Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Taxi to the Dark Side

This Oscar-winning documentary is even more devastating than No End in Sight or Bush’s War, because it does not just make the all-too-familiar case for the knee-jerk arrogance and aggressive, willful ignorance of the Bush Administration, but quietly ponders the question, “Are we evil?” It’s a film of great passion but never raises its voice, just makes the case with great lucidity. I don’t think it’s a spoiler to reveal what the final credit roll does, explaining the film as a memorial to director Alex Gibney’s father, a longtime FBI interrogator who was outraged by the idea of sanctioned torture. It documents that the abuses of Abu Ghraib et al. were a matter of policy in the so-called, self-justified “War on Terror,” and not the actions of a “few bad apples.” Or rather, that the few bad apples that turned the whole barrel rotten were Cheney, Rumsfeld, and that bunch. What America needs now is not just change, but exorcism -- we need to drive out the devils, not just those guys, but the demons within that allowed us to ratify the usurpers in 2004, even after they had revealed who they were and what they were doing in our name. Our nation needs contrition and penitence, and re-conversion to our original ideals. America has to come home, though it will be a long way back. The film elicits these thoughts, but does not hammer them home, meditating on the meaning and outcomes of torture. A “Taxi to the Dark Side” is certainly what our country has taken, but Gibney grounds his title in specifics, a young Afghan taxi driver who was rounded up in a sweep and murdered in U.S. custody four days later. The film revolves around remarkable interviews with the principals in the subsequent trials, but spirals outward and upward into the whole edifice of legal evasion and perversion embodied in Gitmo. Gibney eschews the flash that marked his excellent previous effort, Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, but is all the more riveting in his intensity of intent. This is must-see witness that is punishing to watch. (2008, Images, n.) *8+* (MC-82.)

Atonement

An honorable illustration of an excellent novel, Joe Wright’s adaptation of Ian McEwan (by way of Christopher Hampton) never takes off as a film of its own. Despite showy direction and insistent sound design, it lacks some fundamental engagement. The actors are generally good, but the characters are put through their paces without essential connectedness. So the film is pleasant to look at, with many dovetailing parts, but the feelings are muted, if not embalmed. Pretty and clever, but not moving -- as the book most definitely is. So if you know the novel, the film is a bit of a comedown, and if you don’t then the story will ring hollow. James McAvoy definitely has appeal, but I find blade-thin Keira Knightley a little scary. All three actresses who play the third side of the triangle, the writer-sister Briony, effectively portray a continuity of character: Saoirse Ronan, Romola Garai, and Vanessa Redgrave. But again the emotions are pumped up rather than flowing naturally from screen to viewer. You are swept away in the flood or you are left a bit high and dry. (2007, dvd, n.) *6+* (MC-85.)

I enjoyed watching The Searchers (1956), to wrap up my latest film series at the Clark, “A Wild and Savage Land: John Ford Looks at the American West” -- but I don’t think it would crack my Top 25 of All Time. The imagery is spectacular in every sense, and John Wayne is excellent, but it’s not quite as intense as I remembered, the story arc broken by bits of Fordian business like the brawl at the wedding. So it strikes me as an excellent but not a transcendant Western.

Goya's Ghosts

Let’s be honest here, Natalie Portman is a lovely and intelligent young woman, but she is not much of an actress. In Milos Forman’s film she is asked to hold a ramshackle story together with a three-part role, and sadly fails. A classic case of less than the sum of its parts, this film offers some sense of period and practice, but none of character or significance. It would love to be another Amadeus but does not come close. Stellan Skarsgard seems an odd choice for Goya, but maybe there’s a physical similarity, and his role is confined to observing anyway, as he watches the melodrama unfold but does not participate much. The central character is Javier Bardem as Inquisitor turned Napoleonic proconsul, who is fun to watch if not so much to think about. Poor Natalie is the woman he ruins, and the courtesan daughter that results. But the film does put a lot of Goya’s work on display, and paints a picture of the time and place from which it emerged, with a strained effort to draw contemporary parallels. A visual feast, if an emotive famine. (2007, dvd, n.) *5+* (MC-52.)

Out of the vein of recent disappointing re-viewings spurts The Grifters (1990), which may appeal to those who felt No Country for Old Men was the best picture of 2007, but leaves me rather cold, despite engaging performances from Anjelica Huston, John Cusack, and Annette Bening. Stephen Frears’ first American film is a stylish noir revival of Jim Thompson’s hardboiled “Sophoclean” worldview, in an incestuous triangle of con artists who dance and mate and kill like scorpions in a bottle. It’s funny and clever, but only to set up grisly scenes of horror, both physical and psychological. If that’s your idea of entertainment, then don’t let my lack of enthusiasm steer you away from a film that many rave about.

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Enchanted

This Disney self-parody is enchanting, and I was enchanted particularly by Amy Adams, as the cartoon princess who gets catapulted into the center of a too-real Times Square by evil queen Susan Sarandon, but loses none of her sunny pluck, summoning rats, pigeons, and cockroaches with her “Happy Working Song.” Kevin Lima’s direction is notable for another well-done production number set in Central Park. I was glad that a song from Once beat out three from this film for the Oscar, but they are definitely not too cloying. Mike Leigh regular Timothy Spall, in an unlikely role, really does embody the evil queen’s toady, but the lawyer prince and the cartoon prince did not particularly register on me, hunks of the month though they may be. There is also an Abigail Breslin wannabe who is refreshingly uncute. (Names withheld to be nice.) It was amusing to see Disney goofing on its whole Princess marketing strategy, and Amy Adams is definitely a Princess to root for, so the appeal of this film extends way beyond tween girls. (2007, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-75.)

Logging & blogging

My new year’s resolution for 2000 was to start a filmlog, just to keep track of all the films I was watching, so they wouldn’t all blur together in memory, and to rate my reaction on a scale of *10*. Having gotten in that routine, my new year’s resolution for 2005 was to start a film blog, where I could share my observations and evaluations about movies and have them at ready reference -- thus you have this, which I have come to view as a public service, for however miniscule a public.

So the last few films I’ve watched fell somewhere in between those purposes. It would be no service to call your attention to them, yet to keep up with my record of viewing or re-viewing I should note them in passing. Trying to fathom the Clintons in this primary season, I re-watched Primary Colors (1998), figuring that Emma Thompson would put the most sympathetic gloss possible on Hilary and her motivations. And what did I see but a monster of political calculation? So maybe it isn’t Bill and the consultants, but the true Hillary emerging in this campaign. For the rest, Mike Nichols’ direction and John Travolta’s impersonation of Bill wear thin after a while, and the story thinner. It’s worth seeing, but not worth re-seeing.

David Mamet’s directorial debut, House of Games (1987), had stuck in my mind as an outstanding demonstration of the art of the short con and the long con, so I thought to show it to my daughter, a psychology grad. But the games have lost some of their lustre -- Mamet has gone on to do better, Joe Mantegna is no longer such a surprise, and Lindsay Crouse (Mrs. Mamet at the time) is now for me indelibly the evil government scientist in the fourth season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. In this film, she is startlingly young and butch, capturing a moment of “shoulder-pad feminism” as a bestselling psychologist drawn to the tells, reveals, and misdirections of the con game. Her performance is somewhat robotic, but that is in keeping with her characterization and with the Mametian dialogue. Mantegna memorably combines the suave and the seedy, with a familiar array of shape-shifting characters around him. It’s still a smart thriller for its time, but no enduring classic.

For a Clark After Dark with the theme of The Roaring 20s, I was asked to show The Cotton Club (1984) and I was content to be paid to watch it, but I can’t recommend that you spend your time on it. A notorious fiasco from Francis Ford Coppola, it doesn’t know whether to be The Godfather or a rollicking Harlem musical, with one impulse getting in the way of the other and tripping up the footwork. Lots of familiar faces mill around, but some, like Diane Lane, are virtually unrecognizable. Richard Gere is recognizable but nothing more. Their romance throws off zero sparks. Gregory Hines hoofs okay, and even more could be made of the song and dance variety show from the likes of Duke Ellington and Cab Calloway, while Charlie Chaplin and Gloria Swanson watch from stage-side tables. But meanwhile Dutch Schultz is winning and losing gang wars. It’s all too much and too little. I was just as happy to punch my timeclock and leave the club.

On the other hand, you wouldn’t have had to pay me to re-watch She Wore a Yellow Ribbon (1949), in glorious color on the big screen, most effective in its appropriation of the subjects, hues, and style of Frederic Remington. The film is one iconic shot after the other, but still retains some plausibility within the context of its worldview. The reverence for military ritual may be a little thick, and the obligatory bits of Fordian business, like the slapstick saloon brawl, may wear thin, but visually this is masterful and the sentiments are truer than usual. John Wayne is really very good as the retiring captain of the cavalry, while Ben Johnson and Victor McLaglen lend excellent support, and Joanne Dru and Mildred Natwick come across better than the typical Ford woman. If you’re in the mood for a classic cavalry western, this is the one.

One other thing I’ve been watching is the four-hour PBS Frontline special on “Bush’s War.” It’s not quite as focused as No End in Sight, which covers much of the same ground, but makes for a useful summation of the indictment against the criminal war “monkees” that got us into this mess -- “Daydream Believers” indeed! The clock is ticking on Bush’s term, but the deleterious effects of his administration will haunt this country for decades. And it’s just too tragic to think of what we’ve lost as a nation since the Florida coup of 2000.

Great World of Sound

This Sundance favorite is Salesman meets American Idol, with a flavoring of Glengarry Glen Ross for good measure. Two fellows are recruited as A&R men for the fly-by-night music producing company of the title, which is obviously a scam but which the men buy into with forlorn hope, traveling to cities like Biloxi and Birmingham to audition musicians, who come to their motel room in response to ads in the local paper. Then the musicians are asked to demonstrate their commitment by putting up in advance 30% of the cost of producing a record. Writer-director Craig Zobel does a lot with a little, and the cheesiness of the sets and flatness of the lighting are perfectly appropriate to the story. The performers really were answering ads in the paper and were filmed with hidden cameras, and used with their consent after the fact. Pat Healy is the nerdy white partner and Kene Holliday is the buoyant black partner, and they bond nicely on the road, until the house of cards starts to fall apart. Deadpan humor melds with sorrowful authenticity in this very promising debut. (2007, dvd, n.) *7-* (MC-72.)

Bedlam

Val Lewton completes his remarkable run of low-budget, genre-transcending near-masterpieces at RKO by writing this script based on Hogarth’s Rake’s Progress. Amazingly ambitious, it examines not just the notorious asylum in 18th century London but the concept of madness in the Age of Reason, and presents the Quaker case for reform in a more intelligent manner than I’ve ever seen in a film. Anna Lee is up to the task of playing the saucy actress pet of a lord, who has her conscience awakened by a Quaker stonemason, and winds up thrown in the madhouse herself. And Boris Karloff is just right as the asylum warden. Mark Robson may be the least adept of Lewton’s directors at suggesting horror without showing it, but still manages to do a lot with a little. The ambition exceeds the budget at times, but the intention remains honorable. (1945, dvd, n.) *7-*

Saturday, March 22, 2008

This & that (Otto & Val)

As a film programmer myself, I am sometimes led by film programs to explore byways of cinema that would not otherwise come to my notice. Two recent examples are a Film Forum (NYC) series on Otto Preminger, and a Turner Classic Movies feature on Val Lewton -- with both I just scratched the surface without surprising any urge to dig deeper.

Preminger is definitely notable for his cussed independence and attraction to controversy, and ultimate ability to work on his own terms, but I do not engage with his directorial sensibility. By reputation his keywords are “objectivity” and “ambiguity” -- which are somewhat at odds with his dominating personality. Certainly his career has enough different stages to attract critics of different stripes. I remember being impressed by Advice and Consent (1963) and The Cardinal (1964) in my teen years, as well as two classics I caught up with on video, Laura (1944) and Anatomy of a Murder (1959). Following Film Forum, I watched a few more on DVD but turned up no strong recommendations, though each is not without interest.

Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) is a noir subject but not in noir style, the shadows are within the characters rather than within the frame. Dana Andrews is a detective with Oedipal rage, who kills a suspect and courts his wife (Gene Tierney, in a typical Preminger pairing in that period), but his behavior is observed dispassionately, so he’s as hard to take sides for or against as Jimmy McNulty on The Wire.

Angel Face (1952) has another Freudian howler in Jean Simmons, as the title character with a maniacal crush on her father, a femme as fatal as they come, who enlists a bemused Robert Mitchum into her schemes -- the supposedly shocking ending seems a foregone conclusion.

The Man with the Golden Arm (1956) was a breakthrough depiction of heroin addiction, but seems old hat now, just a small extension of boundaries from The Lost Weekend. Frank Sinatra is quite good as the junkie card dealer who wants to become a drummer, held back by a scheming shrew of a wife but encouraged by adoring girlfriend Kim Novak (surprisingly believable). So we can leave it that Otto Preminger is a good filmmaker, but not a director I feel compelled to attend to.

And I might say the same about Val Lewton. A generous appreciation of the low-budget producer as auteur is offered in the new documentary, Val Lewton: Man in the Shadows (2007), presented by Martin Scorsese and directed by Kent Jones (with whom I have had a friendly acquaintance). In conjuction with its premiere, TCM programmed a Val Lewton retrospective, which I sampled selectively, and determined that Lewton was indeed more than just a predecessor of b-movie mogul Roger Corman -- he was an estimable artist of limited means. His films may transcend genre and budget but are still limited by it; at this stage of film history, they’re definitely more than a goof but still require a large suspension of belief not to laugh at.

Cat People (1942) is yet another Freudian howler, complete with villainous shrink. Simone Simon is suitably kittenish as the Serbian immigrant with an odd family tree, who fears that if she gives way to passion her feral forebears will manifest in her. Given the crazy premise, the film is surprisingly subtle in its use of suggestion for suspense, and its failure to take sides for or against the characters’ fantasies, except for that really creepy psychiatrist. Like Corman with Scorsese and others, Lewton gave Jacques Tourneur his first chance as director with this film.

He also got Robert Wise started with The Curse of the Cat People (1944), an ingenious twist to the requirement of a sequel after the earlier film’s success. This film almost dispenses with the horror genre altogether, in presenting the fantasy world of a young girl, though the threats seem real enough. To me it ranks with The Night of the Hunter as an evocation of childhood fears. Simone Simon returns as the imaginary friend of the young daughter of her former husband and the woman he has married after the action of the first film. Though the thread is tenuous, the films are connected, but I would definitely recommend this sequel even if you haven’t seen the originial.

Faced with the demand to make a film with zombies, Lewton turned to Charlotte Bronte and remade Jane Eyre in Haiti as I Walked with a Zombie (1943), directed by Tourneur. It’s a film that weaves a visual spell out of simple elements, and doesn’t overstay its welcome at 69 minutes, but still the atmosphere it creates does not linger in the mind, dissipating into airy nonsense.

Lewton’s aspirations are even more on view in The Body Snatcher (1945), which he adapted himself from a story by R.L. Stevenson. Boris Karloff is a “resurrection man,” digging up bodies for medical professor Henry Daniell, and both familiar faces give nuanced performances, with a bit role for Bela Lugosi to give the film genre appeal. But the approach to the unhappy marriage of medical science and ghoulish means is amazingly serious. Director Wise offers a fair evocation of Edinburgh in 1831, and the only low-budget flaw in the film is the inept actor who plays the young doctor in the middle of the action. Otherwise it’s far from a laughable period piece.

The Seventh Victim (1943) wears its literary aspirations on its sleeve, opening with an epigraph from John Donne, and taking place mostly in a building with a restaurant call The Dante. The story anticipates Rosemary’s Baby -- about a fashionable young woman in the clutches of a Manhattanite devil cult -- but first time director Mark Robson is no Roman Polanski. It’s easy to see why some say it’s Lewton’s most personal film, or his masterpiece. But neither the actors nor the film itself have the resources to bring it off, to make sense out of a dense and convoluted story, heavy with dread and ambiguity.

One film I did have to laugh at was Paul Schrader’s remake of Cat People (1982), in which the Freudian subtext is made risibly overt. Nastassja Kinski is again suitably kittenish, and Malcolm McDowell heads a cast that seems amazingly familiar in retrospect, but the film makes no sense at all in its heat and gore -- the horror seen rather than imagined -- yet it retains a strange attraction. So do you laugh at Nastassja in her birthday suit padding like a panther through a forest at night, or do you have some other somatic reaction? Your call.

Mouchette

The ethical and aesthetic credo of Robert Bresson has always struck me as too severe, except when it is sublime. His view of life as a prison transcends itself in two austere masterpieces, A Man Escaped (certainly among my own top 25 films of all time) and The Trial of Joan of Arc, where the imprisonment is literal. There are only metaphorical or metaphysical bars around the Country Priest, the donkey Balthazar, or the peasant girl who is the title character of this film (endearingly, “Little Fly”). Such a careful filmmaker will often make memorable scenes, but overall his approach seems chilly and schematic. He has so little regard for screen acting that he refers to his nonprofessional players as models rather than actors. Bresson may be one of the great directors, but he is also a hazing ritual for a cult of critics -- if you aim to be serious about cinema, you are obliged to immerse yourself in his astringent output. So when the Criterion Collection recently released a pristine print, I had to watch poor Mouchette suffer her fate all over again, one blow after another in a heartless world, as much a beast of burden as Balthazar. And again the ending seemed abrupt and some points along the way unconvincing, so unless one clicks into a transcendental reverie, this Bressonian effort seems thin, starved of life (aside from the justly celebrated carnival scene where Mouchette gets to drive a Dodge ‘Em). On the same theme, I find the Dardennes brothers’ Rosetta more memorable. (1966,dvd, r.) *6+*

Sunday, March 16, 2008

The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford

Writer-director Andrew Dominik fails to adapt Ron Hansen’s novel sufficiently, and the result is less than the sum of its parts -- starting with excellent performances by Brad Pitt and Casey Affleck as the title characters and superb cinematography by Roger Deakins (“on loan” from the Coen Brothers) -- and more than the story will bear -- making it rather dozy at close to three hours. The giveaway is a mostly unnecessary narration, which is obvious at times but leaves much of the story confusing and underdeveloped, in need of connection. There’s enough good stuff to keep one watching, and enough aimless scenes and shots to set eyelids closing and head nodding. While offering the pictorial delights of a classic western, the film attempts to offer a meditation on the beginning of celebrity culture, as cult hero Pitt is stalked by fan and assassin Affleck. Each performance is riveting at times, but again the connection is missing. Meanwhile some fine actors are wasted in undeveloped supporting roles, Sam Shepard and Mary Louise Parker among others. The slack self-indulgence of this postmodern Western was highlighted for me since I came to it directly after showing Stagecoach to kick off my John Ford series at the Clark. Ford’s economical storytelling conveyed more than this film’s vaporous aestheticizing in half the time. Though Dominik’s film has its advocates and detractors, a common point of comparison is Terrence Malick, but while I am definitely a fan of his, of this not so much. (2007, dvd, n.) *6+* (MC-68.)

Across the Universe

Here’s a bit of heresy -- I liked this appropriation of a Sixties musical icon about as much as I’m Not There. Julie Taymor pours on the showbiz pizzazz and the Boomer nostalgia to transform 30 Beatles songs into a Hair-y chronicle of that defining era. I’m not so in love with the Beatles that I consider it a desecration, but was sufficiently imprinted with their work at an impressionable age that I can call up the words even when I don’t have any idea what they mean -- didn’t then, don’t now. So here the simple-minded transposition of lyric into action struck me as inevitable and yet revelatory. I got some of these songs in a way I never did before. And since all Beatles songs have been covered repeatedly, it didn’t bother me to hear them in other voices. Granted, the Sixties are presented as a series of comic book panels, but I’m invested and imbued enough to have a Pavlovian reaction to depiction of such scenes, unless they’re so badly done as to elicit revulsion. Certainly, plenty of critics were revolted by this psychedelic potpourri, but I bought into it for the duration (which, typically, should have been a quarter-hour less). Evan Rachel Wood is rather bland as the straight blond love interest, but maybe that was Waspishly appropriate. I didn’t care for her brother either, an Ivy League dropout turned Vietnam grunt, but I’d be just as put off if I met the character in the flesh. Luckily, Jim Sturgess is appealing, in a Jake Gyllenhaal manner, as the Liverpudlian shipworker who stows away to NYC and winds up in the East Village crash pad of a Janis Joplin-like singer and her Jimi Hendrix-like guitarist. But the story or characters hardly matter except as a pretext for kinetic visual pyrotechnics. I enjoyed it, but I can’t guarantee that you will. (2007, dvd, n.) *7-* (MC-56.)

On the other hand, Syndromes and a Century (2007, dvd, n.) was acclaimed by some, enough to come in at #4 on the annual Indiewire critics poll, but remained as opaque to me as its title. The Thai filmmaker, Apichatpong Weerasethakul (who helpfully goes by the name of “Joe”) is a darling of the international film festival set, but I can’t get into his work, which is carefully crafted but incomprehensible to me. He has a light and lovely touch, but I have no idea what he’s getting at, even with the clue that it has something to do with how his parents met, as two doctors, with the story told twice from opposing perspectives, once in a country hospital and once in a city. Or something like that. Buddhist or surrealist, it’s all beyond me.

Monday, March 10, 2008

The Wire, R.I.P.

I’ve already had my say on The Wire, and such praise has now become commonplace, so if you haven’t been swayed yet by widespread assertions that it’s the greatest TV series ever, nothing I can add will convince you to give this work the attention it deserves and requires. But now that its mind-bending, heart-rending five-season run is complete, I have to offer a RIP bouquet.

I believe one word says it all about The Wire: “complicity.” It’s all there in the complicated portrait of a city. The complicity of institutions, and their complicity in social woes. The complicity of individuals, following their own interests or codes. The complicity of cops with criminals; the complicity of money and power, business and politics, schools and media. The complicity of actors and characters, which gives the film/novel the feel of reality. The complicity of fact and fiction. The complicity of show and viewer, makers and responders, so evident in impassioned online message boards. The complicity of critics, striving to keep an underwatched show alive by attracting viewers. Complicity is the opposite of conspiracy -- it is the genuine invisible hand that rules everything. We’re all accomplices.

As for a review of the fifth and final season, they’re everywhere -- take your pick. All I have to say is that David Simon, Ed Burns, and all the rest of the writers, cast, and crew remained true to the greatness of their endeavor to the very end -- 60 hours that will live as long as television does. All over America today, people are going back to Episode 1, and the pre-title-sequence demise of “Snot-boogie,” to start all over again. The parallel world of The Wire is complete, and it will last forever in our memories.


P.S. If like me you just can't let go, here's a nice wrap-up of last episode by a group of Salon writers. (You may have to watch a brief ad to get to Salon, but once there you should check out another excellent interview with David Simon.)

State of Play

For those suffering from Wire-withdrawal, this six-hour BBC miniseries delivers a welcome jolt. Also for Michael Clayton fans, disappointed that the best film didn’t win “Best Picture.” Here Paul Abbott has written a superior conspiracy thriller script, and David Yates directs in propulsive style, with editing and music insistent on keeping up the pace. The story hurtles by, as the viewer strains to keep up with its twists and turns. It all starts when a lovely young research assistant for a British energy minister jumps -- or is pushed? -- in front of a train, and we follow a dedicated but unscrupulous band of reporters trying to get to the bottom of a story which seems to have no bottom, just a deeper and deeper cesspool of responsibility. The cast is amazing as an ensemble, whether little-known or quite familiar. Bill Nighy is superb as usual as the managing editor, Kelly Macdonald is reliably excellent as a spunky reporter (with her native Glasgow accent quite a shock after her full Texan in No Country for Old Men), James McAvoy hints at the movie star he would soon become as another of the reporters, Polly Walker overcomes her indelible image as Atia in the HBO miniseries Rome. Less familiar are the two leads -- John Simm as the lead reporter, and David Morrissey as the rising young MP (just what he played as eventual PM Gordon Brown in The Deal). I advise you to watch this series soon for full effect, since Abbott has adapted it for an American remake, which is now being filmed for 2009 release by Kevin Macdonald, with these substitutions: Helen Mirren, Rachel MacAdams, nobody, Robin Wright Penn, Russell Crowe, and Ben Affleck. (2003, dvd, n.) *7+*

The Heart of the Game

Hey, I just saw this great film about a sassy high school student having a baby, and no, it wasn’t Juno. Ward Serrill’s documentary follows the fortunes of Seattle’s Roosevelt Roughriders through seven seasons of girls’ basketball, as a quirky, disheveled tax law professor takes the reins and applies his own hilarious but effective coaching approach to giving the game heart. But the story finds its focus with the arrival of Darnellia, a talented freshman who happens to be black in an overwhelmingly white school. What follows couldn’t be scripted, though it follows the template of every rousing sports story ever told. To say this isn’t quite a Hoop Dreams for girls is merely to say it isn’t one of the greatest films of all time, but still well worth seeking out. The dvd extras flesh out the story, to give it a little more of that epic scope. Like the excellent book In These Girls, Hope Is a Muscle, this is, among other virtues, a paean to Title IX. See it. (2005, dvd, n.) *8* (MC-74.)

Ford film series at the Clark

A Wild and Savage Land: John Ford Looks at the American West
In conjunction with the Clark's current exhibition, Remington Looking West, I'll present a program of John Ford films, to suggest how Ford follows in Frederic Remington's footsteps in depicting the majesty and mythos of the Wild West, transferring a shared visual style from canvas to film. All films will be shown by widescreen digital projection in the Clark auditorium on Saturdays at 2:00 p.m.

March 15: Stagecoach. (1939, 100 min.) A mythic success, this film sets the mold for the Western genre, with Ford establishing the characters, themes, and scenes he and others would return to time and again, while making a star of John Wayne. You’ve seen this story dozens of times, but see the original again or for the first time.

March 22: My Darling Clementine. (1946, 97 min.) Ford takes on another myth of the Old West, with Henry Fonda as Wyatt Earp in Tombstone, leading up to the gunfight at the OK Corral. With Victor Mature as Doc Holliday and Walter Brennan as the vile patriarch of the Clanton gang, along with Ford’s standard repertory of actors.

March 29: She Wore a Yellow Ribbon. (1949, 103 min.) Ford instructed his cinematographer to study Remington’s pictorial style before making his first Western in color. John Wayne is a cavalry officer who longs to retire after Custer’s defeat, but duty calls him to make a final stand against another Indian attack. Victor McLaglen is his trusty sergeant.

April 5: The Searchers. (1956, 119 min.) Ford transcends himself in this searching depiction of John Wayne as an Indian hunter and hater, who travels long and far to find a niece abducted by Indians. But when he finds her, Natalie Wood has been acculturated as a squaw herself, which creates a memorable internal conflict. Viewed by many as the greatest Western of them all.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

There Will Be Blood

It may seem churlish to depreciate an ambitious, uneven film with many excellent attributes, lionized by critics, but all I can do is offer my honest and considered response. Paul Thomas Anderson’s film about the progress of an oil tycoon from solitary chthonic endeavor to world-bestriding megalomania is vivid and true in large measure, but succumbs repeatedly to operatic implausibility. Time, place, and technology are rendered with striking verisimilitude, but characterizations and plot points are elided or fumbled. Daniel Day-Lewis’s acclaimed performance is impressively detailed and forceful, but also wildly over the top. As his evangelical antagonist, Paul Dano is simultaneously obvious and enigmatic, as he confusingly plays two brothers on whose parched California land oil is found. A nonprofessional child actor performs admirably as Daniel’s beloved (?!?) son, but his origins and motivations are left shrouded in ambiguity. The discovery and exploitation of oil is brilliantly depicted, epic enough to make the film worth seeing, but character and story are simultaneously larger and smaller than life. And the music, while frequently effective, is way too insistent, contributing to the film’s hectoring quality. This is a film whose aspirations to greatness keep it from being as good as it might be. (2007, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-92.)

Gone Baby Gone

Ben Affleck captures a lot of local Boston color in his first directorial effort, and his younger brother Casey is surprisingly convincing as a juvenile-looking but tough-minded private detective. And Michelle Monaghan also comes through, as his rather implausible partner. Ed Harris is reliably powerful as the police detective they team up with, to search for an abducted 4-year-old girl. Amy Ryan earned her best supporting actress nod as the girl’s dissolute mom, quite a contrast to the saintly Beadie she plays on The Wire. Morgan Freeman, however, is fatally misused in a small but pivotal role as a police captain. The film has an odd structure in that it seems to end at the midpoint and start over, but I could buy that. What I couldn’t buy was its resolution of the moral conundrum it propounds. The choices made are far from satisfying, and the film itself doesn’t seem to know which side to take. It owes a lot to Mystic River, including the writer of the source novel, Dennis Lehane, but here the ambiguities are crippling. Just call it flavorful but flawed. (2007, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-72.)

Michael Clayton

Screenwriter Tony Gilroy’s debut as director is a highly successful attempt to re-capture the look and feel of the wide-screen, not-so-paranoid conspiracy thrillers of the 70s. In a year when Sidney Lumet proved he’s still got it, Gilroy revisits Lumet’s heyday, along with others such as Alan Pakula and Sydney Pollack (who actually acts -- and very well -- in this film.) But first off, I have to confess a serious mancrush on George Clooney, who not only has the magic charm of the true movie star, but like Redford and Beatty before him, and Cary Grant before them, uses it to wise effect, to get good films made and to make them better by his presence. Without him, there’s no film, in more ways than can be enumerated. Not that the rest of the cast and crew don’t perform admirably. Clooney is the ex-cop, Fordham-grad fixer in a white-shoe Manhattan law firm, the one who gets his shoes, and everything else, dirty. Tom Wilkinson negotiates the line between sanity and madness as the chief corporate litigator who goes bonkers during a deposition in a class action lawsuit he is defending for a company which markets cancer-causing defoliants -- has he gone crazy, or is he finally sane, crossing over to the other side? Tilda Swinton wonderfully portrays the neurotic but forceful chief counsel for the ADM-like agribusiness. There’s even an excellent child actor as Clooney’s son, who sells an intriguingly interwoven subplot related to a fantasy gaming novel. The story is complicated and convoluted, and makes pleasing demands on the audience’s powers of attention and ratiocination. The plot I’ve leave you to follow -- or not -- for yourself. (2007, dvd, n.) *8* (MC-82.)

Becoming Jane

To truly hate a movie, you have to care about the subject, and I really care about Jane Austen. Despite pretty pictures and pretty people, this attempt to read Austen’s fiction back into her life is pretty bad. Notwithstanding attractive costumes and settings, the film has no feel for period at all. To anyone with the least sense of Regency England, the dialogue and behavior of the characters is repeatedly eye-rolling, painfully incredible. I was quite taken with Anne Hathaway as the “smart fat girl” of The Devil Wears Prada, but oh my, she is more disablingly anachronistic than Keira Knightley in the Pride and Prejudice to which this film transparently tries to be a sequel. James McAvoy has something as a movie star, but nothing to make him a plausible Darcy figure. There is no glimmer of insight into the trials and contradictions of Austen’s life or her creative psychology, the irony into which she poured those contradictions. Instead of the least appreciation for her art, we get latter-day rom-com conventions. I sat though it, but don’t know when I’ve squirmed and sighed so much in the course of a movie. (2007, dvd, n.) *3+* (MC-55.)

On the other hand, I was appropriately on the edge of my seat for Speed (1994, dvd, n.), which was equally nonsensical but true to its own kinetic premise, summed up in the one-word title. I’m not a big fan of the fun of blowing things up on camera, but Jan de Bont’s film moves fast enough to achieve release velocity, soaring into suspension of disbelief as well as gravity. Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock do what movie stars are supposed to do, offer a pleasing fantasy of identification. This is the sort of Hollywood contraption that I would usually avoid, but I was happy enough to catch up with it as a diversion long after its release.

Sunday, February 17, 2008

4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days

I was grateful to see this much-praised Romanian film -- winner of the top prize at Cannes -- on IFC’s On Demand option, while it is still playing in select metropolitan theaters. But the image quality was sub-DVD and a far cry from HD. Nonetheless, I got to see the film that “everyone” is talking about. And Cristian Mungiu’s film -- like Cristi Puiu’s recent Death of Mr. Lazarescu -- suggests that Romania might be the happenin’ place in world cinema these days, with a new iteration of neorealism, in which documentary observation is overlaid with literary and cinematic tropes, in a way that sets critics to salivating. So this film depicts the harsh reality of an illegal abortion in 1987, just two years before the overthrow of Ceausescu, but it is also a noir-ish thriller, with two girls instead of two guys, facing down the system and its evil spawn, doing what needs to be done. The action takes place over one day and night, but the title implicitly gives the age of the fetus. The urge to find out what happens next meets with some visceral shocks, while some scenes are supremely suspenseful. And the film is held together by the great performance of Anamaria Marinca as the friend indeed, who guides her hapless roommate through the ordeal, toward a greater ordeal of her own. It’s well worth seeing, but I wasn’t as blown away as many commentators, less inclined perhaps to the grim and gritty, which this undeniably is. So here’s another critical stampede that I find hard to join, but I will go this far -- this film would likely reveal more and seem better on a second viewing. You should give it a chance, and I’ll give it another sometime. (2008, IFC/OD, n.) *7* (MC-99.)

I am almost too embarrassed by my tech illiteracy to point it out, but you may have noticed I finally figured out the simple process to make my notation of Metacritic rating a link to the relevant Metacritic page. So from now on, please click on MC-number to get more info on the film, read reviews, and compare other critical reactions to my own.