Saturday, December 31, 2005

In Good Company

Paul Weitz follows up the Nick Hornby-adaptation, About a Boy, with another sweetly sentimental comedy, though this time brother Chris shares credit only as producer and not writer-director. He’s got a sure touch with light but not insubstantial material, and is well served by a stellar cast. The reliable Dennis Quaid is a 51-year-old ad salesman for a national sports magazine that is taken over by a giant media conglomerate, which shunts him aside for 26-year-old whizkid Topher Grace. Not only does Dennis have to fire his colleagues and friends, his own status is more and more precarious, as his wife announces her surprisingly late pregnancy while older daughter Scarlett Johannson transfers from SUNY to much more expensive NYU. It only gets worse when Topher and Scarlett meet and fall for each other. Both the corporate takeover and romantic entanglement are well-handled. If the sharp satire goes soft at the end, that’s only fitting since we wouldn’t want to leave any of these most appealing characters unhappy. (2004, HBO/T, n.) *7+* (MC-66, RT-82.)

Filling in

Being a bit of a completist, I have recently been watching justly-neglected films by engaging young directors: A Life Less Ordinary from Danny Boyle, Mr. Jealousy from Noah Baumbach, and She Hate Me from Spike Lee. It’s pretty rare for me to look at films with Metacritic or Rotten Tomatoes scores in 20s and 30s, but three in a week indicates how betwixt and between I am at the moment. Each of the three is a mess, yet perversely watchable and instructive.

Millions made me look at Boyle again, and an extremely positive reference by Stephanie Zacharek, the critic (of Salon.com) with whom I agree more than anyone, led me to the big American film he got to make after Trainspotting became a hit. I’m afraid I cannot join her solitary enthusiasm for A Life Less Ordinary (1997), but it does have some appealing aspects -- energy above all. And Ewan MacGregor, whom I am starting to see as a young Cary Grant, always himself but game for any role, from slapstick to musical to drama (he does a bit of everything in this film), is always charming. Cameron Diaz is, to be honest, a little scary to me, with those sculpted cheekbones and all, but does contribute yet more energy. The story is inconsequential on several levels, with him kidnapping her (or vice versa), and a pair of angels played by Holly Hunter and Delroy Lindo (you’ve got to be kidding -- but I don’t take the joke), who will be kicked out of heaven if they don’t make the thrown-together couple fall in love. Not a good movie but a fun enough ride.

The Squid and the Whale represents a quantum leap forward for Baumbach after Mr. Jealousy (1998), which has its good points and its bad. The extensive voiceover narration suggests an inadequate adaptation of very personal material, turned into film by means of New Wave recyclings. I’m not going to come down hard on a film that appropriates music from Jules and Jim and visual tricks from Shoot the Piano Player. Eric Stoltz and Annabelle Sciorra are better than all right as the main couple, and Christopher Eigeman is always a welcome satirical presence, but the thirtysomething downtown NY scene has been covered often and better. I enjoyed the self-referential fun, but found that the film went on too long, with several deflating scenes tacked on to the end.

There are also moments of fun in She Hate Me (2004), but Spike Lee’s piling on of topical points makes for the worst film by an admirable director that I have every seen. The uneasy combination of corporate expose and sex comedy is difficult enough but becomes ludicrous, not in a good way, by tossing in Watergate and other bits of Spike’s outrage, which bloats a thin conceit into epic length. While the whole is appalling, there’s enough wit and competence on display to keep one watching, but at the end of 138 minutes, all you can say is, “Wow, that was a piece of shit.”

Wednesday, December 21, 2005

Triple Features at the Clark

Did you ever sit in the auditorium at the Clark? It’s comfy -- lots of elbow and leg room to stretch out. And a good thing too, since this winter I am inviting audiences to settle in for three long Sunday afternoons of filmwatching, three interconnected programs each day, in a series called “Triple Feature: 3 Colors, 3 Painters, 3 Studios.” So on the final Sunday of the next three months -- if you’ve got the seat for it, have we got a seat for you!

These marathon viewings for the iron-bottomed brigade are intended to add up to more than the sum of the parts, unique opportunities to survey a subject at one sitting. Alternatively, of course, you can pick and choose from the constituent programs, all of which are free admission, as is the museum itself in the off-season. So make a day of it -- visit the galleries, browse the museum shop, walk up Stone Hill, refresh yourself at the cafe, and then settle back in your easy chair for more highly visual viewing.

The first program in the series, on January 29, comprises Krzysztof Kieslowski’s Trois Couleurs trilogy: Bleu, Blanc, and Rouge. Blue will screen at 11:00 am, White at 1:30 pm, and Red at 4:00 pm.

Put together over the course of an amazingly productive year in 1993, these three films based on the tricolor of the French Revolution and the corresponding themes of liberty, equality, and fraternity -- addressed from a spiritual and not a political perspective -- were Kieslowski’s swansong to cinema. He withdrew from filmmaking after Red was released to international acclaim, and died in heart surgery little more than a year later, at the age of 54.

Kieslowski emerged from a documentary movement in Poland, eventually moving from tv to film. He broke into international recognition in the late Eighties with The Decalogue, a series for Polish tv, each hour segment jumping off from one of the Ten Commandments. Thereafter, he worked primarily in French, becoming a darling of the art house circuit with The Double Life of Veronique in 1991. Three Colors came next, the culmination of his meteoric career.

The three separate films have different casts of characters, but were put together by a single creative team, from scriptwriter and composer through the crew, except that each has a different cinematographer to highlight the respective colors in a distinctive visual scheme. And each has a luminous French actress to illuminate the emotional tone.

Blue belongs to Juliette Binoche. Losing her husband and daughter, she wants to cut herself free from all human relations, but the music she shared with her composer husband will not let her go, and draws her back to life and connection. Rarely has grief been explored with such tact and sensitivity.

Julie Delpy sets the black comedy of White in motion by humiliating her Polish husband in Paris divorce proceedings. He has to return to Warsaw to get his balls back, and regains equal status with her by making a killing in the new capitalist free-for-all. After being equally hurtful to each other, they love anew.

Irene Jacob was Veronique, and in Red she is Valentine, a sensitive heart-throb of a student and model in Geneva. She hits a dog with her car, and discovers the owner is a misanthropic retired judge played by Jean-Louis Trintignant. Opposites will attract, and the two form an unusual bond of fraternity.

But believe me, few films are less dependent on plot to weave their spell. The Three Colors are a symphonic cascade of sound and shade, incident and reflection, faces and feelings, gestures and acts. Immerse yourself and discover a new way of cinematic knowing.

Enigmatic but never obfuscating, these films demand an unusual quality of attention from viewers, to make all the connections and yet come face to face with the unsolvable puzzle at the center of the story, the mystery of motivation and the accident of destiny in each life.

Nobody could describe his purpose better than Kieslowki himself: “Film is often just business -- I understand that and it’s not something I concern myself with. But if film aspires to be part of culture, it should do the things great literature, music, and art do: elevate the spirit, help us understand ourselves and the world around us, and give people the feeling they are not alone.”

Beyond the nominal tricolor signification of liberty, equality, fraternity, this trilogy meditates on contingency, coincidence, synchronicity. The human situation in a world of chance and choice. In words of one syllable, these films are about life and death, love and fate. Let us ponder together.

This series continues with “Triple Feature: 3 Painters” on February 26: Artemisia at 11:00, Carrington at 1:30, Pollock at 4:00. And concludes with “Triple Feature: 3 Studios” on March 26, which will be a marathon exploration of animation way beyond Disney or Pixar, surveying the work of The National Film Board of Canada, Aardman Animation (of Wallace & Gromit fame), and the Hubley Studios -- Academy Award-winners all.

Syriana

Stephen Gaghan, writer of Soderbergh’s Traffic, gets to direct his own script here, and does well by his globe-spanning, densely-populated story which straddles the line between thriller and documentary. You know it is the product of research, that he has gone to those scenes and met those people, and recorded the dialogue almost verbatim within a fictionalized construct. This to me is a million times more real and effective than Fahrenheit 911, for example, in revealing the global politics and economics of oil and neo-colonialism. George Clooney is the grizzled, paunchy CIA operative who needs to come in out of the heat, before one of his own missles seeks him out. Matt Damon is a go-go energy trader who gets in over his head. Chris Cooper is a CEO engineering a huge oil company merger, and bribing his way to energy concessions in the volatile Middle East. Jeffrey Wright is a lawyer doing due diligence on the merger for rainmaker Christopher Plummer. The fictional Gulf emirate is represented by the dynastic struggle at the top and the unfortunate fate of immigrant oil workers at the bottom. You definitely have to pay attention to pick up the interweaving of plot strands, but huge amounts of information are delivered in passing, along with a “you are there” feel for some of the world’s trouble spots. When it comes to the role of oil in the world’s woe, this film is preaching to the converted in my case; I already believe the bastards of big oil (along with big pharma, as revealed in the vaguely similar Constant Gardener) are behind most of it. And this film strains my credulity less than Michael Moore. To get it, you need to work at it, and I like that in a movie. (2005, AMC in PA, n.) *8* (MC-76, RT-74.)

This is a busy season, of course, and my film viewing lately has been catch as catch can. I watched a couple of documentaries on the building of the Guggenheim in NYC, for a piece I was writing on Frank Lloyd Wright. The 25th anniversary of John Lennon’s murder brought a re-broadcast of Imagine, and since I’ve been revisiting Sixties musical icons lately, I was quite interested in this rather hagiographic documentary. Another blast from the past was Three Days of the Condor: Sydney Pollack’s 30-year old thriller about the CIA and oil holds up very well, better than most from the so-called golden age of Hollywood independents; the only real problem is that Robert Redford and Faye Dunaway are way too glamorous for their roles -- so much for gritty realism. Realism was the crux of 9 Songs, Michael Winterbottom’s recent leap over the barrier between feature films and pornography -- he makes explicit sex engaging and psychologically revealing, but just alternates bedroom with concert scenes, and leaves out the narrative structure that would make it compelling.

Sunday, December 11, 2005

The Squid and the Whale

Noah Baumbach’s swift and spare domestic tragicomedy makes its points, but not too many. It is less autobiographical venting than a precise dissection of familiar specimens. The sparing use of music is indicative, never to tug emotions but always pointed. I give it a plus for its portrayal of my old neighborhood of Park Slope. The parents of this disintegrating family are both writers, i.e. utterly self-absorbed. Jeff Daniels as the father is the more pathetic of the two; the film has the grace to feel sorry for him while it eviscerates his pretensions and inconsequentiality. Laura Linney as the mother is slightly more sympathetic, because she is Laura Linney, but is also a monster of obliviousness. The boys, 16-year-old Jesse Eisenberg and 12-year-old Owen Kline, emulate and act out the bad behavior of their parents. Everything is painfully true, woefully funny. As Philip Larkin tells us, “Your mum and dad, they fuck you up.” (2005, Images, n.) *8+* (MC-82, RT-95.)

Murderball

This is certainly a worthy documentary, but did not excite me as it has many. Its virtues may have seemed surprising seen fresh, but coming festooned with lavish praise, made me wonder what the fuss was about. Maybe my enjoyment is held back by medical squeamishness, though the matter-of-factness of its approach to quadriplegia is the film’s salient strength. The film also rolls past most of the cliches of competition stories, to peer into the community of the limbless that lies behind the sport of wheelchair rugby. Well worth watching on a number of levels, this doc did not strike me as an exemplar of the genre, for which public enthusiasm is now rising to meet my own. (2005, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-87, RT-97.)

Friday, December 09, 2005

The Triumph of Love

This Marivaux play from 1732 is handsomely mounted in an Italian villa, with sumptuous period costumes and decor. Directed by Claire Peploe and produced by hubby Bernardo Bertolucci, its handheld, jump-cut style, with postmodern flourishes, may have been chosen deliberately or dictated by budget constraints. The disjunction between style and subject strikes some as fresh but does not work for me. I have no idea what the original French may sound like, but this English translation seems rather flat-footed, with none of the poetry that sustains the silliness of a cross-dressing comedy like “As You Like It.” Nonetheless, this a well-acted piece. It makes one wonder where Mira Sorvino has been hanging out since Mighty Aphrodite -- turns out the magna cum laude graduate of Harvard has recently married and had a child, but will be back. Her princess has to seduce every character in the movie and she certainly seduced me. Ben Kingsley and Fiona Shaw delight as a brother and sister who have both forsworn love philosophically, only to succumb to the miraculous Mira. I didn’t like this as much as the Clark audience for the final “Fellows Favorite” film did, nicely primed by visiting scholar Melissa Hyde’s introduction, but I liked it more than the critical consensus. (2001, dvd@cai, n.) *6* (MC-58, RT-48.)

Speaking of the Fellows’ film series, I didn’t write about last week’s Rivers and Tides: Andy Goldsworthy Working with Time because I didn’t have anything new to say on third viewing. If you haven’t seen it, do so at your earliest convenience (and like all dvds shown at the Clark, it is subsequently borrowable from the Milne Public Library in Williamstown.) And if you have see the film, well then, I don’t have to tell you about the artist who ranks with Christo as my favorite contemporary. Interestingly, Clark Fellow Molly Donovan has done books with both, and her introduction offered valuable context to a large and appreciative audience, and a first look at Goldworthy’s recent installation at the National Gallery in Washington, for which she was curator.


A new group of Clark Fellows will resume this Thursday at 7:30 film series late next semester.

A Face in the Crowd

Before it devolves into a noisy rant, this Elia Kazan-Budd Schulberg follow-up to the imperishable On the Waterfront makes some prescient points about the midcentury marriage of media and politics. Andy Griffith debuts as an Arkansas drifter plucked by go-getting college girl Patricia Neal to feature on her radio program, named the same as the film. His calculated folksy charm goes over well and he’s soon on tv. It’s not long till his ability to woo and sway the public attracts the attention of a right-wing cabal of plutocratic politicos. The film breaks down when the character does, but up to that point it is all quite convincing, from the two leads down through an excellent cast that includes Walter Matthau, Anthony Franciosa, and Lee Remick, with walk-ons by the likes of Walter Winchell. Somewhere on the continuum between Mr. Deeds Goes to Town and Network, this is not a classic but bears watching. (1957, dvd, r.) *7*

Millions

A holiday heartwarmer is not what you expect from Danny Boyle, of Trainspotting and 28 Days Later fame, but that’s what he delivers here, from a screenplay by Frank Cottrell Boyce, frequent collaborator with Michael Winterbottom. Adorable urchin Alex Etel narrates and animates the story, as a 7-year-old who engages in easy conversation with saints in the flesh, asking if they’ve seen his recently dead mother in heaven yet. He’s in his backyard cardboard castle when a satchel of cash is thrown off a passing train. After his 9-year-old brother also sees the fantastical money, as he doesn’t the saints, they are in a quandary what to do with their found treasure. Boyle’s characteristic camera-trickery imbues this charming fairy tale with magic-realist energy, but the boys and the sentiments keep their sweet Nativity spirit. (2005, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-74, RT-88.)

Wednesday, November 30, 2005

Closer

Swank and stupid, this is as bad as a film directed by Mike Nichols and starring Julia Roberts, Natalie Portman, Jude Law, and Clive Owen could be. Meant to be blisteringly truthful about love and sex, it is more lurid and wearisome than revelatory. Yet again, dialogue taken for shocking and meaningful on the stage is revealed as shallow and stagey by the steady gaze of the camera. Still, there’s a lot of eye candy here, star power and sleek London settings, and some craft as well. Too bad all these talented people were not better employed. Carnal Knowledge, this ain't. (2005, dvd, n.) *5+* (MC-65, RT-68.)

Pride & Prejudice

I had a contrary reaction to this, compared to Walk the Line. Here I was the true fan, stringently judging how well the movie came up to the source material. And here I was ready for the film to end well before it finally did. Keira Knightley was certainly an appealing heroine, though hardly Jane Austen’s Elizabeth Bennett, the whatshisname Darcy was okay, as were some of the other players, but the best thing by far about this film were the realistic production values and the Constable-like views of the English countryside. But pictorial authenticity did not extend to a true sense of historical period and social mindset. Austen’s subtle nuance and insidious humor are Brontefied and Hollywoodized. Everything is overt and heightened, instead of gently unmasked. I was much more tolerant of the appropriations of Gurinder Chadha’s Bride and Prejudice. (2005, Images, n.) *7-* (MC-83, RT-86.)

Lilya 4-Ever

What makes this film watchable, as well as heartbreaking, is the luminous spirit of the title character, played by Oksana Akinshina. Lilya is a teenaged girl, abandoned by her mother in a ravaged post-Soviet landscape when she escapes to America with her thuggish boyfriend. Then Lilya is shunted aside by a wicked aunt who appropriates the mother’s apartment and sends her off to a dismal flat in which an old man has just died. Her downward spiral follows with all the inexorability of a Zola or Dreiser heroine. Betrayed by a friend who drags her to a disco where Russian new capitalists troll for young girls, Lilya’s each painful step into degradation is carefully delineated, mitigated only by the affection between her and a younger boy, cast out by a brutal father, with whom she forms her only remaining bond. When a handsome, gentle man offers to engineer her escape to Sweden, the boy is rightfully suspicious, and devastated when she grasps the one glimmer of hope afforded her. There is some parallel both in radiant beauty (light against dark) and in plight to the girl in Maria Full of Grace, but Lukas Moodyson, despite the gentleness so well expressed in Show Me Love and Together, is much more relentless in his depiction of her helpless descent. Snatched from the plane in Stockholm, Lilya is imprisoned in a featureless high-rise apartment and taken out only to be sold to a sickening succession of men, her only respite in relation to the remembered boy who is now a half-fledged angel, but unfortunately no guardian. Their whimsical reunion in some rooftop heaven is the only palliative to her dismal fate. Though the story of one indelible character, this film suggests a world of pain over the betrayal and exploitation of children. (2003, dvd, n.) *8* (MC-82, RT-85.)

Walk the Line

Charged by the magnetic performances of Joaquin Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon as Johnny Cash and June Carter, this film’s energy is well channeled by director James Mangold. Like Taylor Hackford of last year’s Ray, he is an underappreciated craftsman, and could have pushed his way on to my “10 Under 50” list of best young directors if I’d already seen this film, coming after Heavy, Cop Land, and Girl, Interrupted. (He is the son of painter Robert Mangold and grew up over in the Hudson valley.) But -- all props to the man behind the camera -- this film belongs to its stars, both the original performers and the actors embodying them, and ranks with Coal Miner’s Daughter at the head of a talented class of country music biopics. There are the traditional tropes of the genre: the hardscrabble childhood, the ravages of life on the road, the sex and drugs, the struggle to find one’s voice and then to sell it, on stage and in the recording studio, the importance of finding a nice house in the country at the end of the road. And there’s also an engaging love story. So it’s all very familiar, but very particular as well. True fans may complain that the film only captures a slice of Johnny Cash’s talent and stature, but for such as myself it was an admirable opening up of some unexplored peaks of the musical landscape. And I would gladly have spent more time in the engaging, exuberant company of Johnny/Joaquin and June/Reese. (2005, AMC Theater in PA, n.) *8* (MC-72, RT-82.)

Monday, November 28, 2005

Again with the diary

Here’s what I’ve been watching lately, none of which rates a strong recommendation. Though each is okay or better, I do not feel driven to apply a number rating or a full-fledged review. (Admittedly it’s an open question how mature the plumage is on even my reviews of widest span.) So on with it:

Two Days in October appeared on the PBS program “American Experience” and marks Robert Kenner as a documentarian to watch. It pairs up two events in 1967 that really paint a portrait of the era -- a Marine detachment is ambushed and massacred in the jungles of Vietnam, which the generals try to pass off as a victory, while back on the homefront at the U of Wisconsin, students sit in to protest Dow recruiters on campus and are violently routed by Madison city police, which radicalizes the entire campus. The mix of archival footage and talking head retrospect is extremely well put together and evocative.

Tarnished Angels is a Douglas Sirk from 1958, not on DVD but broadcast on Turner Classic Movies, in Cinemascope but surprisingly B&W after he had made a string of amazingly expressionistic color films. Adapted from the novel Pylon, this was declared the best film made from Faulkner by the author himself. The leads from Written on the Wind are re-teamed: Rock Hudson, Dorothy Malone, Robert Stack. The first two have some fresh moments, but the last is just his steel-jawed self. Hudson is a maverick reporter for the New Orlean Times-Picayune who becomes fascinated with the flying gypsies of a traveling airshow. Stack is a WWI flying hero now barnstorming in his biplane, with Malone his parachute-jumping wife. Complications ensue, with a good deal of wild chariot-racing low over the water and around the pylons. In some ways a preposterous period piece, in others the film bears the mark of Sirkian sophistication.

De-lovely is almost de-lightful. The Cole Porter songs certainly are, as is Kevin Kline in the lead role. Ashley Judd is appropriately swanky as his wife of convenience and a good deal more. This biopic is infinitely franker about Porter’s homosexuality than Night and Day starring Cary Grant, which is referenced in this film. The problem is that much is referenced but little is developed. There’s a half-heartedly meta- framing device, but the through-line is weak. The music and the performances are worth watching, however, and it’s a kick to hear Ashley tell Kevin that she is engineering his escape from Hollywood debauchery by purchasing a house in Williamstown, Massachusetts.

Reefer Madness: The Musical is jaunty and irreverent, a Sundance fave apparently. For two-thirds of its length, the energy of the singing and dancing definitely carry the story along; the final third spins out of control in a manner that failed to entertain me. I guess you could say the buzz wears off. Kristin Bell (tv’s Veronica Mars) is extremely effective as the ingenue; her death signals the film’s. Alan Cumming is snappy in a variety of roles. Neve Campbell pitches in a nifty dance piece, in support of her brother who plays the lead. Good dirty fun, for the most part, but when it goes over the top I am as reluctant to follow as a smart WWI soldier in a trench.

Monday, November 21, 2005

Hail Caesar! Hail HBO!

Last evening I brought myself up to date with two praiseworthy HBO original series. Oddly, I find I can’t write about tv the way I write about film. When you stop to think about it, they are different aesthetic experiences. A film seems a self-contained object, which can be judged objectively, with whatever subjective shading. A tv series on the other hand is more like a transaction between sender and receiver, a developing relationship which grows closer, uncritically, or fades away to pointlessness. I certainly formed a bond with Titus Pullo and Lucius Vorenus of the series Rome, watching riveted to the final shots of their first season. And also with Julius Caesar, as embodied nobly by Ciaran Hinds, memorable as Captain Wentworth in the superb film adaptation of Jane Austen’s Persuasion. It won’t be giving anything away to reveal that he dies at the end, a bloody corpse on the Senate floor. It’s good news that the rest of the characters we’ve come to know -- maternal monsters, mealy-mouthed polticos and martial heavyweights, would-be emperors and their families -- have been renewed for a second season. It really does bring ancient history alive, in a variety of ways. On a different scale from my film ratings, I would give Rome an A- as a tv series, ranking just behind The Wire and The Sopranos.

Incidentally, HBO will soon start rebroadcast of the first three seasons of The Wire, leading up to the premiere of season four, which may yet overtake Buffy the Vampire Slayer as my favorite tv series of all time. I for one will have my TiVo revved up to catch season three, not yet available on DVD. And while I’m at it, I may give the first season of Deadwood a try, now that it is on DVD.

In a different vein, HBO also produces the Paradise Lost documentaries of Joe Berlinger and Bruce Sinofsky. I’d heard good reports on the original, but it wasn’t available on DVD till very recently; the sequel was, but I avoided it till I could see the first. A third is now in the works, and it is not hard to see how the story compels an ongoing fascination. Paradise Lost: The Child Murders at Robin Hood Woods (1996) details the grisly case of three mutilated young boys found in a drainage ditch in West Memphis, AK, and the trials of three teenaged boys charged with killing them in a satanic ritual. The original documentary is credited with unblinking objectivity, but certainly seems to make the case for the railroading of the charged youths, seemingly more for their taste in clothes and music than for any actual evidence. You begin to assume that this film, like Errol Morris’s Thin Blue Line, will get an unjustly condemned man off death row. But no. Ten years later Damien Echols is still on death row, and his two friends in prison for life without parole. Reasonable doubt? There’s plenty. After the original documentary an internet-spawned group grew up to “free the West Memphis Three,” and they become the focus of Paradise Lost 2: Revelations (1999), along with the deeply scary stepfather of one of the victims, a drug-fueled camera-hound redneck behemoth who makes himself the best candidate for the actual murderer -- all he lacks is a leather mask and a chain saw. The amazing access, to families and suspects and lawyers and the court proceedings themselves, that drives the original, is shut off in the sequel and many key moments are covered by text on a black screen that explains they were forbidden to film. The film, however, compels one to the website -- www.wm3.org -- where one discovers the legal battle is ongoing, with the U.S. Court of Appeals just last month granting a plea of habeas corpus to Damien, who has also published poetry and a memoir written from solitary confinement. Not a word is said about the death penalty itself, but the whole case suggests the capriciousness with which it is sometimes dispensed. This is certainly a real-life courtroom drama to trump any fiction on the tube. As a tv series, it’s a definite A; as films, I would give the first a *7+* and the second a *7*, both essential representatives of the power of the documentary form.

Salvatore Giuliano

I didn’t really get this film when I saw it at MoMA thirty-odd years ago, and I still don’t. Francesco Rosi’s neo-neorealist reconstruction of the death and deeds of a Sicilian bandit leader in the years just after WWII is meticulous but incomprehensible. Shot in operatic black & white, on the actual sites of the events, with actual townpeople in all but two of the roles, the film uses time-fractured editing to depict a complicated tale of conspiracy and double-cross in postwar chaos, among the bandits, separatist politicians, and the Mafia. It’s like watching JFK if you had no antecedent knowledge of the facts of the case, though Rosi is an unturned Stone when it comes to wild speculation. Still, there’s something there about controlling insurgencies in the Mediterranean world, from Algiers to Baghdad, that comes through in this beautifully-presented Criterion Collection dvd. (1961, dvd, n.) *5+*

Sunday, November 20, 2005

The Son (Le Fils)

This film is so un-American, but perhaps that’s just what a Belgian film should be. Critical darlings Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne follow La Promesse and Rosetta with another penetrating look at proletarian life. The brothers remain true to their documentary roots, and to the environment in which they grew up. The long takes seem captured on the fly, though in reality carefully rehearsed. We see more of the protagonist’s neck than of his face, viewing most of the action from over his shoulder. Also un-Hollywood is the refusal to explain -- you have to watch intently and figure it out as you go -- plus the inversion of the typical revenge fantasy (or even atypical ones like In the Bedroom.) The brothers built the film around their favorite actor, Olivier Gourmet, but allowed it to grow from its initial inspiration into something quite strange and surprising, a gripping suspense story without any of the usual tropes of cinematic suspense. Olivier (the character) is a carpentry instructor in a trade school for delinquent boys, who takes an unsettling interest in one of his students, for deep but only gradually revealed reasons. But be forewarned, if you do not approach this film as a quest for understanding, it will frustrate and irritate you. (2002, dvd, n.) *7-* (MC-86, RT-89.)

In the proletarian vein, if you wish to dig a little deeper into the recent news from France, then I strenuously recommend that you watch La Haine, a 1995 film by Mathieu Kassovitz, a Parisian Mean Streets set in precisely the milieu that is now aflame.

Good Night, and Good Luck

George Clooney honors his news anchor father with this well-made tribute to Edward R. Murrow, superbly embodied by David Strathairn. With evident documentary intent, he lets Senator Joseph McCarthy play himself in old newsreels of his communist witch hunt days. The old tv footage blends seamlessly with the deep, rich black & white cinematography, which calls up the Fifties without ever stepping out of doors -- from smoke-filled studios where a crew of bespectacled go-getters use primitive technology to seat-of-the-pants the tv news, to the smoke-filled bar where they swirl bourbon in the glass and strategize the stuggle of a free press in a troubled time. A time, the estimable Mr. Clooney does not even need to imply, that bears some similarity to our own. He also evokes the spirit of the Fifties by effective use of a female blues singer as a sort of Greek chorus. The story is a bit thinly painted, though the canvas is large and looming -- it begins and ends with a lecture, with a civics lesson in between -- but this is honest work of high degree. As drama it lacks some elemental pull, but as dramatized documentary it is a mesmerizing swirl of smoke, infinitely preferable to anything Michael Moore might concoct. George Clooney, to me, is one American hero commenting on another, who inspired him in speaking truth to power. And David Strathairn is an absolute must for a Best Actor nomination, way beyond mimicry of Murrow to a deep channeling. It’s not a great film, but has many elements of greatness. (2005, Images, n.) *7+* (MC-80, RT-94.)

No Direction Home

Two American masters meet, Bob Dylan and Marty Scorsese, with appropriately epic results. This 3 1/2 hour documentary takes the generational icon up to his motorcycle accident in 1966, at age 25. What would it take to cover the subsequent forty years? I’d be eager to find out. I have friends who expressed impatience with the pace of this piece, but pace them, I happily took the whole ride, down memory lane and into the man of that moment -- a cocky kid and musical sponge with an amazing verbal facility, who bemusedly became the voice of a generation. There’s so much going on here -- the music, the history, the American fable of celebrity -- it seems more inexhaustible than exhaustive or exhausting. (2005, dvd, n.) *7+*

Hana-Bi (Fireworks)

There’s an undeniable charm to this fragmented but sentimental yakuza flick written, directed, acted, and painted by Takeshi Kitano, but this is another critical bandwagon I just can’t get on board. I leave it to the Tarantinos of this world. “Beat Takeshi” may be the Buster Keaton of Japan, but I find him as off-putting as ingratiating. His tangram storytelling, mixing pieces into various shapes, engages but does not convince. As the central character, a police officer who holds himself responsible for his partner getting shot and another officer killed, he turns to bank robbery to pay off loans from the mob, and to take his terminally ill wife on a final tour of Mt. Fuji, the ocean, and other Japanese sights. This film is sweet, funny, and (implicitly) violent, as assured as it is idiosyncratic, but it does not hold together for me, makes me watch but not follow. (1997, dvd, n.) *6*