When the New York Times published
a poll of the “100 Best TV shows of the 21st Century,” I enjoyed comparing their list to mine. We agree on #1 Breaking Bad and
#2 The Wire (though I include #27 Better Call Saul in the
top tandem). My quirky #3 Rectify
does not appear on their list, and my quirky #4 Buffy the Vampire Slayer
was disqualified as dating from the previous century, as was HM The
Sopranos. My #5 Justified
comes in as their #83, but my #6 Deadwood does better
at #24. My #7 Friday Night Lights
is their #14, but my #8 Borgen is absent. My #9 Mad Men and #10 Succession
are their #3 and #4. Among my
Honorable Mentions are #20 The Crown, #96 Halt & Catch Fire,
and Doc Martin (not ranked though I do note that Netflix has just started
an American remake). Among current
contenders, I’m avidly following Slow Horses #62. Some other favorites lack the longevity to
make my list.
But I primarily wanted to use
the NYT list to answer a reader’s query about my highest-ranking
half-hour comedies, which seem to come in pairs. Comedies are more period dependent than
dramas, so I don’t include last-century favorites going back to the likes of Mary
Hartman or Mary Tyler Moore, but only include shows on the Times list. Leading off with the era-defining dark
comedies (or “sad-coms”) #4 Fleabag and #91 Catastrophe,
I have a decided preference for British series, followed up with the seminal
series #60 Peep Show and #63 The Thick of It (more
than its American reincarnation as #7 Veep; just as I enjoyed the
British version of #16 The Office and never watched an episode of
the American at #11). Not on their list,
but among my very favorites is Mum, which stands in for other UK
favorites like The Detectorists or Gavin & Stacey or W1A. The
American series that I love for that sort of wit, warmth, superior acting, and
personal authenticity is #82 Better Things. Recent heartland shows like #76
Somebody Somewhere and #87 Reservation Dogs also offer
more than jokes and calculated laughlines.
Similarly, #50 Parks and Recreation stands out for its
emphasis on character over laughs (while #8 30 Rock seems more standard
sit-com). That sort of depth certainly
describes #74 The Bear, which layers its humor with drama, and
even #75 Ted Lasso, which lays on the sentiment. There may be other favorites that slip my
mind (e.g. where’s Silicon Valley, perhaps the most topical of all? And perhaps I should find a place for Nurse
Jackie? Stop! – this is madness.).
Anyway, these are my picks from the Times list. They stand out in memory for the eagerness
with which I looked forward to each new episode or new season. Feel free to add your recommendations in the
comments.
No comments:
Post a Comment