This is a classic example of less-than-the-sum-of-its-parts. Director Niki Caro travels as far as she can from the New Zealand of Whale Rider to another distant outpost, in northern Minnesota mining country, for another tale of female empowerment, but she brings with her a sense of place, work, and community. Charlize Theron acts well enough that you occasionally forget how gorgeous she is, and she delivers a character cut from the true-life, working-class mold of Norma Rae or Erin Brockovich. Chris Menges’ cinematography is bleak and beautiful. The supporting cast is outstanding: Frances McDormand, Woody Harrelson, Richard Jenkins and Sissy Spacek, among others. There are well-chosen songs by North Country native, Bob Zimmerman (aka Dylan.) But the screenplay is only “inspired by” the true story of a precedent-setting class-action sexual harassment suit at an iron mine, and falls back on a variety of heart-tugging cliches; and either writer or director made some miscalculations with flashbacks and foreshadowings, so the film settles fatally for “inspiration” rather than truth. (2005, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-68.)
Steve Satullo talks about films, video, and media worth talking about. (Use search box at upper left to find films, directors, or performers.)
Sunday, July 02, 2006
An Inconvenient Truth
This is an important document, but not a great documentary. Al Gore’s well-honed, much-travelled slide show on global warming is interspersed with voice-over shots of him making his way from venue to venue. It is informative and alarming -- should be seen -- but director Davis Guggenheim does nothing to advance the art of documentary with this illustrated lecture plus filler. And as well as Gore comes off, he is much more impressive in direct and honest conversation with someone like Charlie Rose. Oh, to see the alternate universe where he actually took office in 2001 . . . !!! (2006, Images, n.) *NR* (MC-74.)
Tuesday, June 27, 2006
Dear Diary
It’s not that I’ve forgotten you, but how did I go two weeks without seeing a movie? Work and travel had something to do with it, but there were other distractions as well. Though I am now officially into “wait till next year” mode with my beloved Cleveland Indians, up till now I have been spending tube time with the Tribe that might otherwise have been devoted to films. I’ve also been reading recent novels by Marilynne Robinson, Alice McDermott, and now E.L. Doctorow.
And then there’s HBO. After the season’s end of The Sopranos and Big Love, I caught up with the second season of Deadwood, to prepare for the third, which is now underway and likely to finish as a best-ever nominee for me, unless it is supplanted by The Wire, whose third season I am stockpiling on TiVo for an orgy of viewing in advance of the upcoming fourth. I am baffled by the critics who say HBO original series are losing momentum -- they just can’t be paying attention. Of course, not everything HBO does is up to the high standard they set. Despite the presence of Helen Mirren, their Elizabeth I was sub-Masterpiece Theater in the sophistication of its storytelling, but sumptuous in its settings and costumes.
I did catch my own double feature at the Clark, to kick off the “Brother to Brother” film series. Of the two Elia Kazan films, On the Waterfront gets me every time, it's indelibly great. The only thing that bothered me, as it seems to do these days, was some of the music in the more intimate scenes. Out-and-out melodrama is one thing, but if you have some pretense to realism, in those tight two-shots let the actors do the work with their faces and voices, stifle the soaring strings. The jazzy dockside music is great though, and one of the audience reminded me the composer was Leonard Bernstein. Still, Brando and Saint were more than capable of carrying those scenes on their own. East of Eden was good to see in Cinemascope, even if projected digitally. The Monterey peninsula in WWI days vies with James Dean as the star of the picture. Raymond Massey is effective as his father, and so is Julie Harris as his brother’s girlfriend, but it all seems weighted with literary significance rather than blazing with the immediacy of Waterfront.
Next up is “Brothers Under Care” on Sunday, July 9th: What’s Eating Gilbert Grape? at 1:30 and Rain Man at 4:00. In the former, the brothers are Johnny Depp and Leonardo DiCaprio, directed by Lasse Halstrom; in the latter, Dustin Hoffman and Tom Cruise, from Barry Levinson.
Looking to appeal to a mixed group of family, I got around to watching Cinderella Man (2005, dvd, n.) and it certainly filled the bill, would have been a more plausible Best Picture than Crash. Though Ron Howard’s direction is practiced to a fault, with heart-tugging made to order from the true-life fairy tale of the amazing comeback of Depression-era boxer, Jim Braddock, it is smoothly done and the ever-surprising Russell Crowe invests his character with almost more reality than the film can bear. Paul Giamatti contributes a reliably engaging turn as the boxer’s manager and trainer. Renee Zellweger looks the part of the stalwart wife, but isn’t given much to do except stir the same ashes as Angela. It’s tasteful and inspiring, and easy to let yourself be manipulated by the movie. My responses are as mixed as the critics, which Metacritic averaged out to to MC-69, and I would rate as *6+* or *7-*.
Working on an intermittent retrospective of Ingmar Bergman, I took a look at the impeccable Criterion Collection dvd of Smiles of a Summer Night (1955, dvd, r.), an uncharacteristic French bedroom farce with a Swedish accent, or Oscar Wilde under the midnight sun. It’s really very well done in every respect, and gave Bergman the popular and international success that allowed him to go on to The Seventh Seal and the rest of the work with his dour signature. As sparkling as it is, and inspirational to Woody Allen and Stephen Sondheim, it took me three evenings to get through it this time, so my *7+* rating is somewhat provisional.
Finally, I just watched Separate Lies (2005, dvd, n.) Julian Fellowes won an Oscar for the screenplay of Gosford Park, and here makes his directorial debut. Tom Wilkinson and Emily Watson are reliably excellent as the well-off couple with a London townhouse and country home in High Wickham. He’s a successful but stuffy solicitor, and she’s a not-quite-right housewife and hostess. There’s an accident, moral quandaries, revelation of deceit, and slippage of personality. It’s quite watchable but doesn’t add up, though it doesn’t overstay its welcome by very much, at less than 90 minutes. If you’re a real Anglophile who loves to see a stiff upper lip quiver, you might like this, but for me it clocks in at a *6-* (MC-71.)
And then there’s HBO. After the season’s end of The Sopranos and Big Love, I caught up with the second season of Deadwood, to prepare for the third, which is now underway and likely to finish as a best-ever nominee for me, unless it is supplanted by The Wire, whose third season I am stockpiling on TiVo for an orgy of viewing in advance of the upcoming fourth. I am baffled by the critics who say HBO original series are losing momentum -- they just can’t be paying attention. Of course, not everything HBO does is up to the high standard they set. Despite the presence of Helen Mirren, their Elizabeth I was sub-Masterpiece Theater in the sophistication of its storytelling, but sumptuous in its settings and costumes.
I did catch my own double feature at the Clark, to kick off the “Brother to Brother” film series. Of the two Elia Kazan films, On the Waterfront gets me every time, it's indelibly great. The only thing that bothered me, as it seems to do these days, was some of the music in the more intimate scenes. Out-and-out melodrama is one thing, but if you have some pretense to realism, in those tight two-shots let the actors do the work with their faces and voices, stifle the soaring strings. The jazzy dockside music is great though, and one of the audience reminded me the composer was Leonard Bernstein. Still, Brando and Saint were more than capable of carrying those scenes on their own. East of Eden was good to see in Cinemascope, even if projected digitally. The Monterey peninsula in WWI days vies with James Dean as the star of the picture. Raymond Massey is effective as his father, and so is Julie Harris as his brother’s girlfriend, but it all seems weighted with literary significance rather than blazing with the immediacy of Waterfront.
Next up is “Brothers Under Care” on Sunday, July 9th: What’s Eating Gilbert Grape? at 1:30 and Rain Man at 4:00. In the former, the brothers are Johnny Depp and Leonardo DiCaprio, directed by Lasse Halstrom; in the latter, Dustin Hoffman and Tom Cruise, from Barry Levinson.
Looking to appeal to a mixed group of family, I got around to watching Cinderella Man (2005, dvd, n.) and it certainly filled the bill, would have been a more plausible Best Picture than Crash. Though Ron Howard’s direction is practiced to a fault, with heart-tugging made to order from the true-life fairy tale of the amazing comeback of Depression-era boxer, Jim Braddock, it is smoothly done and the ever-surprising Russell Crowe invests his character with almost more reality than the film can bear. Paul Giamatti contributes a reliably engaging turn as the boxer’s manager and trainer. Renee Zellweger looks the part of the stalwart wife, but isn’t given much to do except stir the same ashes as Angela. It’s tasteful and inspiring, and easy to let yourself be manipulated by the movie. My responses are as mixed as the critics, which Metacritic averaged out to to MC-69, and I would rate as *6+* or *7-*.
Working on an intermittent retrospective of Ingmar Bergman, I took a look at the impeccable Criterion Collection dvd of Smiles of a Summer Night (1955, dvd, r.), an uncharacteristic French bedroom farce with a Swedish accent, or Oscar Wilde under the midnight sun. It’s really very well done in every respect, and gave Bergman the popular and international success that allowed him to go on to The Seventh Seal and the rest of the work with his dour signature. As sparkling as it is, and inspirational to Woody Allen and Stephen Sondheim, it took me three evenings to get through it this time, so my *7+* rating is somewhat provisional.
Finally, I just watched Separate Lies (2005, dvd, n.) Julian Fellowes won an Oscar for the screenplay of Gosford Park, and here makes his directorial debut. Tom Wilkinson and Emily Watson are reliably excellent as the well-off couple with a London townhouse and country home in High Wickham. He’s a successful but stuffy solicitor, and she’s a not-quite-right housewife and hostess. There’s an accident, moral quandaries, revelation of deceit, and slippage of personality. It’s quite watchable but doesn’t add up, though it doesn’t overstay its welcome by very much, at less than 90 minutes. If you’re a real Anglophile who loves to see a stiff upper lip quiver, you might like this, but for me it clocks in at a *6-* (MC-71.)
Bread and Chocolate
I’m not sure why I resurrected this once-popular Italian comedy. I must have put it in my Netflix queue before I went to Italy last summer, though it retains some topicality as the story of a “guest worker” from Southern Italy in Switzerland. Franco Brusati is a nondescript director, and while star Nino Manfredi has his moments, he’s more like Roberto Benigni than Marcello Mastrioanni. There is some amusing byplay between Italian and Swiss viewpoints, and Anna Karina provides a charming cameo, but the dvd is of poor quality and the film is not particularly deserving of revival. (1973, dvd, r.) *6-*
Monday, June 12, 2006
The Verdict
Some talented people collaborate on a better-than-average courtroom drama: Paul Newman offers an un-showy performance as an alcoholic Irish ambulance chaser in Boston, who grabs his one last chance for redemption; David Mamet writes a snappy script and Sidney Lumet directs with assurance; James Mason and Jack Warden lead a solid supporting cast. They lend some credibility to what might have been a medical malpractice potboiler, but there is some final dimension of realism that this film lacks. My verdict -- not bad, but not special. (1982, dvd, r.) *6*
Heaven Can Wait
I don’t know much about the “Lubitsch touch” -- I have only a scattered acquaintance with his work -- but if this is it, I like it: a very adult comedy of marriage and morals, tightly stylized to avoid the censor, nothing slapstick about it. His first use of color, apparently, but most effective in setting off the decor of the Fifth Avenue mansion where most of the action takes place, changing over the course of fifty years, and the high Deco-style entryway to hell, where Don Ameche tells the tale of the life that he assumes will send him below. Gene Tierney is the wife he woos and wins repeatedly, despite his stagedoor-Johnny antics. A large cast of familiar faces fills out the cast, and the story is very sturdily constructed, with familial vignettes succeeding every ten years or so with endless parallels and cross-references. The dialogue and situations are humorous but subtle, light and dark at the same time, taking a clear look at sex and vanity, aging and death. This is a worthy resurrection by the Criterion Collection. (1943, dvd, n.) *8-*
The Playboys
Rarely have I taken note of music more deleterious to a film’s success, more like soap opera schmaltz than Celtic liveliness. Robin Wright (pre-Penn) does imbue the film with more liveliness than it otherwise demonstrates. Albert Finney and Aidan Quinn are more than adequate in stereotyped roles. There is a definite feel of authenticity to the portrayal of a village in 1957 Ireland, less cuteness than there might be in Gillies MacKinnon’s direction of a Shane Connaughton script, but it ultimately seems formulaic and inconclusive. Robin is the wild girl, pregnant by an unknown man, who upsets the balance of the staid little village. Finney is the imposing Garda sergeant, who is trying to reform his drinking to win her hand. Quinn blows into town with a travelling troupe of vaudeville players led by faux-Shakespearian Milo O’Shea, in a last gasp before the “wireless with pictures” takes over village entertainment. You can fill in the rest. (1992, dvd, r.) *5+*
Elia Kazan double feature at the Clark 6/18
In conjunction with the Clark’s special summer exhibition culminating its 50th anniversary year, The Clark Brothers Collect, the museum will offer a free film series called Brother to Brother: Sunday Afternoon Double Features at the Clark.
This series will explore the tangled fraternal relationship in films that range from the comic to the tragic, from classic to contemporary, from fiction to fact. Presented in pairs, what each film has in common, beyond skilled direction and strong performances, is riveting attention to this powerful sibling bond.
On June 18, the first program will present two films by Elia Kazan: On the Waterfront (1954) at 1:30 p.m. and East of Eden (1955) at 4:00 p.m. In addition to the fraternal theme, this pairing is a doubly appropriate start to the series, because Kazan is a Williams College alumnus and because these films were being made at precisely the time the Clark was originally being built.
Elia Kazan, born in Constantinople to Greek parents, came to this country when he was four and graduated from Williams in 1930. After dropping out of Yale Drama School, he became involved with the Group Theater in New York. Though he began as an actor, his goal was always to direct films. He began directing for the theater while also working on documentary films. By the end of World War II, he had made his first film, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, and continued to work on Hollywood projects, even while returning to New York to become one of the leaders of the Actors Studio and eventually the most prominent director on Broadway, instrumental in adapting Stanislavsky’s acting precepts into the “Method” and developing a new breed of star such as Marlon Brando. He’d already won an Academy Award for best director, for Gentleman’s Agreement, but was still working toward his signature style, incorporating aspects of Italian Neo-realism into films like Boomerang! and Panic in the Streets, shot on location and using non-actors as well as the intense naturalism of Method actors.
In 1951, Kazan transferred Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire from stage to screen, and then made Viva Zapata!, again with Brando, a sympathetic but knowing look at a peasant revolution. Kazan considered himself a lifelong liberal, but turned against the Communists in the Thirties. When Congress started its Red Menace witch hunt into Hollywood, Kazan was caught in the middle and found his accommodation in naming names that were already known to the House Un-American Activities Committee, thereby saving his career but forever alienating certain critics.
Some took On the Waterfront to be his defense of informing, but that implication makes a small part of a towering work, a popular success that earned eight Academy Awards, for Kazan and Brando, as well as writer Budd Schulberg, cinematographer Boris Kaufman, and supporting actress Eva Marie Saint. Rod Steiger, Lee J. Cobb, and Karl Malden were all nominated for best supporting actor, but split the vote.
Kazan followed the black & white grit of Waterfront with the Cinemascope color of East of Eden, John Steinbeck’s retelling of the Cain and Abel story set in California farm country, which introduced another iconic male star in James Dean. Kazan exploited the natural antipathy between Dean and Raymond Massey to highlight the conflict between son and father.
Kazan continued his strong run through the ’50s and into the ’60s, directing A Face in the Crowd, Wild River, Splendor in the Grass, and America, America (the story of his family’s immigration), before he fell into disfavor barely remedied by a special lifetime achievement Oscar he received in 1999 (or an honorary doctorate from Williams.) In the interim he had become a bestselling novelist and memoir writer. Now that he has died, it would be well to reconsider his career as a whole, and On the Waterfront and East of Eden, at the Clark on June 18, would be a good place to start.
Subsequent Brother to Brother programs will include:
July 9: “Brothers Under Care”: What’s Eating Gilbert Grape? (1993) at 1:30 p.m. and Rain Man (1988) at 4:00 p.m.
July 23: “Brothers in Fury”: Raging Bull (1980) at 1:30 p.m. and American History X (1999) at 4:00 p.m.
August 13: “Brothers at Work”: Big Night (1995) at 1:30 p.m. and Adaptation (2002) at 4:00 p.m.
August 27: “Brothers Documented”: Brother’s Keeper (1992) at 1:30 p.m. and Capturing the Friedmans (2003) at 4:00 p.m.
In September, watch for a "Brother to Brother Encore", a special two-day screening at the Clark of The Best of Youth, the six-hour Italian family epic hailed as the best film of 2005 by the New York Times and others, including me.
This series will explore the tangled fraternal relationship in films that range from the comic to the tragic, from classic to contemporary, from fiction to fact. Presented in pairs, what each film has in common, beyond skilled direction and strong performances, is riveting attention to this powerful sibling bond.
On June 18, the first program will present two films by Elia Kazan: On the Waterfront (1954) at 1:30 p.m. and East of Eden (1955) at 4:00 p.m. In addition to the fraternal theme, this pairing is a doubly appropriate start to the series, because Kazan is a Williams College alumnus and because these films were being made at precisely the time the Clark was originally being built.
Elia Kazan, born in Constantinople to Greek parents, came to this country when he was four and graduated from Williams in 1930. After dropping out of Yale Drama School, he became involved with the Group Theater in New York. Though he began as an actor, his goal was always to direct films. He began directing for the theater while also working on documentary films. By the end of World War II, he had made his first film, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, and continued to work on Hollywood projects, even while returning to New York to become one of the leaders of the Actors Studio and eventually the most prominent director on Broadway, instrumental in adapting Stanislavsky’s acting precepts into the “Method” and developing a new breed of star such as Marlon Brando. He’d already won an Academy Award for best director, for Gentleman’s Agreement, but was still working toward his signature style, incorporating aspects of Italian Neo-realism into films like Boomerang! and Panic in the Streets, shot on location and using non-actors as well as the intense naturalism of Method actors.
In 1951, Kazan transferred Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire from stage to screen, and then made Viva Zapata!, again with Brando, a sympathetic but knowing look at a peasant revolution. Kazan considered himself a lifelong liberal, but turned against the Communists in the Thirties. When Congress started its Red Menace witch hunt into Hollywood, Kazan was caught in the middle and found his accommodation in naming names that were already known to the House Un-American Activities Committee, thereby saving his career but forever alienating certain critics.
Some took On the Waterfront to be his defense of informing, but that implication makes a small part of a towering work, a popular success that earned eight Academy Awards, for Kazan and Brando, as well as writer Budd Schulberg, cinematographer Boris Kaufman, and supporting actress Eva Marie Saint. Rod Steiger, Lee J. Cobb, and Karl Malden were all nominated for best supporting actor, but split the vote.
Kazan followed the black & white grit of Waterfront with the Cinemascope color of East of Eden, John Steinbeck’s retelling of the Cain and Abel story set in California farm country, which introduced another iconic male star in James Dean. Kazan exploited the natural antipathy between Dean and Raymond Massey to highlight the conflict between son and father.
Kazan continued his strong run through the ’50s and into the ’60s, directing A Face in the Crowd, Wild River, Splendor in the Grass, and America, America (the story of his family’s immigration), before he fell into disfavor barely remedied by a special lifetime achievement Oscar he received in 1999 (or an honorary doctorate from Williams.) In the interim he had become a bestselling novelist and memoir writer. Now that he has died, it would be well to reconsider his career as a whole, and On the Waterfront and East of Eden, at the Clark on June 18, would be a good place to start.
Subsequent Brother to Brother programs will include:
July 9: “Brothers Under Care”: What’s Eating Gilbert Grape? (1993) at 1:30 p.m. and Rain Man (1988) at 4:00 p.m.
July 23: “Brothers in Fury”: Raging Bull (1980) at 1:30 p.m. and American History X (1999) at 4:00 p.m.
August 13: “Brothers at Work”: Big Night (1995) at 1:30 p.m. and Adaptation (2002) at 4:00 p.m.
August 27: “Brothers Documented”: Brother’s Keeper (1992) at 1:30 p.m. and Capturing the Friedmans (2003) at 4:00 p.m.
In September, watch for a "Brother to Brother Encore", a special two-day screening at the Clark of The Best of Youth, the six-hour Italian family epic hailed as the best film of 2005 by the New York Times and others, including me.
Monday, June 05, 2006
The Ice Harvest
John Cusack is something like a friend -- it’s always a pleasure to spend time in his company. The same is not true for Billy Bob Thornton, but here his comic sleaze is put to good effect. There is effective supporting work from Connie Neilson, Oliver Platt, and Randy Quaid. Harold Ramis directed the imperishable Groundhog Day and other estimable films; Robert Benton and Richard Russo have written some notable scripts (and the latter some favorite novels of mine); this contemporary noir clocks in efficiently at an hour and a half. So why did the movie sink like a stone last year? And why can’t I recommend it as an undiscovered gem. Maybe the humor gets in the way of its darkness or the darkness gets in the way of its humor. It’s setting in Wichita is not far from Fargo, but it’s tone is less certain. On a cold and rainy Christmas Eve, mob lawyer Cusack and pornography czar Thornton look to embezzle $2 mil from mob boss Quaid, with femme fatale Nielson also hanging in the balance. They’re well out of their depth, and complications ensue as Cusack goes from one titty bar to the next, getting drunker amidst the tinsel and carols of the season. If your expectations are low, you may well enjoy this genre exercise. (2005, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-62.)
Platform
You’re on your own with this one. Some reviews of The World (see 3-13-06) suggested this was a better film by Jia Zhangke, so I dutifully sat through it. The long-shot, long-take aesthetic is common in Asian cinema, and can sometimes be thrilling -- in Ozu, for example -- but films like this have me calling “Cut!” or “Close-up, please!” And this is the “streamlined” version, 158 instead of 193 minutes. The lack of a cultural (or even geographical) frame of reference makes such films a mixture of interest and frustration. This is obviously an autobiographical film about the changes in China in the 80s, from the perspective of a provincial performing troupe that goes from pageants celebrating Mao to head-banging, booty-shaking pop music. There are two desultory romantic involvements, but indicative of my troubles in watching this film, I mistook the couple in the final scene, and there was a baby whose parentage I got completely wrong (or most reviewers did.) (2001, dvd, n.) *NR*
Absence of Malice
The problem here is not an absence of justice but an absence of juice. Sydney Pollack’s film might have been a serious exploration of journalistic ethics, but in fact is redeemed only by the presence of Paul Newman. Now there’s a star -- he commands the screen even while hiding from view. Though there are wobbles in the script, and there’s less feel for the Miami locale than you would hope for, the real letdown is the female lead. Sally Field is just too perky to play quick, smart girl slowly and sadly learning wisdom. As the ambitious reporter, a Holly Hunter or Emily Watson or Samantha Morton would have been intense and conflicted enough to set off sparks with Newman and bring off the story. Sally’s too shallow to play callow. And the music is just awful, goosing nonexistent emotions. There are two highlights, however. The opening montage of putting out the newspaper, from newsroom to composing room to pressroom is a vintage look at a vanished world to which I’ve always been connected, in one way or another. And in the end, when Sally has messed her nest, she indicates she may go back to the paper where she started, The Berkshire Eagle. (1981, dvd, r.) *6-*
Tuesday, May 30, 2006
The White Diamond
The documentary form (“creative treatment of actuality” in the classic Grierson formulation) is capacious enough to contain Werner Herzog’s recent films, but truly they are personal essays written on film. He is not looking to record the “truth,” but his own wonderings and wanderings about subjects that attract him. He’s a trippy guy, and it’s a trip to take trips with him. To the Arctic for Grizzly Man and to tropical Guyana here, following the obsessive quest for flight (and “levity”) by the designer of a small airship intended to float over the jungle canopy. The other main character is a local sage called Redbeard, who dubs the contraption, “the white diamond.” It’s not what we would call diamond shaped, but later Herzog takes us to one of the local diamond mines, to see what a diamond looks like straight out of the ground, and sure enough the comparison is apt. I really wish I had seen this film in a theater, for the immersive spectacle of it, the prolonged rapture of something like the climactic shot when thousands upon thousands of swifts fly past the immense waterfall to their nesting place in the cliff behind. The film is random, jottings in Werner’s notebook, but cumulatively revelatory. (2005, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-83.)
Read My Lips
Though I wasn’t all that taken with The Beat That My Heart Skipped, it did lead me to Jacques Audiard’s earlier film, which makes fewer concessions to contemporary thriller conventions and hews closer to its Hitchcockian model -- less splatter, more nuance. Intense character study takes the foreground, while the caper remains distant and enigmatic, serving primarily to provoke character revelation. Emmanuelle Devos is a mouse-brown secretary for a major developer, integral to its operation, but blending into the background -- her desk is where everyone’s empty coffee cup winds up. She’s deaf without her two hearing aids, but uses that to her own advantage in tuning out the world. So does the film, with brilliant sound design, as well as stylish and intimate cinematography. When Devos looks sufficiently beset and bedraggled (no mean feat for such an alluring femme), her boss lets her hire an assistant to make copies and send faxes. She wants a man under her, for reasons that seem obvious but are highly complicated, and hires an ex-con scuzzball, Vincent Cassell, for the job. They attract and repel, but have what each other needs. The plot may have twists that don’t quite parse (who really cares about the maguffin?), but the psychology keeps getting deeper and deeper toward a most satisfying resolution. (2002, dvd, n.) *7+* (MC-82.)
Thursday, May 25, 2006
Duma
This is a well-made and enjoyable mix of real-life nature fable and boy’s own adventure, predictable in its emotional arc but surprising in its details. There are echoes of Twain and Kipling, among others, but director Carroll Ballard has his own vision as well, from The Black Stallion and Never Cry Wolf to Fly Away Home. Here a South African family finds a cheetah cub that has lost its mother, and raises it to adulthood, when it will need to be reintroduced into the wild. A few plot twists send the boy on a quest to return the cheetah to its natural habitat. Along the way, he meets up with a black man who will become his guide and antagonist. They traverse a desert and the Okavango, encountering all sorts of animals and adventures. The acting is all good or better, with the cheetahs stealing the show ("Duma" is cheetah in Swahili.) It says bad things about the state of moviemaking and distribution today, that Warner Brothers chose not to give this film any sort of launch and dumped it in theaters only at the behest of critics and advocates who had seen it. The dvd comes without significant extras either. This isn’t a great film, but I can recommend it as high-quality family entertainment. (2005, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-82.)
Turtles Can Fly
Set in Kurdish territory on the Iraq-Turkey border in the weeks before the U.S. invasion in 2003, this film by an Iranian Kurd, Bahman Ghobadi, looks at war from the perspective of children, but falls somewhat awkwardly between documentary and fable. Just about the only consumables in this village and adjacent refugee camp are leftover military supplies. Thirteen-year-old “Satellite” keeps squads of children busy digging up landmines (many of them consequently missing arms or legs) and exchanges them for guns, or a television dish so the village elders can watch news of the incipient war. He lives in an abandoned armored vehicle, and also has his troop stacking spent artillery shells. He falls for a refugee girl who lives in a tent with two “brothers,” one an armless teen with a gift of prophecy and the other a blind toddler who may be the product of a rape by Saddam’s soldiers. On the one hand, this is an important view into unfamiliar conditions, but on the other it’s a clumsy and confusing narrative which might be taken as hopeless exploitation of the impossible plight of victimized children. Sometimes humorous, sometimes queasily beautiful, it’s worth seeing but not ultimately sufficient to its subject. (2004, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-85.)
Saraband
Ingmar Bergman came out of retirement to direct this made-for-tv film, to revisit the couple from Scenes from a Marriage thirty years later. It’s a bit of a bait-&-switch, however, even though Liv Ullmann and Erland Josephson return as Marianne and Johan, now in their sixties and eighties respectively. The focus is on Johan’s grand-daughter, and his hateful relationship with her father, his son by a previous marriage. In the wake of her mother’s death, the beautiful 19-year-old girl is being held as an emotional hostage by her father, who has not only lost his loving -- even saintly -- wife but also his professorship and his leadership of a musical consort. The lovely girl is a cello prodigy, taught by her father, but now due to go to conservatory, and she is in danger of becoming a pawn in the lifelong conflict between her father and grandfather. Marianne comes into this volatile situation when she takes it into her head to drop in on Johan at his wilderness cottage, after years of no contract, despite Johan’s distaste for such “improvisations.” The film is composed of ten blackout duets between the various characters, with a prologue and epilogue by Marianne looking over a table full of photos and speaking directly to the camera. Bergman retains his capacity for intimate, soul-wrenching conversations, but also his grim take on human nature, the human condition, and all human relationships. The character duets are compelling, as is the music, but the visuals are perfunctory -- e.g. the picture postcard view from Johan’s front porch is exactly that, a picture postcard. The whole is well-made, in the manner of the master, but airless and hopeless, though not entirely unsympathetic. (2004, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-80.)
Thursday, May 18, 2006
Scenes from a Marriage
It’s an ironic result of the advent of DVD and TiVo that television has been revealed as an art with the same or even greater status than film. Freed of its arbitrary push-technology and mind-numbing interruption by commercials, the small screen has become the locus for the best of cinema, while the big screen goes the way of bloated blockbusters and movies that aspire to the condition of amusement park rides or live action comic books, instead of art. Case in point: Ingmar Bergman’s masterful Scenes from a Marriage, which was released to international acclaim as 168-minute feature in the Seventies, and is now finally revealed by this recent Criterion Collection release in its original and transcendent form, as a Swedish tv series of six 50-minute hours. No wonder it became the sort of tv phenomenon that empties the streets of a country for an hour each week. The medium suits Bergman’s style well: interior and intimate, intense and spare. His dialogue retains the sting of documentary veracity while coming across as an artful construction, somehow lofty and pared down at the same time. And if you are going to spend five hours in very close company with two ordinary characters, you could hardly find two better actors than Liv Ullmann and Erland Josephson. He’s a prematurely stodgy academic gradually realizing the hollowness of his great expectations and wised-up certainties. She’s a divorce lawyer who is also a submissive wife, until her husband walks out on her, giving her the opportunity to become a genuine person. Neither is really likable, but both win our sympathy, however wincing the self-recognition. This is aestheticized talk therapy of the highest order. (1973, dvd, r.) *9-*
Consider the following in appraising my claim for the artistic supremacy of television: Poland’s Decalogue, Italy’s Best of Youth, Germany’s Heimat, Britain’s Bleak House or The Office, America’s HBO series such as The Wire, The Sopranos, Deadwood and others, not to mention the various broadcast programs that only reveal their true genius when viewed like a novel, with sustained attention -- Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Freaks & Geeks being two that I am passionate about. Of course the general range of TV is easily as trashy as the movies, I’m merely arguing that the peaks are at least as high.
Consider the following in appraising my claim for the artistic supremacy of television: Poland’s Decalogue, Italy’s Best of Youth, Germany’s Heimat, Britain’s Bleak House or The Office, America’s HBO series such as The Wire, The Sopranos, Deadwood and others, not to mention the various broadcast programs that only reveal their true genius when viewed like a novel, with sustained attention -- Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Freaks & Geeks being two that I am passionate about. Of course the general range of TV is easily as trashy as the movies, I’m merely arguing that the peaks are at least as high.
The New World
Critical opinion is generally divided on philosopher Terrence Malick’s infrequent forays into filmmaking. Metacritic shows a clutch of 100 ratings for this film, but also a number of 50s, including several from critics I normally agree with. In this case I favor the former -- I don’t see how you can have the patience for something like Tropical Malady, and not be willing to stick with Malick and his obsessions. Though criticized for snoozy nature documentary and woozy historical revisionism, this retelling of the Pocahontas story struck me as vivid, lovely, and reverberative. Given its scope, it squeaks past The Squid and the Whale as my favorite American film from last year. Q’Orianka Kilcher makes a striking and moving debut as the Indian maiden navigating between new world and old; by herself she makes the movie worth seeing, much as Keisha Castle-Hughes did in Whale Rider. Colin Farrell and Christian Bale perform well as John Smith and John Rolfe, respectively, though Malick’s focus is less on the actors than the on-location authenticity of the Jamestown and Indian settlements, and in the end on Jacobean England. Malick’s films tend to be more meditation than movie, but the magic and mystery of this New World never lost me for a minute. (2005, dvd, n.) *8+ (MC-69.)
Thursday, May 11, 2006
The Intruder
Another challenge to the film viewer’s powers of persistence, Claire Denis’ film riveted my attention for the first hour, but in the second hour the hypnotic spell wore off for me and enigma fatigue set in. As lovely and striking as it was to look at, the film lacked the human or narrative connection to keep me alert. Under different conditions I might have been awake to its delights and provocations through to the end. The first half is set in the mountains on the French-Swiss border, and the latter half in Tahiti. The protagonist is a burly sensualist, whose heart starts to fail while he is swimming, biking and screwing in the mountains. Weird, inexplicable things happen, but he seems to buy himself a new heart on the black market, and then returns to Tahiti on a quest I never really figured out. At least some of the scenes represent his dreams, and the time sequence is fractured. Frankly, I was glad to put the puzzle behind me when the closing credits rolled. To really appreciate the sort of spell that Denis can weave, see her Beau Travail. (2005, dvd, n.) *NR* (MC-84.)
Darwin's Nightmare
Hubert Sauper’s documentary is jagged and not well put together, but startling in its moments of unexpected beauty and painful insight. A bucket of fish dropped into immense Lake Victoria sometime in the ’60s has become an ecological and economic disaster. The voracious Nile Perch has devoured 200 other species of fish and now cannibalizes its own young, creating a monoculture exploited by neo-colonialist powers. The big transport planes fly in empty -- unless they are bringing in weapons from merchants of death to fuel African civil wars -- and fly out to Russia and the EU filled with tons of processed fish. The local Tanzanians are left with fish-heads to process into a vile soup, and plastic containers the kids can burn and huff like glue. There is no longer the basis for a local economy, except working for the man plantation-style or selling your body to pilots or other outsiders with money. Meanwhile international officials go on tv to extoll the economic development betokened by the booming fish industry. The film is doubly hard to watch, because the harsh reality is so grim and stark, but also because its structure is haphazard and elliptical. Important but not great filmmaking. (2005, Sund/T, n.) *7-* (MC-84.) (This is a good point to observe that the Metacritic rating system is far from scientific, since they assign the numerical ratings to reviews that are then averaged, and it’s clear those numbers are influenced by the unknown tabulator’s own appreciation of the film. A New Yorker review, e.g., might read like a 100 rating to you, but only an 80 to me, since my initial enthusiasm does not match yours. But still, subjectivity compounded achieves at least some objectivity, a la The Wisdom of Crowds, and places my own rating in a context of critical consensus.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)