel Weisz, Paul Rudd, and Gretchen Mol should have been better, but this story is contrived and shallow and the final switcheroo painful, but not in the way intended. (MC-59.)
3-30-06 Why We Fight. *7* (2006, Images, n.) I can hardly call this a convincing documentary because I was convinced going in. But unlike Michael Moore, Eugene Jarecki assembles his case judiciously, allowing alternate voices their say, even while montage and music make his points. Let Richard Perle be condemned out of his own mouth, rather than ridiculing Paul Wolfowitz because he puts his comb in his mouth. Somewhat scattershot in its argument, the film is well-grounded in President Eisenhower’s farewell speech, warning against the power of the “military-industrial complex.” This from a 5-star general and Republican president! With a tip of the cap to Frank Capra’s WWII documentary series of the same name, this film interweaves graphic and archival history, contemporary reporting (a military trade show in particular), and interview testimony from participants and commentators. I have to agree with its premise that we are in the business of war because war is good business. That is almost as good an explanation as oil, or maybe the same explanation, for why we are in Iraq. (MC-68.)
3-31-06 The Beat My Heart Skipped. *6+* (2005, dvd, n.) Jacques Audiard is apparently a coming French director, critically acclaimed, but this noirish remake of Fingers is his most commercial feature yet, and certainly the first I’ve seen. I will look further, but this one did not grab me. Highly watchable, but not something in which I would invest belief or emotion. Romain Duris follows his father’s trade of thuggish real estate transactions, but longs to follow his dead mother as a concert pianist. There’s a succession of alluring young women, a taxonomy of feminine appeal, but as usual, when the everyday low-grade violence turns to cinematic splatter, I begin to tune out. (MC-75.)
3-7-06 Way We Laughed. *7-* (1998, dvd, n.) Gianni Amelio’s film does not have the amplitude or the warmth of The Best of Youth, but it covers some of the same ground. Two Sicilian brothers out of their element in Turin from 1958-64, caught ellipitically on six separate days within that span. Close-mouthed, they keep secrets from each other and from us. They -- and the film -- fail to connect despite deep connection. To appreciate this film, you need to forego traditional narrative satisfactions and resolutions. Everything happens in the gaps and under the surface. The surface, however, is quite handsome. (MC-63.)
3-9-06 Bamboozled. *6* (2000, dvd@cai, r.) As usual with Spike Lee -- too much. Almost all his films would be better 20-30 minutes shorter. The implicit history of the minstrel show and Negro caricature in popular culture is novel and multi-layered. But the satire is uncertain of tone, and when the bullets start to fly the movie goes off the rails. (MC-50.)
3-10-06 Oliver Twist. *6+* (2005, dvd, n.) Stately rather than Dickensian, Roman Polanski’s mounting of the familiar story is neither funny nor pathetic enough. Beautifully designed and shot, but emotionally inert. None of the characters pop off the screen. (MC-65.)
3-13-06 The World. *6+* (2004, dvd, n.) Jia Zhangke’s film has garnered international praise for the young Chinese director, but I found it slow and meandering, albeit full of interesting observation. Set in a Beijing theme park that recreates world sites in dwarf size -- Pyramids, Acropolis, St. Peter’s, London Bridge, Eiffel Tower, Manhattan skyline complete with Trade Towers, etc. etc. -- the film follows a group of provincials who have come to the big city to work as performers (and sometimes prostitutes), security guards, and construction labor. But far from being free and cosmopolitan, they are more trapped and isolated than in the countryside. This is a multifaceted look, incorporating wacky flights of animated fantasy, into the largely unknown world of modern mainland China, both insulated and globalized. The long-shot, long-take aesthetic probably requires a large screen to immerse oneself. More interesting to think about afterwards than to watch. (MC-81.)
3-15-06 Tristram Shandy: A Cock & Bull Story. *8+* (2006, Images, n.) After the misfire provocation of 9 Songs, Michael Winterbottom is back on form as one of my favorite younger directors. Wild and woolly, yet seamless in its rapidfire ricochet through time and levels of reality -- depicted, acted, “real” -- this remains an adaptation of both the spirit and the letter of the book, while also being a classic movie about the making of a movie, plus a backstage reality tv sit-com. Will bear repeat viewing on dvd, with subtitles a help to catch off-hand dialogue of overlapping British accents. Steve Coogan is great, as usual, but the whole cast of familiar and unfamiliar faces works beautifully together. (MC-80.)
3-17-06 My House in Umbria. *6-* (2003, HBO/T, n.) This HBO adaptation of a William Trevor novella was pleasant enough, what with the Italian locations and Maggie Smith’s performance in the central role, but skippable unless you’re a big fan of one or the other.
3-18-06 The Real Dirt on Farmer John. *7+* (2005, B-10, n.) Well put-together documentary on maverick Midwestern farmer who finally saves the family farm through Community Supported Agriculture. An obsessively filmed life leads to an effective film biography, which offers a cultural as well as a personal portrait, helps answer the question, “Whatever happened to the Sixties?” Post-film talk with folk from two Berkshire CSAs and responsive full-house audience at MassMoCA made this an excellent community event.
3-20-06 Occupation: Dreamland. *6+* (2005, Sund/T, n.) This intimate documentary from Ian Olds and Garrett Scott follows a squad of 82nd Airborne, as they try to subdue Fallujah in early 2004. It gives you a real “you are there” feeling, even if you don’t want to be there. Fleshes out just what the word “occupation” means. Demonstrates implicitly that the only way to support our troops is to bring them home.
3-21-06 Cache (Hidden.) *8* (2005, Images, n.) Puts the viewer through Hitchcockian paces, but not at Hitchcock’s pace. Very European, very intellectual, with long, long shots that force you to think about what you are looking at. And if you like your psychological thrillers tied up at the end, forget about it. The last lingering shot of the film is a touchstone: for some it offers the final piece of the puzzle and the picture clicks into place; some cannot even see the action taking place in a distant crowd; me, I saw it but couldn’t figure what it meant. Like much in this film, you are not meant to “get it,” in the sense of having certain knowledge or an easy explanation. Michael Haneke’s frequent gruesomeness is pared down to a single instant of shocking violence, though terror permeates all. Daniel Auteuil and Juliet Binoche are a perfect Parisian bobo couple -- he has a popular book show on public tv and she works for a publisher -- but their complacent, slightly paunchy existence is disrupted by receipt of mysterious videotapes that reveal they are under constant surveillance. The stress fissures their relationship and reveals faultlines buried beneath the surface and in the past. Despite some very slow stretches, the film is riveting, and offers lots to think about. I’d put it in a category with The Vanishing and With a Friend Like Harry, highbrow gothic from the EU. (MC-83.)
3-23-06 The Son’s Room. *8+* (2001, dvd@cai, r.) Nanni Moretti directs and stars as a psychoanalyst who experiences a family tragedy. Chastely heartbreaking, this film stands up well on second viewing. Overwhelmingly sad, it is still understated and funny withal, precisely observed and psychologically acute. (MC-73.)
Reconstruction. *6* (2003, Sund/T, n.) A decent Danish mindtwister from Christoffer Boe, this is an overtly constructed and deconstructed romance about a man who loses his way between two women, played by the same striking actress (Maria Bonnevie.) Stylish -- with neon colors, deep shadows, intense two-shots with lots of swirling smoke -- this film has its Dogme elements, but is most reminiscent of Wong Kar-Wai’s In the Mood for Love. (MC-60.)
3-24-06 The 40-Year-Old Virgin. *7* (2005, dvd, n.) Manages to mix raunchy humor with a sweet spirit and some genuine wit, under the hand of Freaks & Geeks (see it on dvd!!!) alum Judd Apatow. Steve Carrell is surprisingly good as the title character, and Catherine Keener is reliably engaging as the “hot grandma” he falls for. The gang of guys is fun too, and even the women are a bit more than caricatures. Way, way better in every respect than The Wedding Crashers in the adult comedy category, though not the “Best Picture” candidate some made it out to be.
3-25-06 A History of Violence. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) Not as bad as with Munich, but I had with this film the same refusal to suspend disbelief. Despite the surface plausibility and filmmaking skill on view, I kept seeing this as the comic book it originally was. Viggo Mortenson infuses the film with some humanity, and frankly, Maria Bello can dress up in a cheerleader costume for me anytime. Ed Harris is excellent as usual, especially in the best, scariest scene in the movie, when the hitman takes an avuncular interest in the little girl at the mall. No guns, no bloodshed, just palpable terror. William Hurt has a few minutes of fun as the mob boss, brother to Viggo, who has escaped his feral Philly past into small-town Indiana rectitude. And right there, let me note the sort of detail that threw me right out of this film -- I can assure you that there is no roadsign in the Indianapolis vicinity that says “Philadelphia: 680 miles.” David Cronenberg is famously explicit with his gore, the violence meant to be antidote but actually more anodyne. He may make it genuinely ugly, but he’s still making it entertainment. And I’m not buying it. Despite it’s #1 rank in Village Voice critics’ poll best of 2005. (MC-81.)
3-26-06 Through the Fire. *7-* (2006, ESPN/T, n.) Though not nearly as deep or as broad, Jonathan Hock’s documentary plays as a worthy sequel to Hoop Dreams. What is lost in the whole family and community context is made up in hardcore game action, as we follow Coney Island schoolboy phenom Sebastian Telfair through his senior year, in pursuit of a third straight NYC championship and in a quandary over whether to go to Louisville or enter the NBA draft. An Isaiah-sized guard who slices through defenses like a hot knife through butter, Sebastian has the telegenic smile and carefully-groomed demeanor to make himself a marketable commodity, which along with his undeniable hoop skill gets him on the cover of SI, and a shoe contract that negates his college prospects and puts him at the mercy of the draft. The film hardly questions the system or ethos of professional sports, but within its limits offers an honest portrayal of one of those mythic escapes from the projects that fuel the dreams of so many. (MC-64.)
3-28-06 The Wild Parrots of Telegraph Hill. *6* (2005, dvd, n.) This pleasant, if light as a feather, documentary, well-shot by Judy Irving, focuses on a San Franciscan flock of birds and the long-haired fellow who feeds and observes them. The birdman opposite Alcatraz, as it were. The film goes on some amusing and appealing flights of ornithological fantasy, but the parrots are not quite as anthropomorphized as the penguins on their march. On the other hand, there’s not much of a story line, just Mark Bittner’s observations, visual and verbal. The cute ending is a bit of a cheat, coming out of the blue. A better film would have foreshadowed it. (MC-80.)
3-29-06 The Shape of Things. *5* (2003, dvd, n.) Like Closer, this is another four-hander making the transition from stage to screen, only to be seen through, revealed as hollow. Neil LaBute adapts his own play, and the actors follow. Something with Rachel Weisz, Paul Rudd, and Gretchen Mol should have been better, but this story is contrived and shallow and the final switcheroo painful, but not in the way intended. (MC-59.)
3-30-06 Why We Fight. *7* (2006, Images, n.) I can hardly call this a convincing documentary because I was convinced going in. But unlike Michael Moore, Eugene Jarecki assembles his case judiciously, allowing alternate voices their say, even while montage and music make his points. Let Richard Perle be condemned out of his own mouth, rather than ridiculing Paul Wolfowitz because he puts his comb in his mouth. Somewhat scattershot in its argument, the film is well-grounded in President Eisenhower’s farewell speech, warning against the power of the “military-industrial complex.” This from a 5-star general and Republican president! With a tip of the cap to Frank Capra’s WWII documentary series of the same name, this film interweaves graphic and archival history, contemporary reporting (a military trade show in particular), and interview testimony from participants and commentators. I have to agree with its premise that we are in the business of war because war is good business. That is almost as good an explanation as oil, or maybe the same explanation, for why we are in Iraq. (MC-68.)
3-31-06 The Beat My Heart Skipped. *6+* (2005, dvd, n.) Jacques Audiard is apparently a coming French director, critically acclaimed, but this noirish remake of Fingers is his most commercial feature yet, and certainly the first I’ve seen. I will look further, but this one did not grab me. Highly watchable, but not something in which I would invest belief or emotion. Romain Duris follows his father’s trade of thuggish real estate transactions, but longs to follow his dead mother as a concert pianist. There’s a succession of alluring young women, a taxonomy of feminine appeal, but as usual, when the everyday low-grade violence turns to cinematic splatter, I begin to tune out. (MC-75.)
Wednesday, March 22, 2006
Animation marathon at the Clark 3/26
TRIPLE FEATURE: 3 STUDIOS
Animation Festival at the Clark on Sunday, March 26th
11:00 am: NATIONAL FILM BOARD OF CANADA
Boogie-Doodle. 3 min. 1940. Norman McLaren begins by drawing directly on to film.
Begone Dull Care. 4 min. excerpt. 1949. Same idea carried further, to Oscar Peterson piano.
Neighbors. 8 min. 1952, AA-win. Famous for innovation of live-action pixillation.
Mosaic. 6 min. 1965. The culmination of Lines-Vertical and Lines-Horizontal.
Pas de Deux. 14 min. 1967. Stop-motion ballet in b&w outline -- acclaimed masterpiece.
Synchromy. 8 min. 1971. Brilliantly colored summation of visualized sound -- an optical joyride.
Mindscape. 8 min. 1976. Jacques Drouin’s pinscreen animation enters the artist’s mind.
Log Driver’s Waltz. 3 min. 1979. John Weldon animates a rollicking song by Kate & Anna McGarrigle.
The Sweater. 11min. 1980. Sheldon Cohen on a boy’s Rocket Richard jersey. It’s Canadien, eh?
The Street. 16 min. 1976, AA-nom. Caroline Leaf’s ink-on-glass version of Mordicai Richler story.
The Sand Castle. 13 min. 1977, AA-win. Co Hoedeman gives sand a life of its own.
Every Child. 6 min. 1979, AA-win. Eugene Fedorenko for UNICEF on children’s rights.
Blackfly. 5 min. 1991, AA-nom. Christopher Hinton’s hilarious musical take on a Northwoods bane.
Special Delivery. 7 min. 1978, AA-win. John Weldon in NFBC vein of sardonic adult humor.
The Bead Game. 6 min. 1977, AA-nom. Ishu Patel begins with single cell and ends with a bang.
1:30 pm: AARDMAN ANIMATION
Creature Comforts. 6 min. 1989, AA-win. Vox pop interviews put in the mouths of zoo animals.
Wat’s Pig. 11 min. 1996. “The Prince & the Pauper” re-told in claymation.
A Grand Day Out. 23 min. 1989, AA-nom. Nick Park’s student film is first Wallace & Gromit short.
The Wrong Trousers. 29 min. 1993, AA-win. Wallace taken in by criminal penguin, saved by Gromit.
A Close Shave. 30 min. 1995, AA-win. W & G solve sheep rustling scheme, save Wendolene.
Creature Comforts. 2003-to date. Telly programme sequel -- will show several 10-minute episodes.
4:00 pm: HUBLEY STUDIOS
Moonbird. 10 min. 1959, AA-win. John & Faith visualize imaginary quest of their two sons.
Windy Day. 9 min. 1967, AA-nom. They animate a conversation between their two daughters.
People, People, People. 5 min. 1975. The population explosion over 20,000 years.
W.O.W. (Women of the World). 10 min. 1975. Faith’s own historical and global view of feminism.
Who Am I? 4 min. 1989. Discovery of the five senses for Children’s Museum of Manhattan.
The Hole. 15 min. 1962, AA-win. Two construction workers debate nuclear war.
Of Men and Demons. 10 min. 1968, AA-nom. Mankind’s long struggle with nature and machines.
Voyage to Next. 10 min. 1974, AA-nom. Maureen Stapleton and Dizzy Gillespie riff verbally.
Cockabooty. 9 min. 1973. Emily & Georgia fantasize as toddlers; their parents spin the visuals.
Seers and Clowns. 9 min. 1994. Faith channels Klee & Miro in her survey of spiritual guides.
Origin of Love. 5 min. 2001. Emily’s animation of Platonic myth from Hedwig & the Angry Inch.
Everybody Rides the Carousel. 1976. Excepts from feature-length explication of Erik Erikson.
Doonesbury Special. 26 min. 1977, AA-win. John’s final film, tv adaptation of Gary Trudeau’s strip.
Animation Festival at the Clark on Sunday, March 26th
11:00 am: NATIONAL FILM BOARD OF CANADA
Boogie-Doodle. 3 min. 1940. Norman McLaren begins by drawing directly on to film.
Begone Dull Care. 4 min. excerpt. 1949. Same idea carried further, to Oscar Peterson piano.
Neighbors. 8 min. 1952, AA-win. Famous for innovation of live-action pixillation.
Mosaic. 6 min. 1965. The culmination of Lines-Vertical and Lines-Horizontal.
Pas de Deux. 14 min. 1967. Stop-motion ballet in b&w outline -- acclaimed masterpiece.
Synchromy. 8 min. 1971. Brilliantly colored summation of visualized sound -- an optical joyride.
Mindscape. 8 min. 1976. Jacques Drouin’s pinscreen animation enters the artist’s mind.
Log Driver’s Waltz. 3 min. 1979. John Weldon animates a rollicking song by Kate & Anna McGarrigle.
The Sweater. 11min. 1980. Sheldon Cohen on a boy’s Rocket Richard jersey. It’s Canadien, eh?
The Street. 16 min. 1976, AA-nom. Caroline Leaf’s ink-on-glass version of Mordicai Richler story.
The Sand Castle. 13 min. 1977, AA-win. Co Hoedeman gives sand a life of its own.
Every Child. 6 min. 1979, AA-win. Eugene Fedorenko for UNICEF on children’s rights.
Blackfly. 5 min. 1991, AA-nom. Christopher Hinton’s hilarious musical take on a Northwoods bane.
Special Delivery. 7 min. 1978, AA-win. John Weldon in NFBC vein of sardonic adult humor.
The Bead Game. 6 min. 1977, AA-nom. Ishu Patel begins with single cell and ends with a bang.
1:30 pm: AARDMAN ANIMATION
Creature Comforts. 6 min. 1989, AA-win. Vox pop interviews put in the mouths of zoo animals.
Wat’s Pig. 11 min. 1996. “The Prince & the Pauper” re-told in claymation.
A Grand Day Out. 23 min. 1989, AA-nom. Nick Park’s student film is first Wallace & Gromit short.
The Wrong Trousers. 29 min. 1993, AA-win. Wallace taken in by criminal penguin, saved by Gromit.
A Close Shave. 30 min. 1995, AA-win. W & G solve sheep rustling scheme, save Wendolene.
Creature Comforts. 2003-to date. Telly programme sequel -- will show several 10-minute episodes.
4:00 pm: HUBLEY STUDIOS
Moonbird. 10 min. 1959, AA-win. John & Faith visualize imaginary quest of their two sons.
Windy Day. 9 min. 1967, AA-nom. They animate a conversation between their two daughters.
People, People, People. 5 min. 1975. The population explosion over 20,000 years.
W.O.W. (Women of the World). 10 min. 1975. Faith’s own historical and global view of feminism.
Who Am I? 4 min. 1989. Discovery of the five senses for Children’s Museum of Manhattan.
The Hole. 15 min. 1962, AA-win. Two construction workers debate nuclear war.
Of Men and Demons. 10 min. 1968, AA-nom. Mankind’s long struggle with nature and machines.
Voyage to Next. 10 min. 1974, AA-nom. Maureen Stapleton and Dizzy Gillespie riff verbally.
Cockabooty. 9 min. 1973. Emily & Georgia fantasize as toddlers; their parents spin the visuals.
Seers and Clowns. 9 min. 1994. Faith channels Klee & Miro in her survey of spiritual guides.
Origin of Love. 5 min. 2001. Emily’s animation of Platonic myth from Hedwig & the Angry Inch.
Everybody Rides the Carousel. 1976. Excepts from feature-length explication of Erik Erikson.
Doonesbury Special. 26 min. 1977, AA-win. John’s final film, tv adaptation of Gary Trudeau’s strip.
Tuesday, March 07, 2006
Dear Reader
Cinema Salon will be on hiatus for a while, except for posting of exact schedule of “Triple Feature: 3 Studios,” an all-day festival of animation to be presented at the Clark on Sunday, March 26. The specifics of this marathon of award-winning shorts from the National Film Board of Canada, Aardman Animation, and Hubley Studios will be posted the week before the event.
I named this site with the notion that it would be a place of discussion, but it has become a monologue. I may be muttering mainly to myself. The comment feature attracted mostly spam, so I had to disable it. Thus I have no idea who my readers may be and what their responses might be, whether I ought to continue the service or save my breath. Should I just shut up, or take a different approach?
So this, dear insubstantial reader, is your Peter Pan moment: if you believe in fairies, you can keep Tinkerbell alive by clapping. I don’t even mind if the clapping is derisive, but I have to hear from you. Please send an e-mail message to ssatullo@clarkart.edu with the simple statement, “I read this blog a) regularly, b) occasionally, or c) rarely.” Feel free to add any other response or recommendation.
I named this site with the notion that it would be a place of discussion, but it has become a monologue. I may be muttering mainly to myself. The comment feature attracted mostly spam, so I had to disable it. Thus I have no idea who my readers may be and what their responses might be, whether I ought to continue the service or save my breath. Should I just shut up, or take a different approach?
So this, dear insubstantial reader, is your Peter Pan moment: if you believe in fairies, you can keep Tinkerbell alive by clapping. I don’t even mind if the clapping is derisive, but I have to hear from you. Please send an e-mail message to ssatullo@clarkart.edu with the simple statement, “I read this blog a) regularly, b) occasionally, or c) rarely.” Feel free to add any other response or recommendation.
Wrapping up
I am getting out of the habit of blogging, but the day after the Academy Awards seems an opportune moment to wrap up. I watched much more of the awards program than I would normally do, for three reasons: Jon Stewart was host, I’d uncharacteristically seen all the nominated films, and most important, I had TiVo to fast forward through commercials, thank you speeches, and excruciating performances. Turns out Jon was miscast as ringmaster of this scripted orgy of self-congratulation (at least he pointed out how lame the montages were -- except for the gay cowboy pastiche -- and the nominee attack ads brought some NY snark to the proceedings, though they seemed notably out of tune with the proceedings.) Hollywood came across as an amazingly insular community, and this a very tiny event when compared to the insane hype that precedes it, raising the betting stakes to a Super Bowl or Final Four frenzy. The bright spot of the evening was definitely Lily & Meryl’s intro to Altman special Oscar.
Crash for Best Picture was the most arguable of the winners, but it was easy to figure how it appealed to Academy voters, and each film (except the utterly unworthy Munich) received a token award or two: Lee, Hoffman, Witherspoon, Clooney. I began my *7-* review of Crash thus: “Too schematic and artsy, too eager to sell its message, this is nonetheless a well-made film on an essential American subject” (see September 2005 Archives.) I rate it on a par with Pride & Prejudice and Hustle & Flow.
None of my own top choices for best film of 2005 was even nominated. At the top of my list, along with several other critics’, was The Best of Youth, which as an Italian tv series belatedly released in the U.S. as a 6-hour film was probably disqualified on multiple counts. The Squid and the Whale would have been my pick of eligible films, with Brokeback Mountain belatedly joining Walk the Line and Syriana in the runner-up group. If Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room is exiled to the documentary catergory, The Constant Gardener might sneak into the best five domestic films, just edging Good Night, and Good Luck. In the same *7+* rank with the latter were two small but delightful films, Junebug and My Summer of Love; also several documentaries slightly better than the Oscar-winning March of the Penguins, including Grizzly Man and Mad Hot Ballroom; plus the animation winner Wallace & Gromit. I thought Capote was worth watching, but more on the *6+* out-of-the-running level of something like Mysterious Skin.
The only Hollywood contender I haven’t seen yet is A History of Violence, which arrives on dvd next Tuesday. There are a number of foreign films that have gotten Top Ten rankings from scattered critics, which I will be catching up with over the next month or two, but even at this I think it’s fair to say that 2005 wasn’t a bad year for films, as long as you were willing to look beyond the mainstream.
Of course I’m way behind on my ratings here, for whatever they may be worth, so I’ll offer a few brief observations in descending order of my recommendation:
Moolaade. (2004) *8* (MC-91) It’s mean to top the list with a film you have very little chance of seeing, not on dvd and not coming to a theater near you, but I was in a lucky group that saw this at Images Cinema, courtesy of the collaboratively-supported series, “Beyond the Femme Fatale: Leading Women in French and Francophone Film.” It is by the 81-year-old Senegalese director Ousmane Sembene, and I will definitely be looking further into his oeuvre. You are transported to a different world, right into a remote West African village, a deeply traditional society experiencing the first incursions of modernity. While retaining a documentary realism, the film has the quality of a beautiful folk tale, in its elemental struggles and pageant-like set-pieces. One strong woman stands up against the patriarchal practice of female genital mutilation, taking in four girls who have escaped from the ritual of “purification” because they did not want to be cut, and offering them “moolaade” or sanctuary. And the whole structure of the society starts to tremble and fall, with dynamics recognizable in any society, and well-rounded characters also recognizable across cultural divides. This film will give you a new perspective on the world, and a richer appreciation of just what’s at stake in the world’s passage from tribalism to globalism. Hard to imagine, but here the final shot of a television aerial is an image of hope.
Brokeback Mountain. (2005) *8* (MC-87) When I finally caught up with this much-discussed film last week, my companion and I were the only two people in the theater, a quasi-private screening. I’m glad it hung around long enough for me to see it on the big screen. By now you’ve heard all you need to about this film, but personally I liked it a lot, would certainly have picked it out of given Oscar noms. For me the only thing lacking for an absolute rave was the failure to capture the moment when Jack and Ennis fall in love, though the Rocky Mountain landscape makes an effective “objective correlative” (is that obscure Eliotic phrase still in academic circulation?)
Deadwood. (2004) *8-* Quite a different view of the West. I've finished the first season of this HBO series on dvd, and now I’m sufficiently hooked to be TiVo-ing the whole second season in anticipation of the upcoming third. No surprise really, since it’s the brainchild of David Milch, co-creator of NYPD Blue, which for years was the only network series I watched. This portrait of an outlaw town growing up from scratch around a gold strike is reminiscent of Robert Altman’s masterpiece, McCabe and Mrs. Miller, though much raunchier. The unremitting obscenity, the squalid sex and violence, are justified on grounds of historical accuracy, but take some getting used to. Many will not want to get used to it, but for those who do, that long-form magic will take hold. You will be part of this frontier community, familiar with all the characters, and eager to see what damned thing will happen next. But you’ve got to start from the beginning and give yourself four hours or so to get the hang of the neighborhood. For once a slogan has meaning: it’s not tv, it’s HBO. For me, this joins Rome in the pantheon of series, just below The Wire and The Sopranos. And Six Feet Under, before it wore out its welcome.
Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit. (2005) *7+* (MC-87) Who doesn’t love Wallace and Gromit, just awarded the Oscar for animated feature? I’m showing the three preceding W & G shorts in an animation festival at the Clark on Sunday, March 26 (check this space later for exact schedule.) But I have to admit I got drowsy in the middle of this film, which may have been that beer with dinner or it may have been some stretching of the material, tempo as well as plasticine. Still, cracking good cheese.
Nine Lives. (2005) *7* (MC-80) This no-budget indie shares several qualities with Crash but does more with less. Writer-director Rodrigo Garcia is the son of Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Maybe that helped him line up an A-list of actresses working for minimum scale, or maybe it was the appeal to theater people of spending one day of rehearsal and blocking and one day of shooting single 11-14 minute Steadicam takes of well-written domestic drama. Robin Wright Penn, Sissy Spacek, Holly Hunter, Molly Parker, Glenn Close, et al. -- how could a film with such a cast not break through to public recognition? Well, to be honest, it’s work to watch -- but very rewarding work. You have to pay close attention while each scene unfolds in real time, and then you have to start over again with new characters and a new situation. It’s like reading a book of short stories straight through; requires a different sort of attention than sinking into a novel. All the story lines do not collide as they do conveniently in Crash, but there is some overlap. This matches up nicely with Personal Velocity as an interesting depiction of contemporary women’s lives in multiple.
Pleasantville. (1998) *7-* (MC-71) Another matched pair, this with The Truman Show. The technical conceit of having color invade the world of a Fifties b&w tv sitcom is nice handled, but is barely skin deep. Gary Ross’s first effort as writer-director is a pleasant trifle. Reese Witherspoon and Tobey Maguire show promise of stardom to come, as contemporary teenagers transported into an oldie tv world. Joan Allen and William Macy lend their usual effective support as the tv parents. But this film is not up to the standard of Back to the Future or Peggy Sue Got Married.
8 Women. (2001) *5+* (MC-64) Twice I tried to watch Netflix disks that proved defective, and then I couldn’t make it when this film led off the “Beyond the Femme Fatale” series at Images. Then I saw the dvd while browsing in the college library, and took it out. I needn’t have gone to the effort. Francois Ozon’s confection was not to my taste, just too arch, too little attached to any reality whatsoever. It’s a Christie-like country house mystery, with an astounding line-up of great French actresses from Darrieux and Deneuve to Beart and Ledoyen, put to the task of sheer silliness.
I had disappointing audiences for my “Triple Feature: 3 Painters” program at the Clark, but take the opportunity to remind local residents that dvds shown at the Clark are subsequently available for borrowing from the Milne Public Library in Williamstown. For me Artemisia seemed even better on second look, once you get past the undenial bodice-ripping aspect and quibbles about biographical accuracy. Carrington (with Emma Thompson and Jonathan Pryce) and Pollock (with Ed Harris and Marcia Gay Harden) remain well worth seeing if you haven’t already done so.
Crash for Best Picture was the most arguable of the winners, but it was easy to figure how it appealed to Academy voters, and each film (except the utterly unworthy Munich) received a token award or two: Lee, Hoffman, Witherspoon, Clooney. I began my *7-* review of Crash thus: “Too schematic and artsy, too eager to sell its message, this is nonetheless a well-made film on an essential American subject” (see September 2005 Archives.) I rate it on a par with Pride & Prejudice and Hustle & Flow.
None of my own top choices for best film of 2005 was even nominated. At the top of my list, along with several other critics’, was The Best of Youth, which as an Italian tv series belatedly released in the U.S. as a 6-hour film was probably disqualified on multiple counts. The Squid and the Whale would have been my pick of eligible films, with Brokeback Mountain belatedly joining Walk the Line and Syriana in the runner-up group. If Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room is exiled to the documentary catergory, The Constant Gardener might sneak into the best five domestic films, just edging Good Night, and Good Luck. In the same *7+* rank with the latter were two small but delightful films, Junebug and My Summer of Love; also several documentaries slightly better than the Oscar-winning March of the Penguins, including Grizzly Man and Mad Hot Ballroom; plus the animation winner Wallace & Gromit. I thought Capote was worth watching, but more on the *6+* out-of-the-running level of something like Mysterious Skin.
The only Hollywood contender I haven’t seen yet is A History of Violence, which arrives on dvd next Tuesday. There are a number of foreign films that have gotten Top Ten rankings from scattered critics, which I will be catching up with over the next month or two, but even at this I think it’s fair to say that 2005 wasn’t a bad year for films, as long as you were willing to look beyond the mainstream.
Of course I’m way behind on my ratings here, for whatever they may be worth, so I’ll offer a few brief observations in descending order of my recommendation:
Moolaade. (2004) *8* (MC-91) It’s mean to top the list with a film you have very little chance of seeing, not on dvd and not coming to a theater near you, but I was in a lucky group that saw this at Images Cinema, courtesy of the collaboratively-supported series, “Beyond the Femme Fatale: Leading Women in French and Francophone Film.” It is by the 81-year-old Senegalese director Ousmane Sembene, and I will definitely be looking further into his oeuvre. You are transported to a different world, right into a remote West African village, a deeply traditional society experiencing the first incursions of modernity. While retaining a documentary realism, the film has the quality of a beautiful folk tale, in its elemental struggles and pageant-like set-pieces. One strong woman stands up against the patriarchal practice of female genital mutilation, taking in four girls who have escaped from the ritual of “purification” because they did not want to be cut, and offering them “moolaade” or sanctuary. And the whole structure of the society starts to tremble and fall, with dynamics recognizable in any society, and well-rounded characters also recognizable across cultural divides. This film will give you a new perspective on the world, and a richer appreciation of just what’s at stake in the world’s passage from tribalism to globalism. Hard to imagine, but here the final shot of a television aerial is an image of hope.
Brokeback Mountain. (2005) *8* (MC-87) When I finally caught up with this much-discussed film last week, my companion and I were the only two people in the theater, a quasi-private screening. I’m glad it hung around long enough for me to see it on the big screen. By now you’ve heard all you need to about this film, but personally I liked it a lot, would certainly have picked it out of given Oscar noms. For me the only thing lacking for an absolute rave was the failure to capture the moment when Jack and Ennis fall in love, though the Rocky Mountain landscape makes an effective “objective correlative” (is that obscure Eliotic phrase still in academic circulation?)
Deadwood. (2004) *8-* Quite a different view of the West. I've finished the first season of this HBO series on dvd, and now I’m sufficiently hooked to be TiVo-ing the whole second season in anticipation of the upcoming third. No surprise really, since it’s the brainchild of David Milch, co-creator of NYPD Blue, which for years was the only network series I watched. This portrait of an outlaw town growing up from scratch around a gold strike is reminiscent of Robert Altman’s masterpiece, McCabe and Mrs. Miller, though much raunchier. The unremitting obscenity, the squalid sex and violence, are justified on grounds of historical accuracy, but take some getting used to. Many will not want to get used to it, but for those who do, that long-form magic will take hold. You will be part of this frontier community, familiar with all the characters, and eager to see what damned thing will happen next. But you’ve got to start from the beginning and give yourself four hours or so to get the hang of the neighborhood. For once a slogan has meaning: it’s not tv, it’s HBO. For me, this joins Rome in the pantheon of series, just below The Wire and The Sopranos. And Six Feet Under, before it wore out its welcome.
Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit. (2005) *7+* (MC-87) Who doesn’t love Wallace and Gromit, just awarded the Oscar for animated feature? I’m showing the three preceding W & G shorts in an animation festival at the Clark on Sunday, March 26 (check this space later for exact schedule.) But I have to admit I got drowsy in the middle of this film, which may have been that beer with dinner or it may have been some stretching of the material, tempo as well as plasticine. Still, cracking good cheese.
Nine Lives. (2005) *7* (MC-80) This no-budget indie shares several qualities with Crash but does more with less. Writer-director Rodrigo Garcia is the son of Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Maybe that helped him line up an A-list of actresses working for minimum scale, or maybe it was the appeal to theater people of spending one day of rehearsal and blocking and one day of shooting single 11-14 minute Steadicam takes of well-written domestic drama. Robin Wright Penn, Sissy Spacek, Holly Hunter, Molly Parker, Glenn Close, et al. -- how could a film with such a cast not break through to public recognition? Well, to be honest, it’s work to watch -- but very rewarding work. You have to pay close attention while each scene unfolds in real time, and then you have to start over again with new characters and a new situation. It’s like reading a book of short stories straight through; requires a different sort of attention than sinking into a novel. All the story lines do not collide as they do conveniently in Crash, but there is some overlap. This matches up nicely with Personal Velocity as an interesting depiction of contemporary women’s lives in multiple.
Pleasantville. (1998) *7-* (MC-71) Another matched pair, this with The Truman Show. The technical conceit of having color invade the world of a Fifties b&w tv sitcom is nice handled, but is barely skin deep. Gary Ross’s first effort as writer-director is a pleasant trifle. Reese Witherspoon and Tobey Maguire show promise of stardom to come, as contemporary teenagers transported into an oldie tv world. Joan Allen and William Macy lend their usual effective support as the tv parents. But this film is not up to the standard of Back to the Future or Peggy Sue Got Married.
8 Women. (2001) *5+* (MC-64) Twice I tried to watch Netflix disks that proved defective, and then I couldn’t make it when this film led off the “Beyond the Femme Fatale” series at Images. Then I saw the dvd while browsing in the college library, and took it out. I needn’t have gone to the effort. Francois Ozon’s confection was not to my taste, just too arch, too little attached to any reality whatsoever. It’s a Christie-like country house mystery, with an astounding line-up of great French actresses from Darrieux and Deneuve to Beart and Ledoyen, put to the task of sheer silliness.
I had disappointing audiences for my “Triple Feature: 3 Painters” program at the Clark, but take the opportunity to remind local residents that dvds shown at the Clark are subsequently available for borrowing from the Milne Public Library in Williamstown. For me Artemisia seemed even better on second look, once you get past the undenial bodice-ripping aspect and quibbles about biographical accuracy. Carrington (with Emma Thompson and Jonathan Pryce) and Pollock (with Ed Harris and Marcia Gay Harden) remain well worth seeing if you haven’t already done so.
Saturday, March 04, 2006
March of the Penguins
This phenomenally popular documentary hardly needs my endorsement, but I am pleased to give it. Just the colors of Antarctic sky and icescape are sufficient recommendation, but the birds themselves are a beautiful nature study. The narration was not as saccharine as I feared, though it was wincingly anthropomorphic at times. The storyline is strong enough and Morgan Freeman gives it enough gravity, that the narration does not disrupt the natural fascination of the subject, though it is, like the visuals, sanitized of messy details for a G-rating. The overlay of “family values” may have made this play in the heartland, but if your eyes are open this is a paean to evolution’s mystery and the majesty of the reproductive urge. What organisms will do to propagate in a harsh environment! The dvd extras approach the same material from a less fairytale perspective -- conveying the total cacophony and stench of a scrum of emperor penguins, and some of their less exemplary behavior -- and are as immersive as the film itself. (2005, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-79, RT-95.)
Bleak House
This exemplary Masterpiece Theater production recently finished broadcasting and is now available on dvd. Again I am going to cop out of a review, and just urge you to see it. The best thing I can say about this eight-hour adaptation is that it is positively Dickensian. A fabulous array of characters and more plot that you can shake a stick at. I find it hard to grade tv series on the same scale as movies, but this is a masterwork very true to its original, which after all came out as a serial in the first place. Imagine it as the popular Pride and Prejudice series shot with the in-your-face jaggedness of NYPD Blue. Tulkinghorne, Smallweed, Guppy, Bucket, Jarndyce and all the rest are portrayed with amplitude and vividness, but it is the female leads who improve on the original, where Esther and Ada could betray a Victorian insipidity. Lady Dedlock may also have more shading than in the book. If you go for this sort of thing at all, definitely go for this! (2005, PBS, n.) *8*
Thursday, February 23, 2006
The Best of Youth (La Meglio Gioventu)
Originally made for Italian tv, this six-hour family saga had a limited theatrical release in the U.S. last year, so it certainly ranks in my book as the Best Film of 2005. A leisurely unfolding of complicated familial dynamics against the news of the last forty years in Italy, the film focuses on two brothers (though the two sisters are also given their due, as is everyone who is swept up into the broad canvas) coming of age in the Sixties and pursuing divergent (and yet ultimately convergent) paths through the succeeding decades. Luckily that takes them from Rome to Turin to Florence to Palermo and points along the way, so the film works as a beautiful travelogue as well as a primer on recent Italian history. But it is even better as character study charted against time and the times, with novelistic breadth and depth, flawlessly acted by a large cast. Marco Tullio Giordano admirably follows in the tradition of directors like Visconti, Rosi, or Olmi. There’s no way to encapsulate the story, you have to immerse yourself in it, which I advise you to do. If you can’t lay your hands on the dvd, I hope to be able to offer a special event screening at the Clark this September. (2003, dvd, n.) *9-* (MC-89, RT-95.)
The American President
For me this holds up better than The Truman Show, seems funnier and deeper over time. Especially given the afterlife of these knowingly Capra-esque capers in an authentically rendered White House, what with writer Aaron Sorkin taking the chops honed here to The West Wing, where Martin Sheen moved up from chief of staff to the President’s chair. Michael Douglas is effectively triple-threat -- jut-jawed as widowed President, believably smitten by lobbyist Annette Bening (she of the wide-open eyes and wit as quick as her words), able to take his pratfalls with expert timing. Michael Fox, David Paymer, and others are also familiar to these precincts, and Richard Dreyfuss contributes a turn as the opposing Republican candidate. Watching the film again, a telling instance of the Hollywoodization of Washington, offers plenty of reflection on the intervening ten years of presidential politics. Foreshadowing Monicagate behind the scenes, the film’s focus on global warming and energy consumption as an issue is as fresh as today’s news. Astounding that ten years have passed without the first step being taken, as proposed here. Amazing how different the political environment -- except not so. The Republican electoral strategy described here has certainly been followed to a T: find something to fear and find someone to blame. Rob Reiner has definitely made sharp, funny films in his day, though now he’s probably looking to retire to the California governor’s mansion. (1995, dvd@cai, r.) *7+*
It’s only worth taking note of the harmless but juiceless The Boys and Girl from County Clare (2004) to make the promise that Kevin O’Hara and I will team up to write a much more flavorful screenplay, both tighter and more open-ended, out of some of the same Irish themes and scenes, as we adapt the just-optioned Last of the Donkey Pilgrims for the screen. Mike Haley is set to produce, soon after he is honored this May at the first Berkshire International Film Festival, for a long career culminating with an Emmy for the HBO production of Angels in America. (At the moment he is off to Morocco for location scouting on Charlie Wilson’s War, a film starring Tom Hanks and directed by Mike Nichols.) So if my blogging slows down, you’ll know it’s because I’m trying to make a movie instead of commenting on them.
It’s only worth taking note of the harmless but juiceless The Boys and Girl from County Clare (2004) to make the promise that Kevin O’Hara and I will team up to write a much more flavorful screenplay, both tighter and more open-ended, out of some of the same Irish themes and scenes, as we adapt the just-optioned Last of the Donkey Pilgrims for the screen. Mike Haley is set to produce, soon after he is honored this May at the first Berkshire International Film Festival, for a long career culminating with an Emmy for the HBO production of Angels in America. (At the moment he is off to Morocco for location scouting on Charlie Wilson’s War, a film starring Tom Hanks and directed by Mike Nichols.) So if my blogging slows down, you’ll know it’s because I’m trying to make a movie instead of commenting on them.
Monday, February 20, 2006
The Truman Show
Upon reconsideration I had a rather lukewarm response to this prescient but pallid pastel parable of our mediated future. Certainly it skewers the medium of reality tv before it really got started, but by now Charlie Kauffman and Spike Jonze have raised the bar on mindblowing, so this quirky script from Andrew Niccol with placid direction from Peter Weir does not seem all that surprising in retrospect. The creation of the artificial world of Seahaven out of the artificial world of Disney’s made-up town of Celebration is very well done, and keeps your mind spinning between what is real and what is fake. Jim Carrey goes beyond mugging but not so far as involving or enlightening performance, as the real person whose whole life has been created for a real-time tv soap opera master-minded by Ed Harris, the God-like director whom he gives a human dimension. Future indie icons such as Paul Giammati and Laura Linney put in an appearance, and while the latter is perfectly plastic as Truman’s pretend wife, that’s not exactly what you want from an actress who exudes warmth and humanity, even when playing a monster like the mother in The Squid and the Whale. Natascha McElhone is wasted as the figurehead of freedom and escape into reality, but is indicative of the quality that went into this production. So by all means see this film if you missed it, but don’t bother revisiting it as a presumptive classic. The set-up raises a lot of interesting questions, but the film changes the channel without really answering them. That might be a virtue in some respects, but left me slightly unsatisfied in this case. (1998, dvd, r.) *7* (MC-90, RT-96.)
Downfall
This is a nominee for Best Foreign Film in this year’s Oscar race, and it would be a worthy choice. Not everybody will want to spend quality time with Hitler and his crew during their last ten days in the bunker, not even for the exhausting catalogue of ways and means to commit suicide. But I can’t imagine any film conveying a greater sense of “you are there,” whether you want to be or not. Picking up from a recent documentary about Hitler’s young secretary, the film convincingly answers the question of how you might get into that situation, and how you might get through it. Bruno Ganz makes Hitler believable and almost understandable, if not quite sympathetic. Eva Braun, Albert Speer, the Goebbels family, and all the rest of the characters in this lumpen Gotterdammerung are also believably real if unbelievably misguided people. For its native German audience, this must be a particularly powerful, perhaps necessary experience. For the rest of us, Oliver Hirschbiegel delivers impeccable filmmaking if not a lot of laughs or tears. (2004, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-82, RT-91.)
Match Point
My number grade on this film is an approximate average, since I’d give at least a *7* to the first half of Woody Allen’s Hitchcockian departure from Manhattan to London, but barely a *5* to the second half when the shotgun comes in and plausibility goes out the window. Initially Woody’s misogyny is obscured by a wittily dyspectic misanthropy, but when the film turns against Scarlett Johansson something goes seriously wrong, since there is no other character to care about in this chilly, passionless depiction of crimes of passion. Jonathan Rhys Meyers works as a sort of Brit Joaquin Phoenix, but it is impossible to put yourself in his place, trying to decide between sultry Scarlett and twittering twit Emily Mortimer, who has to work hard to subdue her innate charm into upper-class inanity. I wouldn’t join those who call this a return to form for Woody, but it is a worthwhile exercise for a craftsman who turns out a more or less competent film every year, and occasionally something decidedly more. He remains a model of independence and indefatigability, if not a wholly admirable artist. (2005, Images, n.) *6* (MC-72, RT-78.)
Tuesday, February 14, 2006
Some Mother's Son
This is a remarkably uninflammatory film about the 1981 IRA hunger strike, led by Bobby Sands in the Maze prison of Ulster. Iron Maiden Maggie Thatcher and her minions are skewered, but all other sides are given due consideration. Directed by Terry George, with Jim Sheridan as producer and co-writer, this is a companion piece to the stirring In the Name of the Father, written by George and directed by Sheridan. The film centers around the always-estimable Helen Mirren, and also Fionnula Flanagan, as the mothers of two of the hunger strikers. When it comes to Ireland today, this is thankfully distant history, but the issues of terrorism as a political vs. a criminal act are as current as the latest news from Gitmo. This film admirably puts a human face on the question. (1996, Sund/T, n.) *7*
I am in the middle of two tv miniseries that I will write about when I finish them, the first season of HBO’s Deadwood on dvd, and the Masterpiece Theater adaptation of Bleak House on PBS.
I’ve also been catching up with some unseen oldies on Turner Classic Movies’ “31 Days of Oscar,” notably F.W. Murnau’s Sunrise (1927) and Laurel & Hardy’s Way Out West (1937.) The former is important, one of the great culminating silent films, frequently on lists of the best of all time, well worth watching especially with double time to get through the really slow parts -- it reminds one how amazingly quicker we “get it” these days. There are very few title cards at all, but when they have to bring back a two-sentence piece of dialogue for a second read, you know the old audience was a little slow on the uptake. So it’s hard to recommend viewing this film, despite the striking Expressionist visual style, imported from Germany to Hollywood, contrasting city and country life. Janet Gaynor won the very first Best Actress Oscar for her role as “The Wife.” I suspect I may have watched Way Out West on tv as a kid in the Fifties, certainly there was a lot of Laurel and Hardy on the tube back then, so the memories were engaging if the movie was not.
I am in the middle of two tv miniseries that I will write about when I finish them, the first season of HBO’s Deadwood on dvd, and the Masterpiece Theater adaptation of Bleak House on PBS.
I’ve also been catching up with some unseen oldies on Turner Classic Movies’ “31 Days of Oscar,” notably F.W. Murnau’s Sunrise (1927) and Laurel & Hardy’s Way Out West (1937.) The former is important, one of the great culminating silent films, frequently on lists of the best of all time, well worth watching especially with double time to get through the really slow parts -- it reminds one how amazingly quicker we “get it” these days. There are very few title cards at all, but when they have to bring back a two-sentence piece of dialogue for a second read, you know the old audience was a little slow on the uptake. So it’s hard to recommend viewing this film, despite the striking Expressionist visual style, imported from Germany to Hollywood, contrasting city and country life. Janet Gaynor won the very first Best Actress Oscar for her role as “The Wife.” I suspect I may have watched Way Out West on tv as a kid in the Fifties, certainly there was a lot of Laurel and Hardy on the tube back then, so the memories were engaging if the movie was not.
Hustle and Flow
As attracted to Black culture as I have always been, I’ve never been able to get down with hip-hop, and its whole pimps ‘n’ ho’s aesthetic. Give me Smokey Robinson or Marvin Gaye any day. And yet Memphis white boy Craig Brewer as writer/director has infused the scene with a satisfying creative passion, the drive to make that demo tape of crunk a direct parallel to his own quest to make the movie. The whole struggle-to-breakthrough story arc is tried and true, but there is plenty of local color and flavor along the way. His passion recruited director John Singleton to produce, and eventually to finance it himself when none other could be found. The film won multiple awards at Sundance last year, and Terrence Howard’s performance has been deservedly nominated for a Best Actor Oscar. He’s a scuffling-to-get-by pimp and dealer who glimpses redemption in getting his story out and his rapping noticed. Yeah, yeah, everybody’s got a dream. But more importantly none of the details are fudged, this is not what you would call an admirable character here, but you do root for the dream to be realized. The whores and bandmates are well-sketched characters as well. The uppers and downers of the story are nicely-balanced, but it’s just not my scene. (2005, dvd, n.) *7-* (MC-68, RT-81.)
Thursday, February 09, 2006
African American Lives
Reluctant to commit to another multi-episode tv documentary after the disappointment of Country Boys, I was also put off by the focus here on Oprah and Whoopi and other Black celebrities, but some very positive reviews made me tune into this blandly-titled presentation by Henry Louis Gates Jr., head of African-American Studies at Harvard. And I’m very glad I did. Skip Gates is an utterly charming guide, the stories told are profoundly moving, the archival footage is thoroughly engrossing, and the exploration of genealogical and DNA research is intriguing in its own right. Following nine family trees back through the Great Migration to slave times and all the way back to Africa, this series delves into a past that is both tragic and uplifting. (2006, PBS/T, n.) *7+*
Munich
Pure punishment. Never in my life have I hated a movie this much. The moral confusion of its preachiness. The queasiness of its thriller apparatus. The unredeemed and unredeemable violence. The opaqueness of its characters. The sheer unreality and boredom of it all. Never have I been more reluctant to suspend disbelief. This is not a political but an aesthetic judgment. As to the politics of the situation, my feeling is strictly “seven plagues on both their houses,” so this film’s presumed evenhandedness offends me on both sides. I went into this Best Picture nominee with no preconception, but I found it excruciating from start to finish, neither entertaining nor thought-provoking, both obvious and incomprehensible. All the food and kitchen scenes made me want to puke. As “Avram’s Eleven,” it disgusts me. As “Israeliana,” it leaves me in the dark without a glimmer of light coming from the screen. Hands down, this wins my Worst Picture award. What a waste of the talent involved!(2005, Images, n.) *0* (MC-74, RT-78.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)