As a confirmed auteurist, I generally approach films with the notion that the controlling artist is the director, but for once I’ve been taking a fanboy approach and making my way through the collected works of Barbara Stanwyck. At one level, I can’t presume to compete with the appreciation written by Anthony Lane in The New Yorker two years ago, on the hundredth anniversary of her birth. But besides offering a film series at the Clark called “An Artist in Her Own Right: Barbara Stanwyck and the Modern American Woman,” I’ve been filling in my knowledge of her immense filmography, and I have some highlights to share.
Night Nurse. (1931) Like Baby Face, this is part of TCM’s “Forbidden Hollywood” collection, but not at all what one would expect. Yes, these nurses do seem to change out of their clothes quite frequently, but that is incidental to the way that Barbara Stanwyck both seduces and challenges the medical establishment, as she does the right thing in revealing a plot against a pair of children in her care. The mother -- in the sort of Depression-era characterization of the irresponsible rich that we are likely to be seeing more of in coming days -- is in thrall to bootleg liquor, jazz, and the evil chauffeur Clark Gable, who is scheming to get his hands on the children’s trust fund. Joan Blondell is Stanwyck’s fellow nurse, and there is a fair bit of attention to what a nurse’s career actually entails before the suspense kicks in. Besides the abundant underwear shots, the ending in which the “good” guy gets away with murder was a flagrant flouting of the production code, which is recalled in a documentary included as an extra on this dvd.
Baby Face. (1933) I had not seen this entire movie, definitely not in its pre-censorship state, so I was surprised by its sharpness and wit, and pleased by how well it was received by the Clark audience. It’s delectable to see our Barbara at work, with absolute confidence in her power over men. She’s not conventionally beautiful, despite the dialogue that reinforces that notion throughout her career, but she has no doubt about her desirability. The certainty of allure is the key to her career. I enjoyed swotting up her biography for my introduction to the film series. Ruby Stevens, born in Brooklyn in 1907, became a tough broad at an early age. Her mother died in a trolley car accident when she was very young, and her father took off, leaving four children to fend for themselves among family and foster homes. Ruby left school for good at 13 and lived with her older sister, who was a showgirl. By 15 she was in a Ziegfield chorus line herself, and before she was 20 had a hit on Broadway, under the new name of Barbara Stanwyck. Within a year, she was making films in Hollywood, and kept doing so for sixty years. Parallels to the protagonist of this film suggest themselves, as she sleeps her way up a ladder of men. Maybe it’s just acting, but there’s an unsettling conviction about it. After beginning my intro with Anthony Lane’s remark, “When I think of the glory days of American film, at its speediest and most velvety, I think of Barbara Stanwyck,” and assertion that “no actress delivered a more accomplished body of work,” I wrapped up with the conclusion from David Thomson’s essay on her, “She was honest, sharp, gutsy, and smart. Terrific.”
Annie Oakley. (1935) This films seems to signal Stanwyck taking control of her career and her image. No longer a contract player in films like Ladies of Leisure, Forbidden, The Woman in Red, she was free to move between studios and choose her own material. So in this film she is the legendary heroine, demure though dead-eye, who comes out of rural southern Ohio to become an international star of Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show. Here Barbara first displays the riding skill that will stand her in good stead for decades to come. The romance is a little saccharine, and leaves the proto-feminist comedy of the sure-shot woman behind, but George Stevens does mount some impressive Wild West spectacles, which suggest that the movies actually began fifty years before -- before film was even invented.
Stella Dallas. (1937) Apparently Sam Goldwyn had a lot of emotion as well as money invested in this remake of his 1925 hit. Barbara Stanwyck was not among his first half-dozen choices for the title role, but made it her own and earned her first Oscar nomination, as well as locking in the essential duality of her persona, the tough exterior masking an inner nobility, or at least personal resolve. Selfless mother was not her most comfortable role -- neither in film nor life -- but even her self-sacrifice is made on her own terms. King Vidor’s film is not great, but Stanwyck’s performance qualifies as iconic.
Golden Boy. (1939) Wow, William Holden seems startlingly young in his debut. Apparently Stanwyck took the young actor under her wing (she was famous for her cordial relations with co-workers on the set, part of an impeccable professionalism) and I believe he wound up handing her a “golden boy” decades later, when she finally won an honorary Oscar. As usual, she has great rapport with her fellow lead, who is electric as the shy Italian violinist who becomes the brash boxing champ. Rouben Mamoulian’s adaptation of the Clifford Odets’ play is sharp and smooth, with surprisingly good fight scenes despite the clanking plot. Barbara is caught between her boy and long-time squeeze Adolphe Menjou, his manager. Joseph Calleia is amusingly tough as the gangster who wants a piece of the boy, and Lee J. Cobb (just six years older than Holden) plays the ethnic dad. This really needs to be added to the topflight films of Hollywood’s annus mirabilis.
Remember the Night. (1940) In an obvious nod to It Happened One Night, this romantic comedy of a mismatched couple on a road trip brings together Barbara Stanwyck and Fred MacMurray, in a far cry from Double Indemnity. He’s a hotshot district attorney, and she’s apprehended after shoplifting from a Fifth Avenue jewelry store. When he sees that the public defender is successfully playing on the jury, he has the case postponed till after Christmas break. Of course he is not immune to our Barbara’s charms, feels guilty that she will spend the holiday in jail and arranges bail, and when he finds out she’s from Indiana too, offers to drive her home for Christmas. I don’t need to tell you how it turns out, but a witty script from Preston Sturges and smooth direction from Mitchell Leisen, along with the chemistry of the leads, certainly make this a palatable holiday confection.
The Lady Eve. (1941) Stanwyck’s peak -- and Preston Sturges’ as well. I wanted my series to build toward it, so only later did I find out it was made earlier than Ball of Fire, which probably explains why it was the latter that earned her second Oscar nod. Certainly she plays well in that ensemble, but here she is the centerpiece, the absolute jewel in the setting, in a brilliant quasi-dual role as adventuress and aristocrat, even though they are “definitely the same dame.” As usual, she partners effectively with Henry Fonda, and Sturges at his best goes Wilde, so this remains firmly among the most delightful of all American comedies.
You Belong to Me. (1941) Stanwyck’s chemistry with Fonda was immediately capitalized upon in this misnamed follow-up, written and directed by Wesley Ruggles. Here she is a dedicated doctor on a skiing vacation, and he is a playboy who is immediately smitten when she tends to him after an accident on the slopes. He soon proposes and she declines, citing the demands of her career, but when he promises not to interfere with her practice of medicine, she accedes. The promise is easily made, but push soon comes to shove, and she is out the door at the most frustrating moments. Henry has made his bed and now must sleep in it -- alone. You will be relieved to hear that the resolution does not involve our Barbara giving up her career for her marriage, but you know it wouldn’t have been a Stanwyck movie if she had.
Ball of Fire. (1941) Just so, Sugarpuss O’Shea may have fallen for her “Pottsy” -- he-man nerd Gary Cooper, in another re-pairing from that same year (Frank Capra’s Meet John Doe) -- but there’s no doubt the showgirl will continue to wrap the professor around her little finger, or maybe her shapely ankle. Billy Wilder’s script and Howard Hawks’ accomplished screwball direction made this a big escapist hit when it came out around the time of Pearl Harbor. Amazing though these four films in the same year may be, a few years later Stanwyck’s career reached another peak when in 1944 she edged out Betty Davis as the highest-earning woman in America, apparently on the basis of films that are mostly forgotten, except for:
Double Indemnity. (1944) There’s that ankle again, this time Fred MacMurray’s undoing. It seems that working with Stanwyck only made you want to do it again. So Wilder turned to her when he turned director with a bang. It’s possible to take this film merely as a chilly exercise in style, but stylish it is, and Stanwyck, MacMurray, and Edward G. Robinson invest it with recognizably human qualities.
Sorry, Wrong Number. (1948) I suppose Stanwyck got her final Oscar nomination for playing against type as the helpless, bedridden woman menaced by ominous phone calls. But this thriller continually betrays it source in a radio play, and Stanwyck is only herself in the flashbacks, which show her as a rich girl claiming Burt Lancaster as her husband. It’s no surprise that he is scheming to escape her invalid clutches. Anatole Litvak’s direction is smooth enough, but the transposition of radio to film seems slight and artificial.
East Side, West Side. (1949) But here’s one I found much more substantial than its reputation, despite the soap opera plot of will-she-or-won’t-she stay with her straying husband. James Mason as Stanwyck’s rich lawyer husband is drawn to the wilder side of town by the strikingly young and tempting Ava Gardner, while good guy Van Heflin moons over Barbara, waiting to save her from her degradation as betrayed wife. She talks over her dilemma with best friend Nancy Davis, soon to be Reagan. It’s a period piece, to be sure, but nicely put together by Mervyn LeRoy, with a genuine feel for New York City.
The Furies. (1950) Here’s how I reviewed this last winter: “I’m not really up to speed with Anthony Mann’s Freudian Westerns, aside from one or two of the Jimmy Stewarts, but this transposition of King Lear to the New Mexico desert reeks of incestuous passion. Walter Huston, in his last film, is a cantankerous cattle baron, with Barbara Stanwyck as his spirited daughter, a mare who will not be broken. In noirish black and white, with more night scenes and interiors than wide open spaces, the film is a little much, but not enough, if you know what I mean. The leads are magnetic but much that surrounds them is laughable. Only for aficionados of one sort or another.” That of course includes Stanwyck fans, and this is a foretaste of the Westerns which would predominate in her later career, jumping off from her real-life ownership of a ranch.
Clash by Night. (1952) This would have been the final film in my Stanwyck series, if the budget allowed. I would have been glad to see it again, but I will simply quote what I wrote in my filmlog shortly before I started this website: “Fritz Lang’s noirish adaptation of Clifford Odets’ play is set with some reality in a Monterey fishing and canning village. Barbara Stanwyck is effectively wised-up as the defeated wayward girl who returns home and settles for marriage to Sicilian fishing boat captain Paul Douglas. Robert Ryan is the bad man with whom sparks fly. A very young Marilyn Monroe plays the lively, expansive girl that BS might once have been. The script is literate, if filled with a lot of hooey on the battle of the sexes, and Lang’s direction is careful and shapely. Aside from the baby who is little more than a plot point, this is a believable kitchen sink drama.”
Executive Suite. (1954) Directed by Robert Wise from a script by Ernest Lehman, this is an unusually intelligent and still-relevant business drama, as five executives vie for control of a furniture company after the president dies suddenly. Each has a strategy based on their speciality, numbers man Frederic March squaring off especially against innovator William Holden, in a battle for the soul of the company and the support of disenchanted heiress Stanwyck.
Forty Guns. (1957) In an extremely gutsy role for a fifty year old woman to take on, especially for crazed director Samuel Fuller, Stanwyck keeps all forty of those guns at her disposal, whether it’s thundering across the countryside on horseback, leading the phalanx like a troop of private cavalry, or sitting in satin and frills at the head of a banquet table where they again line up in two docile rows. But forty pistols are not enough, so when Barry Sullivan wanders on the scene, she goes after another. She obviously does her own riding and stunts, including being dragged by the heel in the stirrup of a horse spooked by a twister, in this jaw-dropping take on Western mythology, dripping with sexual innuendo.
Crime of Passion. (1957) This low-budget noir offshoot is notable for completing the picture of Ms. Stanwyck as a woman who will not be kept down. She’s a Miss Lonelyhearts at a San Francisco paper, who gets a big scoop by bringing in a woman who killed her husband, in the process meeting LA homicide detective Sterling Hayden. Sparks fly, more or less believably -- Babs is still pretty well put together at 50, though clearly her character is meant to be in her 30s -- and soon she is giving up that big break at a New York paper, and going to live in an LA bungalow with her cop hubby. No bungalow is big enough to hold our gal, and the parties where the cop buddies play poker in living room while their wives talk about nothing at all in the kitchen quickly drive her insane. Soon she’s scheming to advance her husband’s career, and then she really loses her mind, just like the lost souls who used write her for advice. This decent B-movie is a waystation on Stanwyck’s path to revival of her career in television, where she won three Emmys to make up for the four Oscars she failed to take home.
Roustabout. (1964) When her career descended to B-movie status, Barbara Stanwyck did not fall as far as other classic Hollywood screen goddesses, no Baby Janes for her. No, she’s still trim and sharp, hip to the younger crowd, as the carnival owner who encourages a certain drifter to stick around and work for her. Maybe she was in fact working for Elvis (or Col. Parker), but I know who stole the show for me. In widescreen and garish color, the tough old broad holds her own against the gyrations of all those kids.
For further Stanwyck favorites, here’s a site where various people pick their own five best.
Steve Satullo talks about films, video, and media worth talking about. (Use search box at upper left to find films, directors, or performers.)
Tuesday, September 01, 2009
Waltz with Bashir
I would have to see this film a second time to render a firm judgment. Nonetheless I am recommending it, though you may find yourself, as I did, drifting and dozing momentarily in the course of it. This may have something to do with the dream-like spell the animated documentary weaves. The conflict between Israel and Palestine is one over which I maintain a calculated ignorance, so the events of the 1982 war in Lebanon were not lodged in my memory, which would have made this film more coherent and engaging to me. But I loved the animation, found it potent even when it repeated or when I lost the thread. The film starts with a dream sequence of wild dogs running through a city, which the dreamer recounts to the film’s director, Ari Folman (or his animated avatar), leading Folman to try to recover his own suppressed memories of the experience as a 19-year-old soldier. He does this by going to interview fellow vets, also animated, and then illustrating their memories. My point of comparison would be Generation Kill, for its first person view of the chaos and horror of war. (2008, dvd, n.) *7 (or better)* (MC-91)
Two Lovers
James Gray is halfway interesting as a writer-director, and his latest film is halfway interesting too. A filmmaker’s dependence on other films can be a plus or a minus, but I found it a distraction here, like a parlor game. Yep, there’s Rear Window and there’s Vertigo. The outer borough view of Manhattan as a distant fantasyland seems lifted from Saturday Night Fever. But the whole story is virtually a remake of the Israeli film, Late Marriage, going so far as to import the actor who plays the central character’s father. Joaquin Phoenix does carry the film in what purports to be his last acting role, as a young man trying to recover from a bout of mental illness, with the good luck to be caught between two women, Gwyneth Paltrow as the amazing shiksa who appears on his doorstep in Brighton Beach and Vinessa Shaw as the plainly beautiful Jewish girl who has been arranged for him, to seal the merger of their fathers’ dry cleaning chains. All these characters seem authentic in their behavior, believably poignant and pathetic, and earnestly romantic. The supporting players definitely add flavor, with Isabella Rossellini as an improbable but convincing Jewish mother and Elias Koteas as the suave Manhattan lawyer with whom Joaquin must vie for the attentions of Gwyneth. But the sense of real people and real emotions is undermined by the quotation marks around many scenes, and the conclusion suffers from comparison to the exquisitely wrought coda to Late Marriage. Maybe I would have liked it better without the baggage of constant reference to other films, but perhaps that wouldn’t be an impediment to your enjoyment. (2008, dvd, n.) *6+* (MC-74)
Sunday, July 12, 2009
Docs rock!
Let me start with a confession of bias. To me, film originated with two opposing impulses -- Lumiere vs. Melies, the train pulling into the station vs. the rocket to the moon -- which I characterize as documentary vs. fabulation. I am a lifelong member of the party of Lumiere, and it’s not just that I prefer documentaries to fiction films, but that fiction films appeal to me by how much they document a real world, and lose my interest when they depend on fantasy and fashion. So following a rundown of features that I couldn’t quite bring myself to recommend, here’s a variety of nonfiction films that I heartily endorse. If the subject interests you, each is worth seeking out.
Scandalously unable to finance another feature after the high critical acclaim and low public response to The House of Mirth (2000), Terence Davies turned to documentary, and returned to the theme of his earlier films about growing up Catholic and gay in postwar Liverpool. Of Time and the City (2009, MC-81) is an unapologetic mash-up of poetry and music, archival footage and cinematic contemplation of Liverpool as it has become today. Davies is crotchety as well as passionate, acerbic as well as lyric. He appropriates, uncredited, a lot of poetry that was immediately familiar to me, notably Eliot’s “Four Quartets,” and music ranging from Mahler to dancehall. Along with images old and new, words and music weave a mood of reverie, of celebration and regret, in 72 artful and highly personal minutes. Davies may not be a guy you’d want to know, but he expresses himself in a film you ought to see.
Speaking of things you ought to see but don’t really want to, War Photographer (2002, MC-79) follows the career of James Nachtwey as he documents war and famine, devastation and destitution, around the globe, from Bosnia to Rwanda to Indonesia and beyond (after the film was made, he was seriously injured in Iraq, but seems to have recovered). Nachtwey is a quiet, even subdued personality who funnels all his passion into steely acts of attention and witness. Director Christian Frei follows him into the heart of the action, and the photographer also has a mini-cam attached to his camera, so we share his view as he takes his pictures. Besides the witness to human suffering, this film proffers a provocative debate on the ethics of photography, in implicit answer to Susan Sontag. What might be ghoulish sensationalism is rendered admirable by the hushed intensity of focus that the photographer brings to his anguished subjects.
Trouble the Water (2008) also follows behind and incorporates the images of a witness to devastation, in this case Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath in New Orleans. The eyewitness in this case is a 24-year-old woman from the Lower Ninth Ward, who couldn’t afford the “luxury” of evacuation and took refuge with family and others in the attic of one house as their neighborhood was inundated, wielding her camcorder the while. Documentarians Carl Deal and Tia Lessin discover her and her footage of the storm, and then follow as she and her husband escape to the relative paradise of Memphis but then return to participate in the reconstruction of New Orleans. Kimberly Roberts is a force of nature herself. Daughter of a drug addict who died of AIDS, she initially seems a bit wacked, but is gradually revealed as strong and articulate, with a rap persona who winds up crafting some powerful songs about the disaster, including the title song that plays over the final credits. Spike Lee’s When the Levees Broke will remain the definitive view from outside of Katrina, but this film offers an intense and ultimately uplifting view from the inside. No dvd release has been scheduled yet, but it has been shown on HBO. Watch for it.
Scandalously unable to finance another feature after the high critical acclaim and low public response to The House of Mirth (2000), Terence Davies turned to documentary, and returned to the theme of his earlier films about growing up Catholic and gay in postwar Liverpool. Of Time and the City (2009, MC-81) is an unapologetic mash-up of poetry and music, archival footage and cinematic contemplation of Liverpool as it has become today. Davies is crotchety as well as passionate, acerbic as well as lyric. He appropriates, uncredited, a lot of poetry that was immediately familiar to me, notably Eliot’s “Four Quartets,” and music ranging from Mahler to dancehall. Along with images old and new, words and music weave a mood of reverie, of celebration and regret, in 72 artful and highly personal minutes. Davies may not be a guy you’d want to know, but he expresses himself in a film you ought to see.
Speaking of things you ought to see but don’t really want to, War Photographer (2002, MC-79) follows the career of James Nachtwey as he documents war and famine, devastation and destitution, around the globe, from Bosnia to Rwanda to Indonesia and beyond (after the film was made, he was seriously injured in Iraq, but seems to have recovered). Nachtwey is a quiet, even subdued personality who funnels all his passion into steely acts of attention and witness. Director Christian Frei follows him into the heart of the action, and the photographer also has a mini-cam attached to his camera, so we share his view as he takes his pictures. Besides the witness to human suffering, this film proffers a provocative debate on the ethics of photography, in implicit answer to Susan Sontag. What might be ghoulish sensationalism is rendered admirable by the hushed intensity of focus that the photographer brings to his anguished subjects.
Trouble the Water (2008) also follows behind and incorporates the images of a witness to devastation, in this case Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath in New Orleans. The eyewitness in this case is a 24-year-old woman from the Lower Ninth Ward, who couldn’t afford the “luxury” of evacuation and took refuge with family and others in the attic of one house as their neighborhood was inundated, wielding her camcorder the while. Documentarians Carl Deal and Tia Lessin discover her and her footage of the storm, and then follow as she and her husband escape to the relative paradise of Memphis but then return to participate in the reconstruction of New Orleans. Kimberly Roberts is a force of nature herself. Daughter of a drug addict who died of AIDS, she initially seems a bit wacked, but is gradually revealed as strong and articulate, with a rap persona who winds up crafting some powerful songs about the disaster, including the title song that plays over the final credits. Spike Lee’s When the Levees Broke will remain the definitive view from outside of Katrina, but this film offers an intense and ultimately uplifting view from the inside. No dvd release has been scheduled yet, but it has been shown on HBO. Watch for it.
Rahmin Bahrani, American neorealist
Rahmin Bahrani is emerging as one of the most interesting young filmmakers in America. His latest -- Goodbye Solo -- may seal the deal, but I haven’t seen it yet, though its reception prompted me to catch up with his first two films. Born in North Carolina and educated at Columbia, he then spent several years in his parents’ native Iran before returning to America to make films. The influence of Kiarostami is evident, as are the antecedent debts to Italian neorealism, Satyajit Ray, and Robert Bresson.
Man Push Cart (2005, MC-71) is a deceptively simple Sisyphean parable of a Pakistani immigrant in NYC, who every day before dawn wheels his coffee cart into traffic and drags it many blocks to its spot on the street, the play of neon reflections on its faceted stainless steel a silent commentary on the man’s dark, drab existence. The repetitive process is rendered with grim lucidity, which is enlivened by chance encounters on the street, with a girl from Barcelona who is filling in at a relative’s news stand, and a yuppie from Lahore who recognizes the pushcart man as formerly a successful singer back in Pakistan. But romance or rediscovery is not in the cards for our hero, just the daily grind of pushing that rock up that hill. It could all be very depressing, but comes across as astringent and bracingly real.
Chop Shop (2008, MC-83) takes place in a realm that seems fantastical but is utterly factual, a little slice of the Third World right in the Big Apple -- Willets Point, a twenty-block area of fly-by-night auto repair shops, presided over by the looming presence of Shea Stadium. We follow 12-year-old Alejandro, an apparent orphan, as he works odd jobs and small crimes to survive, while allowed to live above one of the repair shops. He is thrilled when his 16-year-old sister Isamar comes to live with him, but not so thrilled when he learns what she has to do to get by. They dream of getting a burrito van of their own. Bahrani’s world is not one where dreams have much chance of coming true, but where life is lived as if it’s real, in a savvy mix of exhilaration and despair.
Man Push Cart (2005, MC-71) is a deceptively simple Sisyphean parable of a Pakistani immigrant in NYC, who every day before dawn wheels his coffee cart into traffic and drags it many blocks to its spot on the street, the play of neon reflections on its faceted stainless steel a silent commentary on the man’s dark, drab existence. The repetitive process is rendered with grim lucidity, which is enlivened by chance encounters on the street, with a girl from Barcelona who is filling in at a relative’s news stand, and a yuppie from Lahore who recognizes the pushcart man as formerly a successful singer back in Pakistan. But romance or rediscovery is not in the cards for our hero, just the daily grind of pushing that rock up that hill. It could all be very depressing, but comes across as astringent and bracingly real.
Chop Shop (2008, MC-83) takes place in a realm that seems fantastical but is utterly factual, a little slice of the Third World right in the Big Apple -- Willets Point, a twenty-block area of fly-by-night auto repair shops, presided over by the looming presence of Shea Stadium. We follow 12-year-old Alejandro, an apparent orphan, as he works odd jobs and small crimes to survive, while allowed to live above one of the repair shops. He is thrilled when his 16-year-old sister Isamar comes to live with him, but not so thrilled when he learns what she has to do to get by. They dream of getting a burrito van of their own. Bahrani’s world is not one where dreams have much chance of coming true, but where life is lived as if it’s real, in a savvy mix of exhilaration and despair.
Rossellini's Historical Films
The Criterion Collection once again proves its inestimable value and exquisite taste with an Eclipse boxed set of “Rossellini’s Historical Films: Renaissance and Enlightment.” Though made for tv broadcast and popular consumption, Rossellini’s late films seem esoteric and strange, until you fall under their spell and they become an acquired taste. The Rise to Power of Louis XIV, separately released by Criterion, is certainly the most approachable of those I’ve seen, but in this set the one that gripped my attention was Blaise Pascal (1972); it certainly had me taking down my old paperback of the Pensees and grazing through my old annotations. I liked when Pascal bested Descartes in disputation, but Rossellini went on to give fair play to the latter in Cartesius (1974), never a thinker I cottoned to but whose life was interesting to follow. I confess to fast-forwarding through parts of the three-episode Age of Cosimo de Medici (1973), though the third part, which focuses on Leon Batista Alberti, is consistently fascinating. First off, let’s grant that these films are long and slow, with lengthy bits of argument and exposition somewhat awkwardly declaimed, but their pageant-like quality, with devotion to scenic verisimilitude and patient reenactment, offers a wide window into the past. I eagerly anticipate another set that will include Socrates and The Messiah.
Speaking of esoteric, I won’t do much of a postmortem on my “Four Seasons in Japan” film series, but will note my pleasure in drawing a more than decent audience for such high-flown fare, and look forward to cultivating that audience in that time slot, with my Cinema Salon Film Club at the Clark starting in September. Of these four, Ugetsu was a bit of disappointment, most of the Mizoguchi images that stuck in my mind must have come from Sansho the Bailiff, but there are still more films of his I would be eager to see when they become available. When a Woman Ascends the Stairs certainly held up, on a second viewing within a relatively short period, and I tracked down another Naruse film, Late Chrysanthemums, which whets my appetite for more. A re-viewing of An Autumn Afternoon merely confirmed how much I love Ozu, certainly among my favorite directors. And Ran was a revelation -- turns out I had never seen it, just the start on an inadequate videotape -- proving that Kurosawa was a master to the end.
Speaking of esoteric, I won’t do much of a postmortem on my “Four Seasons in Japan” film series, but will note my pleasure in drawing a more than decent audience for such high-flown fare, and look forward to cultivating that audience in that time slot, with my Cinema Salon Film Club at the Clark starting in September. Of these four, Ugetsu was a bit of disappointment, most of the Mizoguchi images that stuck in my mind must have come from Sansho the Bailiff, but there are still more films of his I would be eager to see when they become available. When a Woman Ascends the Stairs certainly held up, on a second viewing within a relatively short period, and I tracked down another Naruse film, Late Chrysanthemums, which whets my appetite for more. A re-viewing of An Autumn Afternoon merely confirmed how much I love Ozu, certainly among my favorite directors. And Ran was a revelation -- turns out I had never seen it, just the start on an inadequate videotape -- proving that Kurosawa was a master to the end.
Boston blackguards
Confusable with Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead in multiple ways, What Doesn’t Kill You (2008, MC-71.) also stands in the shadow of The Departed, Mystic River, and Gone Baby Gone, so it’s no surprise it came and went without notice, despite worthy performances by Mark Ruffalo and Ethan Hawke, and an authentic directorial perspective on South Boston from Brian Goodman, telling more or less his own story. Ruffalo plays him, and he himself plays the gang leader under whose sway the two longtime friends chafe, each going astray in his own way, with one headed for redemption and one for oblivion. It’s all done well enough (including Amanda Peet as the wife), but not well enough to stand out in a crowded field.
I also caught the recent Criterion release of the granddad of all these films, The Friends of Eddie Coyle (1973), directed by Peter Yates from the George V. Higgins novel. Not exactly Bullitt goes to Boston, this film suffers from too many “friends” and not enough Eddie, in the person (and presence) of Robert Mitchum. He’s a small-time hood and Quincy family man in a bind, running guns and facing time, negotiating with other crooks and the cops, caught in a web he doesn’t begin to discern. At times this film plays like an instructional documentary for a bank heist, and at others like a primer on deviousness, as the bad and not-so-good guys make their deals in the shady bars of Boston, and on the plaza of the then-new City Hall. As gritty and downbeat as it gets, as meticulous and observant as it is, this film lacks a beating heart, ending with only a flashing neon sign in an almost empty bowling alley parking lot.
I also caught the recent Criterion release of the granddad of all these films, The Friends of Eddie Coyle (1973), directed by Peter Yates from the George V. Higgins novel. Not exactly Bullitt goes to Boston, this film suffers from too many “friends” and not enough Eddie, in the person (and presence) of Robert Mitchum. He’s a small-time hood and Quincy family man in a bind, running guns and facing time, negotiating with other crooks and the cops, caught in a web he doesn’t begin to discern. At times this film plays like an instructional documentary for a bank heist, and at others like a primer on deviousness, as the bad and not-so-good guys make their deals in the shady bars of Boston, and on the plaza of the then-new City Hall. As gritty and downbeat as it gets, as meticulous and observant as it is, this film lacks a beating heart, ending with only a flashing neon sign in an almost empty bowling alley parking lot.
Wednesday, July 08, 2009
Next at The Clark
An Artist in Her Own Right:
Barbara Stanwyck and the Modern American Woman
Free Films Saturdays at 2:00 in the Clark Auditorium
Like Georgia O’Keeffe’s, Barbara Stanwyck’s career spanned most of the 20th century, and according to film scholar David Thomson, reveals the most “credible portrait in cinema of a worldly, attractive, and independent woman in a man’s world.” Brooklyn-born orphan Ruby Stevens became a showgirl in her teens and by the age of 20 she was starring on stage as Barbara Stanwyck and moving on to a 60-year career in Hollywood as a tough, smart, funny, and sexy leading lady. This series will survey the best of Stanwyck’s groundbreaking work from the same era as the O’Keeffe paintings displayed in the Clark’s special summer exhibition.
July 18: Baby Face. (1933, 70 min.) A barmaid marshals her assets and climbs man by man from the basement to the penthouse. This startlingly explicit film is notorious for leading to the Hollywood production code that desexualized film for decades.
July 25: Stella Dallas. (1937, 106 min.) A millworker marries a rich man, and after a divorce, poignantly gives up her daughter to a better life. This classic “woman’s weepie,” directed by King Vidor, earned Stanwyck her first Academy Award nomination.
August 1: Ball of Fire. (1941, 111 min.) A gang moll takes refuge with a group of seven professors (i.e. dwarves) and instructs them in compiling an encyclopedia of slang. Howard Hawks directs Stanwyck to her second Oscar nomination, as she charms the flustered Gary Cooper.
August 8: The Lady Eve. (1941, 97 min.) A con woman supreme wraps a bumbling herpetologist beer heir around her little finger – twice! No Oscar nod, but perhaps her greatest performance, in Preston Sturges’ classic screwball comedy, opposite Henry Fonda.
August 15: Double Indemnity. (1944, 107 min.) The ultimate femme fatale lures an insurance agent into a plot to kill her husband. Film noir doesn’t get any darker than Billy Wilder’s great thriller. Stanwyck indelibly earns her third Oscar nomination by seducing Fred McMurray (and the audience) while trying to outsmart Edward G. Robinson.
Barbara Stanwyck and the Modern American Woman
Free Films Saturdays at 2:00 in the Clark Auditorium
Like Georgia O’Keeffe’s, Barbara Stanwyck’s career spanned most of the 20th century, and according to film scholar David Thomson, reveals the most “credible portrait in cinema of a worldly, attractive, and independent woman in a man’s world.” Brooklyn-born orphan Ruby Stevens became a showgirl in her teens and by the age of 20 she was starring on stage as Barbara Stanwyck and moving on to a 60-year career in Hollywood as a tough, smart, funny, and sexy leading lady. This series will survey the best of Stanwyck’s groundbreaking work from the same era as the O’Keeffe paintings displayed in the Clark’s special summer exhibition.
July 18: Baby Face. (1933, 70 min.) A barmaid marshals her assets and climbs man by man from the basement to the penthouse. This startlingly explicit film is notorious for leading to the Hollywood production code that desexualized film for decades.
July 25: Stella Dallas. (1937, 106 min.) A millworker marries a rich man, and after a divorce, poignantly gives up her daughter to a better life. This classic “woman’s weepie,” directed by King Vidor, earned Stanwyck her first Academy Award nomination.
August 1: Ball of Fire. (1941, 111 min.) A gang moll takes refuge with a group of seven professors (i.e. dwarves) and instructs them in compiling an encyclopedia of slang. Howard Hawks directs Stanwyck to her second Oscar nomination, as she charms the flustered Gary Cooper.
August 8: The Lady Eve. (1941, 97 min.) A con woman supreme wraps a bumbling herpetologist beer heir around her little finger – twice! No Oscar nod, but perhaps her greatest performance, in Preston Sturges’ classic screwball comedy, opposite Henry Fonda.
August 15: Double Indemnity. (1944, 107 min.) The ultimate femme fatale lures an insurance agent into a plot to kill her husband. Film noir doesn’t get any darker than Billy Wilder’s great thriller. Stanwyck indelibly earns her third Oscar nomination by seducing Fred McMurray (and the audience) while trying to outsmart Edward G. Robinson.
Potpourri
I defy you to find any connection amongst them -- neither style nor era nor nationality --but here’s a quick rundown of some films I’ve been watching lately, each worthy in its way but not something I would urge you to put in your Netflix queue unless some detail piques your interest.
Given what Kate Winslet and director Peter Jackson have gone on to since, I was interested to revisit Heavenly Creatures (1994). Jackson’s transition from his early splatter movies (unseen by me) to the imaginative fantasies of his Lord of the Rings trilogy (seen by everyone) is blessedly reticent with the bloodletting, though it details a real-life murder in 1950s New Zealand. As a tale of adolescent lesbian infatuation and the intense fantasy world the girls create for themselves, the film is so convincing and absorbing that it’s a shame it has to come round to a sensational climax. The Kate Winslet character went on in real life to become the British writer of historical mysteries, Anne Perry.
I remembered being impressed with Lady with a Dog (1959) decades ago, but I don’t know what prompted me to watch it again, though I do know that I would have enjoyed it more if I had read the Chekhov story first, since while this Russian film is lovely, it is so filled with soulful staring into space that it would have helped to be able to fill in the interior monologue. As a quiet study of bygone manners and passions, Josif Heifits’ film was a striking surprise to come out of the Soviet era.
Watching all the Rossellini I can get my hands on, I got around to the one commercial success of his career, Generale Della Rovere (1960), which stars a superlative Vittorio De Sica as a collaborationist con man and gambler, who tries to save his own skin by impersonating a resistance leader at the behest of the Nazis. In prison he comes to know the men he’s spying on, and by indirection himself, as he becomes the fearless leader he pretends to be. This is a waystation, or even an aberration, on the way from Rossellini’s classic postwar neorealism to the televised docudramas that occupied the end of his career, with the staginess and meticulous mise en scene looking backward and forward at the same time. Purportedly Rossellini and DeSica got together and decided to make a film that would win the Golden Lion at Venice and revive both their careers, and then they did so. The Criterion dvd has some excellent extras, including interviews with Isabella and the other Rossellini children, which bring out how autobiographical the film was for both men.
Anthony Mann is one of those directors who was once seen as a Hollywood journeyman and is now seen as an auteur, and I have been belatedly catching up on his oeuvre, so I made a point of recording Man of the West (1958) when it came round on TCM. Unfortunately, what seems archetypal to some seems formulaic and implausible to me. Likewise, some have no trouble with the fact that Gary Cooper is decades older than the character he is meant to portray, in fact older than Lee J. Cobb who plays his uncle, the raging gang leader whose protege he once was. Cooper has gone straight but Cobb longs to drag him back into his Old West crime family. Julie London is on hand as a saloon canary (though she never gets to sing), to demonstrate Cooper’s innate nobility and the gang’s sexualized nastiness.
I had never seen a Batman movie nor thought I would, but credible recommendations and an opportunity to watch on big-screen hi-def led me to take a gander at The Dark Knight (2008). Yes, there is some impressive visual spectacle. Yes, there is the appeal of familiar faces in so many roles, notably the late Mr. Ledger. Yes, Christopher Nolan directs this comic book for adults, with characters and situations that are indeed impressively dark. But yes, it is awfully long and exhausting, and no, you don’t have to see it if you don’t want to.
Given what Kate Winslet and director Peter Jackson have gone on to since, I was interested to revisit Heavenly Creatures (1994). Jackson’s transition from his early splatter movies (unseen by me) to the imaginative fantasies of his Lord of the Rings trilogy (seen by everyone) is blessedly reticent with the bloodletting, though it details a real-life murder in 1950s New Zealand. As a tale of adolescent lesbian infatuation and the intense fantasy world the girls create for themselves, the film is so convincing and absorbing that it’s a shame it has to come round to a sensational climax. The Kate Winslet character went on in real life to become the British writer of historical mysteries, Anne Perry.
I remembered being impressed with Lady with a Dog (1959) decades ago, but I don’t know what prompted me to watch it again, though I do know that I would have enjoyed it more if I had read the Chekhov story first, since while this Russian film is lovely, it is so filled with soulful staring into space that it would have helped to be able to fill in the interior monologue. As a quiet study of bygone manners and passions, Josif Heifits’ film was a striking surprise to come out of the Soviet era.
Watching all the Rossellini I can get my hands on, I got around to the one commercial success of his career, Generale Della Rovere (1960), which stars a superlative Vittorio De Sica as a collaborationist con man and gambler, who tries to save his own skin by impersonating a resistance leader at the behest of the Nazis. In prison he comes to know the men he’s spying on, and by indirection himself, as he becomes the fearless leader he pretends to be. This is a waystation, or even an aberration, on the way from Rossellini’s classic postwar neorealism to the televised docudramas that occupied the end of his career, with the staginess and meticulous mise en scene looking backward and forward at the same time. Purportedly Rossellini and DeSica got together and decided to make a film that would win the Golden Lion at Venice and revive both their careers, and then they did so. The Criterion dvd has some excellent extras, including interviews with Isabella and the other Rossellini children, which bring out how autobiographical the film was for both men.
Anthony Mann is one of those directors who was once seen as a Hollywood journeyman and is now seen as an auteur, and I have been belatedly catching up on his oeuvre, so I made a point of recording Man of the West (1958) when it came round on TCM. Unfortunately, what seems archetypal to some seems formulaic and implausible to me. Likewise, some have no trouble with the fact that Gary Cooper is decades older than the character he is meant to portray, in fact older than Lee J. Cobb who plays his uncle, the raging gang leader whose protege he once was. Cooper has gone straight but Cobb longs to drag him back into his Old West crime family. Julie London is on hand as a saloon canary (though she never gets to sing), to demonstrate Cooper’s innate nobility and the gang’s sexualized nastiness.
I had never seen a Batman movie nor thought I would, but credible recommendations and an opportunity to watch on big-screen hi-def led me to take a gander at The Dark Knight (2008). Yes, there is some impressive visual spectacle. Yes, there is the appeal of familiar faces in so many roles, notably the late Mr. Ledger. Yes, Christopher Nolan directs this comic book for adults, with characters and situations that are indeed impressively dark. But yes, it is awfully long and exhausting, and no, you don’t have to see it if you don’t want to.
Breaking Bad & other worthy TV
I’m off my film watching and reviewing stride, so I going to start to catch up with a few firm recommendations for long-form viewing, tv originals now on dvd.
Breaking Bad went through two seasons on AMC without attracting my attention, despite being promoted along with Mad Men. But I came across an article that compellingly praised the second-string cable channel for having the two best shows on tv. With the first season already out on dvd, it was easy to try out this series, and soon jump on the growing critical bandwagon. If you tend to like HBO series, then take a look at what AMC is doing. The creator of Breaking Bad is Vince Gilligan, a veteran of The X-Files, which means nothing to me, and the star is Bryan Cranston, of Malcolm in the Middle and other tv that I have never seen. But together they’re doing something special here -- taking an unlikely premise and spinning it out to absurd yet oddly convincing lengths. Cranston is a straight-arrow high school chemistry teacher in Albuqueque, who is diagnosed with inoperable lung cancer, and to build a nest egg for his family before he dies, decides to “break bad” and start cooking crystal-meth. Complications ensue, which I will allow you to discover for yourself. (Any resemblance to the premise of Weeds is decidedly superficial, though it’s possible this is more of what Pineapple Express wished to be, ordinary guys in an action movie situation.) This series is culturally and socially observant, suspenseful and funny, grisly and wry, with great characterizations from a large cast of characters who are easy to become involved with. After the initial seven hour-long episodes, I’m eager for the second season to come out on dvd or re-run on AMC. This show is more interesting and amusing than any chemistry class has a right to be.
Having re-watched all 26 episodes of The World at War for the first time since it was broadcast in 1974, I have to say that it stands up very well as a panoptic view of the cataclysmic events of WWII. With footage from German, Russian, and Japanese archives, as well as the American and predominantly British viewpoint, you see things rarely witnessed before or since. Laurence Olivier’s narration and the plangent music are perfectly and memorably pitched. And there is a poignancy in the first-person recountings from the early Seventies, which are more distant from us than they were from the events themselves. This series is a window on a perspective we always need to keep in view.
As a big fan of the Emma Thompson-Kate Winslet Sense & Sensibility directed by Ang Lee, I didn’t feel the urge to watch the three-hour Masterpiece Classic version broadcast on PBS last year, but I did finally catch up with it on dvd, and I have to say that for those of us who can never get enough Jane Austen (as long as her memory is not traduced by the adaptation), this is well worth watching, with exceptional location shooting for a tv series and solid performances from Hattie Morahan and Charity Wakefield, who do not supplant Emma and Kate but offer new shadings to the sensible and sensitive Dashwood sisters and their errant suitors. Classic, indeed.
Breaking Bad went through two seasons on AMC without attracting my attention, despite being promoted along with Mad Men. But I came across an article that compellingly praised the second-string cable channel for having the two best shows on tv. With the first season already out on dvd, it was easy to try out this series, and soon jump on the growing critical bandwagon. If you tend to like HBO series, then take a look at what AMC is doing. The creator of Breaking Bad is Vince Gilligan, a veteran of The X-Files, which means nothing to me, and the star is Bryan Cranston, of Malcolm in the Middle and other tv that I have never seen. But together they’re doing something special here -- taking an unlikely premise and spinning it out to absurd yet oddly convincing lengths. Cranston is a straight-arrow high school chemistry teacher in Albuqueque, who is diagnosed with inoperable lung cancer, and to build a nest egg for his family before he dies, decides to “break bad” and start cooking crystal-meth. Complications ensue, which I will allow you to discover for yourself. (Any resemblance to the premise of Weeds is decidedly superficial, though it’s possible this is more of what Pineapple Express wished to be, ordinary guys in an action movie situation.) This series is culturally and socially observant, suspenseful and funny, grisly and wry, with great characterizations from a large cast of characters who are easy to become involved with. After the initial seven hour-long episodes, I’m eager for the second season to come out on dvd or re-run on AMC. This show is more interesting and amusing than any chemistry class has a right to be.
Having re-watched all 26 episodes of The World at War for the first time since it was broadcast in 1974, I have to say that it stands up very well as a panoptic view of the cataclysmic events of WWII. With footage from German, Russian, and Japanese archives, as well as the American and predominantly British viewpoint, you see things rarely witnessed before or since. Laurence Olivier’s narration and the plangent music are perfectly and memorably pitched. And there is a poignancy in the first-person recountings from the early Seventies, which are more distant from us than they were from the events themselves. This series is a window on a perspective we always need to keep in view.
As a big fan of the Emma Thompson-Kate Winslet Sense & Sensibility directed by Ang Lee, I didn’t feel the urge to watch the three-hour Masterpiece Classic version broadcast on PBS last year, but I did finally catch up with it on dvd, and I have to say that for those of us who can never get enough Jane Austen (as long as her memory is not traduced by the adaptation), this is well worth watching, with exceptional location shooting for a tv series and solid performances from Hattie Morahan and Charity Wakefield, who do not supplant Emma and Kate but offer new shadings to the sensible and sensitive Dashwood sisters and their errant suitors. Classic, indeed.
Friday, June 12, 2009
Now Showing at The Clark
“Four Seasons in Japan: A Cycle of Film Classics”
Free Films Fridays at 4:00 in the Clark Auditorium
This series samples the classic work of four Japanese masters of cinema, who made the postwar era a golden age of film in Japan. Rising from the ashes of atomic annihilation and the humiliation of surrender and occupation, Japanese cinema burst on to the international scene when Kurosawa’s Rashomon won the grand prize at the Venice film festival in 1951, with Mizoguchi winning there the next three years.
Ozu achieved posthumous recognition when Tokyo Story was belatedly released abroad in the ’70s, its supreme achievement gradually confirmed as part of a seamless and peerless fabric of work, when his later films were rediscovered. In the ’80s Naruse was revived to critical acclaim but little distribution, becoming a special favorite of cinematic cognoscenti. All four of these directors had extremely prolific careers that bridged the devastation of World War II, and while many of their films are hard to find, the visible tip of the iceberg is monumental indeed.
June 12: Ugetsu. (1953, 96 min.) Kenji Mizoguchi’s celebrated tale follows a 16th century potter who leaves home to sell his wares in the midst of a civil war, and is captivated by a ghost princess. His signature style, with a gliding camera that unfolds scenes like a Japanese scroll, conveys the magic and mystery of the uncanny without blinking at the gritty reality of a war-torn world. Mizoguchi (1898-1956) is also known for The Life of Oharu and Sansho the Bailiff, among other undiscovered gems.
June 19: When a Woman Ascends the Stairs. (1960, 110 min.) Mikio Naruse’s modern story examines the life of a woman who ascends (and descends) the stairs to the Ginza bar where she serves as a female companion to businessmen, in a niche between geisha and prostitute. Naruse (1905-1969) shares a slow and stately style with Ozu, though his focus tends to be harder edged and grimmer in implication, so almost none of his films are easy to find.
June 26: An Autumn Afternoon. (1962, 112 min.) Yasujiro Ozu’s valedictory film recapitulates his customary themes, with a widower marrying off his daughter as the modern postwar world supplants traditional Japanese ways. As more of his films become available, the place of Ozu (1903-1963) in the pantheon of great directors becomes more certain. The Clark caps last summer’s popular “Seasons of Ozu” film series with this final testament to his genius.
July 3: Ran. (1985, 160 min.) Akira Kurasawa’s culminating masterpiece adapts King Lear to a mythical samurai past with pageantry and passion, mounting some of the most spectacular battle scenes ever filmed. Kurosawa (1910-1998) was the youngest and by far the most Westernized of these four masters. Besides Shakespeare, he found inspiration in John Ford Westerns and other popular genres, and the favor was amply returned when Hollywood remade a number of his films, most notably The Seven Samurai. With his mastery of genre and a wider view of his work, it’s hard to pigeonhole his style, but Ran demonstrates his taste for the epic.
Coming to the Clark – a film series called “An Artist in Her Own Right: Barbara Stanwyck and the Modern American Woman,” showing Saturdays at 2:00, July 18-August 15. And in September, the Cinema Salon Film Club at the Clark -- watch this space for more information.
Free Films Fridays at 4:00 in the Clark Auditorium
This series samples the classic work of four Japanese masters of cinema, who made the postwar era a golden age of film in Japan. Rising from the ashes of atomic annihilation and the humiliation of surrender and occupation, Japanese cinema burst on to the international scene when Kurosawa’s Rashomon won the grand prize at the Venice film festival in 1951, with Mizoguchi winning there the next three years.
Ozu achieved posthumous recognition when Tokyo Story was belatedly released abroad in the ’70s, its supreme achievement gradually confirmed as part of a seamless and peerless fabric of work, when his later films were rediscovered. In the ’80s Naruse was revived to critical acclaim but little distribution, becoming a special favorite of cinematic cognoscenti. All four of these directors had extremely prolific careers that bridged the devastation of World War II, and while many of their films are hard to find, the visible tip of the iceberg is monumental indeed.
June 12: Ugetsu. (1953, 96 min.) Kenji Mizoguchi’s celebrated tale follows a 16th century potter who leaves home to sell his wares in the midst of a civil war, and is captivated by a ghost princess. His signature style, with a gliding camera that unfolds scenes like a Japanese scroll, conveys the magic and mystery of the uncanny without blinking at the gritty reality of a war-torn world. Mizoguchi (1898-1956) is also known for The Life of Oharu and Sansho the Bailiff, among other undiscovered gems.
June 19: When a Woman Ascends the Stairs. (1960, 110 min.) Mikio Naruse’s modern story examines the life of a woman who ascends (and descends) the stairs to the Ginza bar where she serves as a female companion to businessmen, in a niche between geisha and prostitute. Naruse (1905-1969) shares a slow and stately style with Ozu, though his focus tends to be harder edged and grimmer in implication, so almost none of his films are easy to find.
June 26: An Autumn Afternoon. (1962, 112 min.) Yasujiro Ozu’s valedictory film recapitulates his customary themes, with a widower marrying off his daughter as the modern postwar world supplants traditional Japanese ways. As more of his films become available, the place of Ozu (1903-1963) in the pantheon of great directors becomes more certain. The Clark caps last summer’s popular “Seasons of Ozu” film series with this final testament to his genius.
July 3: Ran. (1985, 160 min.) Akira Kurasawa’s culminating masterpiece adapts King Lear to a mythical samurai past with pageantry and passion, mounting some of the most spectacular battle scenes ever filmed. Kurosawa (1910-1998) was the youngest and by far the most Westernized of these four masters. Besides Shakespeare, he found inspiration in John Ford Westerns and other popular genres, and the favor was amply returned when Hollywood remade a number of his films, most notably The Seven Samurai. With his mastery of genre and a wider view of his work, it’s hard to pigeonhole his style, but Ran demonstrates his taste for the epic.
Coming to the Clark – a film series called “An Artist in Her Own Right: Barbara Stanwyck and the Modern American Woman,” showing Saturdays at 2:00, July 18-August 15. And in September, the Cinema Salon Film Club at the Clark -- watch this space for more information.
Revolutionary Road
This is an okay film that suffers by comparison to two superior works, the Richard Yates novel on which it is based, and the tv series Mad Men, which has claimed that era and milieu as its own. I had high hopes when I heard this film was coming out with Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet, directed by her husband, Sam Mendes, so I re-read the 1961 novel to whet my appetite. Yates is deservedly known as a writer’s writer, and indeed I was led to him originally by Joe McGinnis, with whom I became friendly after I wrote a rave review of Fatal Vision. So this film preserves most of the novel, except that which makes it a great book -- the writing. Particularly the excruciatingly nuanced accumulation of shame and humiliation deduced from the workings of self-delusion, the mind in subverted communication with the tongue, and the tongue with others, in a cascade of misrepresentation. Beginning with the same scene, the novel presents the snowballing disaster of a community theater performance in a protracted set piece, but the film shows only the curtain coming down to scattered sarcastic comments from the audience. If you know the book, the movie seems skimpy. If you don’t, it’s likely to seem simplistic and unmotivated, however blistering. Likewise if you know Kate and Leo -- and who does not? -- then it’s hard to see them as these resourceless characters, trapped in a cage of their own illusions. They seem bigger than their cramped circumstances, which is just what the Wheelers were not. When I was reading the book, I couldn’t help seeing April in the guise of Betsy of Mad Men -- January Jones, as pretty, fragile, and hard as porcelain. Ms. Winslet simply has too much substance for the role, and no way is Leo pathetic enough to be Frank. Which is not to disparage their performances, but to point to the misconception that dooms this film from its worthy inspiration to its tasteful semi-tragic conclusion. It’s hard to make a great film from a great book. (2008, dvd, n.) *6+* (MC-69.)
That truism might, at a stretch, apply as well to Killshot (2008, dvd, n.) Elmore Leonard is great within the limits of genre fiction, but maybe not as literature. And certainly he has proven amenable to movie adaptation, from Out of Sight and Get Shorty down through the ranks. This one, however, didn’t make it to theaters but went straight to dvd, despite a noteworthy cast of Diane Lane, Mickey Rourke, Joseph Gordon-Levitt and others, plus director John Madden (of Shakespeare in Love fame). Somebody must have made Harvey Weinstein mad, because worse crap than this shows up in cineplexes every week. I think the key element missing from this adaptation is Leonard’s sly humor. The whole femme-in-jeopardy shtick is competently handled, as a woman witness is stalked by two crazy hitmen. But some crucial element of wit and irony is missing. Nonetheless this dumped film strikes as better, not worse, than average.
That truism might, at a stretch, apply as well to Killshot (2008, dvd, n.) Elmore Leonard is great within the limits of genre fiction, but maybe not as literature. And certainly he has proven amenable to movie adaptation, from Out of Sight and Get Shorty down through the ranks. This one, however, didn’t make it to theaters but went straight to dvd, despite a noteworthy cast of Diane Lane, Mickey Rourke, Joseph Gordon-Levitt and others, plus director John Madden (of Shakespeare in Love fame). Somebody must have made Harvey Weinstein mad, because worse crap than this shows up in cineplexes every week. I think the key element missing from this adaptation is Leonard’s sly humor. The whole femme-in-jeopardy shtick is competently handled, as a woman witness is stalked by two crazy hitmen. But some crucial element of wit and irony is missing. Nonetheless this dumped film strikes as better, not worse, than average.
Friday, June 05, 2009
Frost/Nixon
Ron Howard’s adaptation of Peter Morgan’s play is well-played as far as it goes, but as with Milk’s quasi-documentary, it tends more toward the quasi-. All is forgiven for Frank Langella’s portrayal of Nixon, humanizing the bogey man who haunted my youth. I guess it’s a compliment to call Michael Sheen’s portrayal of Frost convincingly fatuous, until the dark night of the soul when he becomes a responsible journalist. It’s rather absurd how the film buys into the mano a mano fantasies of the pair. Once again, the artificiality of a theater piece is unmasked by the unavoidable actuality of film. Nice try, but the need to insert a standard dramatic arc (and eye candy like Rebecca Hall) undermines the veracity of the documentary intent. (2008, dvd, n.) *6+* (MC-80.)
Rambling round-up
I’ve been laid up for a little longer than expected after a knee operation, so I’ve used some of the leg-up time to catch up with movies on my TiVo playlist, some recorded more than a year ago. There’s none I’d recommend outright, but in the interests of viewer advice, I’ll suggest why you might want to watch any of them.
For cinephiles of my generation or a little older, Antonioni was always a touchstone. I never had a taste for him -- too dour a personality, too grim a viewpoint -- though I could see the appeal of his formal cinematic approach. Back then, L’eclisse (The Eclipse) (1962) struck me as the liveliest of his trilogy looking at fashionable modern alienation between men and women, so when I spotted a chance showing on TCM, I recorded and finally got around to watching it again. Monica Vitti is all that as a vision of romantically troubled blond beauty. Alain Delon is just as pretty as the hyperactive and distractable stock trader, who may or may not meet up with her in the end. The scenes at the Bourse exchange lend a frenetic vitality to what otherwise might sink into vapidity. Antonioni has a sure hand, a steady eye, but a cold and lonely heart.
I recorded Lust for Life (1956) to re-watch for possible showing at the Clark some time, and would not be embarrassed to show it, despite Kirk Douglas’s teeth-gritting, scenery-chewing performance as Van Gogh -- he certainly looks the part of all those self-portraits, though a little louder than the paintings. Just as loud, and colorful, are the widescreen visualizations of director Vincente Minnelli, who clearly favors art over kitsch in his adaptation of the Irving Stone bestseller.
I’ve had several occasions to review the slim pickings of feature films about the American Revolution, and each time I noticed recommendations of the filmed musical 1776 (1972), so I recorded it off TCM and eventually found it to be surprisingly adult in its portrayals and dialogue, set in the Continental Congress leading up to the Declaration of Independence, with songs full of content if not exactly hummable, such as one on the triangle trade of molasses, rum, and slaves. William Daniels is John Adams, Howard da Silva is Ben Franklin, and Ken Howard is Tom Jefferson, in performances more flavorful than you would expect, with impressive sets and costumes, and even some location shooting at Independence Hall. The proceedings do drag a bit, however.
As I was making my way through the top films in the indieWire critics poll for American releases of 2008, I happened to spot #21, The Duchess of Langeais (2006), showing on the Sundance Channel. New Wave veteran Jacques Rivette’s latest won’t make my list of best of year or of his career, but was certainly interesting to watch (MC-74.). This adaptation of a Balzac story set in the 1820s features Jeanne Balibar as the duchess who captivates the wounded Napoleonic general Guillaume Depardieu, and is captivated in return. With manners and conventions barely subduing unruly passions, these two dance around each other until it’s too late for anything but tragedy. What the production lacks in psychological realism, it makes up in elegant formality. Though nowhere near as long and slow as certain Rivette masterpieces, this film doesn’t hurry through its florid emotions and sensational plot, but marinates them in his obsession with theatrical performance, in life as well as on stage.
Because I’m showing Ball of Fire in a Barbara Stanwyck film series at the Clark this summer, I was intrigued when I saw that Howard Hawks later remade it as a musical, A Song is Born (1948), with Virginia Mayo in the Stanwyck role and Danny Kaye subbing for Gary Cooper. As you would expect, it’s not as good. But it’s still good fun, with the “seven dwarves” becoming musicologists instead of lexicographers, and the gang moll instructing them in the ways of jazz instead of slang, and rollicking guest appearances by the likes of Louis Armstrong and Tommy Dorsey.
A more plausible film to show at the Clark sometime might be Age of Consent (1969). I was interested in it as Michael Powell’s all but last film, and also for the promised sight of a teenage Helen Mirren frolicking in the nude both underwater and above. Successful New York painter James Mason decamps to an underpopulated island on the Great Barrier Reef north of Australia, where he encounters child of nature Helen, who inspires him to paint again. There are elements of inappropriate humor and questionable sentimentality, but in its portrayal of an aging painter reinvigorated by a naked young muse, it bears comparison to Rivette’s magnificent La Belle Noiseuse.
While Age of Consent was issued on dvd in tandem with an old Powell-Pressburger favorite of mine, A Matter of Life and Death (1946, aka Stairway to Heaven), the Criterion Collection brought out an earlier production of “The Archers” -- The Small Back Room (1948). Let it be said that any Michael Powell film is worth seeing, but coming after the fevered color dreams of Black Narcissus and The Red Shoes, this is a look back, to WWII in B&W -- a tense but multivalent story of a bomb disposal specialist, who must contend with a tin foot and a drinking problem, as well as a difficult relationship with a lovely, loving secretary, and a new booby-trap bomb that the Germans have taken to dropping on the English countryside. I watched the film in a fragmented way, but it was not only that that forced me to go back and re-view the beginning to put together all the pieces. It doesn’t blow up in his face, but the film is not among Powell’s best.
For cinephiles of my generation or a little older, Antonioni was always a touchstone. I never had a taste for him -- too dour a personality, too grim a viewpoint -- though I could see the appeal of his formal cinematic approach. Back then, L’eclisse (The Eclipse) (1962) struck me as the liveliest of his trilogy looking at fashionable modern alienation between men and women, so when I spotted a chance showing on TCM, I recorded and finally got around to watching it again. Monica Vitti is all that as a vision of romantically troubled blond beauty. Alain Delon is just as pretty as the hyperactive and distractable stock trader, who may or may not meet up with her in the end. The scenes at the Bourse exchange lend a frenetic vitality to what otherwise might sink into vapidity. Antonioni has a sure hand, a steady eye, but a cold and lonely heart.
I recorded Lust for Life (1956) to re-watch for possible showing at the Clark some time, and would not be embarrassed to show it, despite Kirk Douglas’s teeth-gritting, scenery-chewing performance as Van Gogh -- he certainly looks the part of all those self-portraits, though a little louder than the paintings. Just as loud, and colorful, are the widescreen visualizations of director Vincente Minnelli, who clearly favors art over kitsch in his adaptation of the Irving Stone bestseller.
I’ve had several occasions to review the slim pickings of feature films about the American Revolution, and each time I noticed recommendations of the filmed musical 1776 (1972), so I recorded it off TCM and eventually found it to be surprisingly adult in its portrayals and dialogue, set in the Continental Congress leading up to the Declaration of Independence, with songs full of content if not exactly hummable, such as one on the triangle trade of molasses, rum, and slaves. William Daniels is John Adams, Howard da Silva is Ben Franklin, and Ken Howard is Tom Jefferson, in performances more flavorful than you would expect, with impressive sets and costumes, and even some location shooting at Independence Hall. The proceedings do drag a bit, however.
As I was making my way through the top films in the indieWire critics poll for American releases of 2008, I happened to spot #21, The Duchess of Langeais (2006), showing on the Sundance Channel. New Wave veteran Jacques Rivette’s latest won’t make my list of best of year or of his career, but was certainly interesting to watch (MC-74.). This adaptation of a Balzac story set in the 1820s features Jeanne Balibar as the duchess who captivates the wounded Napoleonic general Guillaume Depardieu, and is captivated in return. With manners and conventions barely subduing unruly passions, these two dance around each other until it’s too late for anything but tragedy. What the production lacks in psychological realism, it makes up in elegant formality. Though nowhere near as long and slow as certain Rivette masterpieces, this film doesn’t hurry through its florid emotions and sensational plot, but marinates them in his obsession with theatrical performance, in life as well as on stage.
Because I’m showing Ball of Fire in a Barbara Stanwyck film series at the Clark this summer, I was intrigued when I saw that Howard Hawks later remade it as a musical, A Song is Born (1948), with Virginia Mayo in the Stanwyck role and Danny Kaye subbing for Gary Cooper. As you would expect, it’s not as good. But it’s still good fun, with the “seven dwarves” becoming musicologists instead of lexicographers, and the gang moll instructing them in the ways of jazz instead of slang, and rollicking guest appearances by the likes of Louis Armstrong and Tommy Dorsey.
A more plausible film to show at the Clark sometime might be Age of Consent (1969). I was interested in it as Michael Powell’s all but last film, and also for the promised sight of a teenage Helen Mirren frolicking in the nude both underwater and above. Successful New York painter James Mason decamps to an underpopulated island on the Great Barrier Reef north of Australia, where he encounters child of nature Helen, who inspires him to paint again. There are elements of inappropriate humor and questionable sentimentality, but in its portrayal of an aging painter reinvigorated by a naked young muse, it bears comparison to Rivette’s magnificent La Belle Noiseuse.
While Age of Consent was issued on dvd in tandem with an old Powell-Pressburger favorite of mine, A Matter of Life and Death (1946, aka Stairway to Heaven), the Criterion Collection brought out an earlier production of “The Archers” -- The Small Back Room (1948). Let it be said that any Michael Powell film is worth seeing, but coming after the fevered color dreams of Black Narcissus and The Red Shoes, this is a look back, to WWII in B&W -- a tense but multivalent story of a bomb disposal specialist, who must contend with a tin foot and a drinking problem, as well as a difficult relationship with a lovely, loving secretary, and a new booby-trap bomb that the Germans have taken to dropping on the English countryside. I watched the film in a fragmented way, but it was not only that that forced me to go back and re-view the beginning to put together all the pieces. It doesn’t blow up in his face, but the film is not among Powell’s best.
Monday, May 11, 2009
The Wrestler
Mickey Rourke is as good as they say in this comeback bid, and so is Marisa Tomei. And director Darren Aronofsky offers a surprisingly self-effacing and empathetic look at a working-class New Jersey environment, where the aging hero and heroine have the exotic but ordinary jobs of professional wrestler and bargirl pole-dancer, good at what they do and heartfelt in it, though well past their prime. It’s all show biz, and these folks are troupers. Got to be, living from performance to performance, within a close and closed-in community. Mickey’s got specs (as well as pecs) and a hearing aid, but is still willing to give his body and soul to his bloody art. Marisa can definitely still shake that thing. The film manages to stand a number of cliches on their heads, without stooping to redemption or resolution. It feels real but doesn’t push it too far. (2008, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-81.)
Tell No One
Guillaume Canet’s French adaptation of an American thriller by Harlen Coben plays like an insanely complicated mash-up of Vertigo and The Fugitive, delivered with the blithe incomprehensibility of The Big Sleep. But like the current American remake of the brilliant British miniseries, State of Play, it tries to incorporate just too much conspiracy and mystification into two hours, though with a cast that makes it well worth watching. How can you quibble with a film that deploys such Francophone pulchritude as Marie-Josee Croze, Kristin Scott Thomas, Marina Hinds, and Nathalie Baye? There’s a pleasing array of male character actors as well, led by Francois Cluzet looking a lot like Dustin Hoffman in Marathon Man. He’s a pediatrician still mourning the murder of his wife eight years previous, a case in which he was the prime suspect, and is again now that two more bodies have been unearthed. This film makes no concession to an audience’s desire to figure out what the hell is going on, but if you stick with it, a lot of kinetic energy covers the implausible gaps in the story. It’s the classic Hitchcock situation of someone pursuing the evildoers while being pursued by the police himself. And while it has a ton of ’splainin’ to do in the final reel, it doesn’t feel like a complete cheat. Generally I look for a French film to do more than out-Hollywood Hollywood, but the result here is fairly satisfying. (2008, dvd, n.) *7-* (MC-82.)
Nothing But the Truth [etc.]
Topical subject and notable cast notwithstanding, this Rod Lurie film essentially went straight to video. Kate Beckinsale is a character similar to Judith Miller, the NYTimes reporter who went to jail rather than reveal her source in the outing of CIA agent Valerie Plame. The latter type is played by Vera Farmiga, and the two have some good toe-to-toe scenes. Matt Dillon is the special prosecutor who keeps putting the screws to the reporter so she’ll reveal her source, and Alan Alda is her white-shoe defense attorney. Though Kate is undoubtably more heroic than Judith was, and her prison time harder, she does have her ambiguities, and other views get fair expression. I’m not sure about the fictional displacement of the story to an imaginary Venezuelan assasination attempt and U.S. retribution, nor about the story’s final twist, which is fair but raises as many questions as it answers. But for the most part, this is a cleanly executed political thriller, with a conscience. (2008, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-64.)
To tie up loose ends: I wanted to confirm my assertion about Milk that the documentary was better, so I re-watched The Times of Harvey Milk (1983), and indeed it is so. Not that Gus Van Sant’s film was without value, but in comparison to the Oscar-winning documentary, it strikes me as something unnecessary, like his shot-for-shot remake of Psycho. Of course it’s an important message and reaches a wider audience through the celebrity of Sean Penn’s performance, but most of the story’s impact is lifted directly, and little is added by appending drama to docu-.
Somewhere I read a favorable remark on The Americanization of Emily (1964), so when I saw it coming on TCM, I recorded it. Since the story is about an American serviceman and English servicewoman during World War II, and I am the product of just such a meeting, I got around to watching it quite promptly. I can’t go so far as to recommend the film, but it is an intriguing odd duck indeed. It’s hard to imagine a cynical black comedy about D-Day after we’ve seen Saving Private Ryan, but I suppose writer Paddy Chayefsky was trying to cash in on the then-current bestselling success of Catch-22. James Garner comes across as too nice for the “dog robber” he plays, in the vein of Milo Minderbinder. And Julie Andrews, looking for a change of pace between Mary Poppins and Sound of Music, is too prim and not tart enough, as the driver who is escaping the ethic of courage that took every male in her family and looking for a fling with a certified coward. Director Arthur Hiller does little to liven up the proceedings or fine tune the performances, so the tone is wobbly throughout, while Chayefsky is trying satirically to undercut the glorification of war. The widescreen black & white is reminiscent of then-recent classic The Apartment, but Hiller is not Wilder enough for the job.
To tie up loose ends: I wanted to confirm my assertion about Milk that the documentary was better, so I re-watched The Times of Harvey Milk (1983), and indeed it is so. Not that Gus Van Sant’s film was without value, but in comparison to the Oscar-winning documentary, it strikes me as something unnecessary, like his shot-for-shot remake of Psycho. Of course it’s an important message and reaches a wider audience through the celebrity of Sean Penn’s performance, but most of the story’s impact is lifted directly, and little is added by appending drama to docu-.
Somewhere I read a favorable remark on The Americanization of Emily (1964), so when I saw it coming on TCM, I recorded it. Since the story is about an American serviceman and English servicewoman during World War II, and I am the product of just such a meeting, I got around to watching it quite promptly. I can’t go so far as to recommend the film, but it is an intriguing odd duck indeed. It’s hard to imagine a cynical black comedy about D-Day after we’ve seen Saving Private Ryan, but I suppose writer Paddy Chayefsky was trying to cash in on the then-current bestselling success of Catch-22. James Garner comes across as too nice for the “dog robber” he plays, in the vein of Milo Minderbinder. And Julie Andrews, looking for a change of pace between Mary Poppins and Sound of Music, is too prim and not tart enough, as the driver who is escaping the ethic of courage that took every male in her family and looking for a fling with a certified coward. Director Arthur Hiller does little to liven up the proceedings or fine tune the performances, so the tone is wobbly throughout, while Chayefsky is trying satirically to undercut the glorification of war. The widescreen black & white is reminiscent of then-recent classic The Apartment, but Hiller is not Wilder enough for the job.
Reprise
There’s lots to like about this energetic Norwegian film by Joachim Trier, but I suspect I’m just too old to remain enchanted with the self-dramas of artsy twentysomethings. I respect the homage to classics of the French New Wave like Jules et Jim (in my top five of all time), and it’s cool to see how international cultural artifacts of the ’90s played in Oslo (even though I only know Joy Division, e.g., through its portrayal in several movies ). There were lots of inside references in this story of two friends just out of school, sending off the manuscripts of their first novels, to varying effect, both in fantasy and in reality, which are sometimes hard to sort out. The two friends are appealing, and their cronies fitfully amusing, along with a Bjork-lookalike girlfriend. I was happy enough to go for the ride, but I didn’t catch every twist and turn. And in the end I didn’t care all that much. (2006, dvd, n.) *6+* (MC-79.)
Vicky Cristinia Barcelona
Thankfully Woody Allen no longer appears in his own films, with touristic footage of European cities filling in for some of his more annoying shtick, but there is still a shallow, nihilistic worldview at work in his films, so when they’re not funny they’re pretty bleak, in a way that is assumed not earned. So everything and everyone is pretty and well-heeled, if ultimately emptied of significance. He doesn’t abuse Scarlett Johansson as badly as in recent films, but still makes her into a pretentious bubblehead. Luckily the other three principals are not so easily moved around like straw people. Javier Bardem and Penelope Cruz are pretty hilarious as the hot-blooded artist couple, with whom the post-graduate Americans, Vicky (an effective Rebecca Hall) and Cristina, fall in during their hot Mediterranean summer in Barcelona. There’s an intrusive narration that one wants to take as ironic, but no, really, it’s just that flatfooted -- I wonder if Woody could have sold it in his own voice? In no way a hardship to watch, this film was in no way moving or illuminating. (2008, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-70.)
Saturday, April 25, 2009
The Class (Entre les murs)
It’s time to start mentioning Laurent Cantet among the great directors working today. Winner of the highest award at Cannes last year and rapturously received at the NY Film Festival, this film follows the impressive string of Human Resources (1999), Time Out (2001), and Heading South (2005). Each of his films is tuned into social and economic realities, but with The Class (which might also have been called The Classes, or better yet, the original title, Between the Walls), his quasi-documentary approach yields unassailable truth. Francois Begaudeau wrote a memoir of a year teaching in a Parisian middle school, then worked with Cantet on a script based on his experiences, and finally plays a semi-fictionalized version of himself, over the course of a year with a classroom of real students, though not the original subjects. The other teachers and parents are also “real.” Filming with three HD cameras, Cantet captures the verite of public schooling better than anyone since Frederick Wiseman. But the real amazement is how entertaining and involving the proceedings become; out of the boredom of the classroom a portrait of a volatile multicultural society emerges. There are tensions between the African and Caribbean Blacks, between the Arabs and those who proclaim a French identity, between the academically eager Chinese and the immigration authorities. This pot is bubbling but not melting. No summary of “plot” or character will clue you into the experience of this film, you must take it all in on the fly, like a fly on the wall. My point of comparison would be the superlative fourth season of The Wire, telling the hard truth about the education of marginal youths, without bludgeoning the viewer into despair. (2008, Images, n.) *8+* (MC-92.)
Doubt
While this might have worked as a four-hander declaimed from the stage, as a film it once again underscores the difference (not to say superiority) between cinema and theater. John Patrick Shanley adapts and directs his own Pulitzer-winning play. He does some location shooting at the Bronx parochial school he actually attended in the early 60s, when the story is set, and populates it with additional characters, but the play is dissipated rather than opened-out, and askew camera angles and other stage business highlight the artificiality. What remains are the central performances, and they are quite good. Meryl Streep offers a sly caricature of the rigid old-school nun (she must have had fun doing this back-to-back with her loosey-goosey, aging hippie in Mamma Mia!), and Philip Seymour Hoffman as usual convinces as a Vatican II-era priest who may or may not be a pediphile. Amy Adams radiates innocence as the younger Sister of Charity enlisted in the older nun’s plot to force out the pastor, and Viola Davis is effective in a brief but crucial appearance as the mother of the boy who might have been abused. But in the effort to be open-ended, and provocative of walking-out-of-the-theater disputation, the film fails to find its focus or point. Having just worked with a friend on the story of his parochial school education, I found much of this film intriguing and even funny, but was finally annoyed by its refusal to resolve its themes, its attempt to have it every which way, under cover of its title. (2008, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-68.)
The Reader
This would have been a better film if it tried to do less, had maintained a sharper and narrower focus. Trying to negotiate four time frames within the film, in order to illuminate an unseen fifth, namely the Holocaust, dissipates the drama and overreaches the truth. Of course, Kate Winslet’s opportunity to age prosthetically probably won her the Oscar, but for me she only registered at something like her own age. The film falls apart when she goes from pairing with David Kross as her teenage lover to Ralph Fiennes in the character’s later incarnation, as the haunted lawyer who failed to provide her with an alibi (she was unable to read, so couldn’t have been responsible for a falsified report) when it came out that she had been an SS guard at a concentration camp, subsequently tried for murder and sentenced to life imprisonment. In the end, Stephen Daldry’s film (and David Hare’s script from Bernhard Schlick’s novel) offers more exploitation than illumination, relying on prestige rather than honest emotion or clear viewpoint. A stripped-down version would have had a cleaner (though nicely dirty) impact. (2008, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-58.)
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Wendy and Lucy
Kelly Reichardt’s follow-up to critical fave, Old Joy, yields a sad and modest, but beautifully modulated film in the vein of indie neorealism. It plays like an American Umberto D., but instead of a destitute old man and his dog, it tells of a destitute young woman and her dog. Wendy is marvelously inhabited by Michelle Williams, as a waif-like drifter on her way to Alaska, always on the edge of tears but rarely succumbing. She is not headed “Into the Wild” but hoping to get a job at a cannery in Ketchikan. Her car breaks down in a small town in Oregon, and her life proceeds to break down around her. When she desperately tries to shoplift some dogfood for Lucy, played by Reichardt’s own “yellow-gold” mutt, she is collared by an eager-beaver clerk and sent to be booked and fingerprinted. And when she finally posts bail from her rapidly dwindling stake of cash and returns to where Lucy had been tied up, the dog is no longer there. The rest of the brief but deliberately-paced eighty minutes is taken up with Wendy’s increasingly desperate attempts to find Lucy. Without histrionics, an abject story of poverty and loneliness unfolds, with some tender and touching moments but just the slightest glimmer of hope in its denouement. (2008, Images, n.) *7-* (MC-80.)
Elegy
Except for the main character’s name and the title credits, you would hardly imagine this film was adapted from a Philip Roth novel. The situation might be recognizable but the scathingly witty authorial voice is nowhere heard, despite some half-hearted narration. Aging satyr Ben Kingsley teaches at Columbia (in an earlier Roth novel David Kepesh was The Professor of Desire, though in this The Dying Animal) and commentates on culture for public television and highbrow magazines. He has a satisfactory shag-&-run relationship with Patricia Clarkson, but regularly lets young ladies graduate from his classroom to his bedroom. Penelope Cruz proves (understandably) to be more than a passing fancy, however. He turns for advice to his only friend, a Pulitzer-winning poet played by Dennis Hopper, while on the other side he is hounded by resentful son Peter Sarsgaard. With such a cast and such a provenance, this film is certainly watchable but hardly memorable. Without getting all sexist about it, I wonder if a Spanish woman -- Isabel Coixet -- is the ideal director to get across the Rothian worldview? (2008, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-66.)
Synecdoche, New York
Intellectually playful from its clever title forward, Charlie Kaufman’s directorial debut returns to the obsessive themes and oddball humor of his scripts for Being John Malkovich, Adaptation, and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, but without a lightening touch from Spike Jonze or Michel Gondry, the proceedings turn rather lugubrious. There’s lots of dark cerebral humor, but the film inevitably ends with the word, “Die.” So being inside Charlie’s head for two hours might be a tad glum, except for the life generated by an exceptional cast. Philip Seymour Hoffman is a morose, hypochondriac playwright-director from Schenectady, whose artist wife (Catherine Keener) leaves him, taking their daughter, for whom he pines throughout the film. As a consolation, he wins a MacArthur genius grant, which allows him to move to NYC and obtain a huge warehouse where he mounts an insanely elaborate theatrical recreation of his life. He marries the actress who plays his wife (Michelle Williams) and has a surrogate daughter, but cannot recreate the happiness he probably never had. Along the way he dallies with a hot-to-trot box office cashier (Samantha Morton) -- so hot she lives in a house surreally on fire for decades -- who in the course of the years becomes his directorial assistant, whose character winds up being played by Emily Watson in the unending, if never opening, play within the film. Got that? Probably not on the first go, you won’t. And that’s not all, you’ll see Dianne Wiest and Jennifer Jason Leigh and other familiar faces as well. There’s a lot going on here, not all of it fun but most of it bleakly farcical and mind-bending. Even with the aftertaste of ashes, this is my cup of tea. (2008, dvd, n.) *7+* (MC-67.)
Pineapple Express
The high concept of a stoner action flick is taken for a ride -- with car chases and gunfire as well as clouds of pot smoke -- by Freaks & Geeks alums, Seth Rogen and James Franco, with director David Gordon Green trying to break out of the sensitive indie ghetto. It’s not entirely unamusing, with the writing and the acting having their moments, but still strikes me as unnecessary. (2008, dvd, n.) *6-* (MC-64.)
Wednesday, April 08, 2009
Prospecting for the Clark
Here’s a group of films that I watched recently in choosing forthcoming series at the Clark. I’d already nailed down my “Four Japanese Masters” for a series in June, but Kon Ichikawa’s The Burmese Harp (1956) remained on my Netflix queue, and it turned out to be new to me. I had it confused with his other famous WWII film, Fires on the Plain (1959), which I didn’t really want to see again, though its images of cannibalism among the defeated Japanese troops have stuck with me since I saw it long ago. The Burmese Harp also deals with the aftermath of Japanese surrender, but in a gentler way. One survivor is nursed back to health in a Buddhist monastery, and rather than return with his unit to Japan, he becomes a monk and stays in Burma to bury all the dead troops that litter the landscape. Looking good on a Criterion Collection DVD, this film was in its day an international hit for its lovely evocation of pacifist sentiment after the carnage of war.
I’ve been taking a break in the middle of re-watching the 26 episodes of The World At War, but continuing to explore the themes of World War II in film (as the world economy careens toward disaster, it’s reassuring to know we’ve come back from much worse devastation). So the confluence of several strands of interest finally got me to watch Open City (1945), which had been on my TiVo playlist for a year and a half. Roberto Rossellini’s film about the Roman resistance in the waning days of the war in Italy, filmed on the spot before the war had ended, is taken to be one of the founts of neorealism. It’s so much a monument that it’s hard to approach it freshly as a film. How well it’s made is almost beside the point of it’s being made at all. Its blend of the real and the cinematic remains a nearly miraculous result of minimal means. If I get to do my film club series on Italian neorealism next fall at the Clark, this is sure to kick it off.
One way that Open City is the mother of all Italian postwar cinema is for making famous Anna Magnani, one of the few professionals in the cast. She also appears in Pier Paolo Pasolini’s Momma Roma (1962), almost as if she had survived the earlier film and had the son she was pregnant with at the time. Retrieving him from rustication, after years of supporting him by walking the streets of Rome, Magnani tries to forge a new life in a housing development with her semi-delinquent teenager. Pasolini pulls out all the stops, but the whole does not sustain itself. There are bravura sequences, like two where Magnani walks through the streets of Rome and narrates her story to a succession of street characters who fall in step with her, and stylistic quirks, like the almost Ozu-like frontality with which Magnani and others address the camera. But there was a whole level of symbolic signification that didn’t work for me at all, so the film made no unified impact. There’s a lot of emotion on display in which I did not share.
I filled the last slot in my “Projections of Rome” film series with Three Coins in the Fountain (1954), trivial as a romantic comedy, but eye-popping as a digitally-restored Cinemascope travelogue of Rome. Enough of an innovation in location shooting to win the Oscar for cinematography, it became a surprise hit. In front of the star of the show -- the sights of Rome, seen only occasionally in jarring back-projection -- three unlikely American secretaries (Dorothy Maguire, Jean Peters, and Maggie McNamara--an Audrey Hepburn-lite whose career fizzled) dance in pursuit of the men of their dreams (Clifton Webb, Rossano Brazzi, and Louis Jourdan) and -- surprise! -- meet them altogether in the end, in front of the Trevi Fountain where they made their wishes at the start of the movie, to the strains of Frank Sinatra singing the title tune.
I’ve been taking a break in the middle of re-watching the 26 episodes of The World At War, but continuing to explore the themes of World War II in film (as the world economy careens toward disaster, it’s reassuring to know we’ve come back from much worse devastation). So the confluence of several strands of interest finally got me to watch Open City (1945), which had been on my TiVo playlist for a year and a half. Roberto Rossellini’s film about the Roman resistance in the waning days of the war in Italy, filmed on the spot before the war had ended, is taken to be one of the founts of neorealism. It’s so much a monument that it’s hard to approach it freshly as a film. How well it’s made is almost beside the point of it’s being made at all. Its blend of the real and the cinematic remains a nearly miraculous result of minimal means. If I get to do my film club series on Italian neorealism next fall at the Clark, this is sure to kick it off.
One way that Open City is the mother of all Italian postwar cinema is for making famous Anna Magnani, one of the few professionals in the cast. She also appears in Pier Paolo Pasolini’s Momma Roma (1962), almost as if she had survived the earlier film and had the son she was pregnant with at the time. Retrieving him from rustication, after years of supporting him by walking the streets of Rome, Magnani tries to forge a new life in a housing development with her semi-delinquent teenager. Pasolini pulls out all the stops, but the whole does not sustain itself. There are bravura sequences, like two where Magnani walks through the streets of Rome and narrates her story to a succession of street characters who fall in step with her, and stylistic quirks, like the almost Ozu-like frontality with which Magnani and others address the camera. But there was a whole level of symbolic signification that didn’t work for me at all, so the film made no unified impact. There’s a lot of emotion on display in which I did not share.
I filled the last slot in my “Projections of Rome” film series with Three Coins in the Fountain (1954), trivial as a romantic comedy, but eye-popping as a digitally-restored Cinemascope travelogue of Rome. Enough of an innovation in location shooting to win the Oscar for cinematography, it became a surprise hit. In front of the star of the show -- the sights of Rome, seen only occasionally in jarring back-projection -- three unlikely American secretaries (Dorothy Maguire, Jean Peters, and Maggie McNamara--an Audrey Hepburn-lite whose career fizzled) dance in pursuit of the men of their dreams (Clifton Webb, Rossano Brazzi, and Louis Jourdan) and -- surprise! -- meet them altogether in the end, in front of the Trevi Fountain where they made their wishes at the start of the movie, to the strains of Frank Sinatra singing the title tune.
Renewed recommendations
I’ve recently rewatched two favorites, one new and one old, and I’m here to urge you to see them, if you have not. From the get-go, I knew I would want to watch Happy-Go-Lucky again with subtitles, and now that it is out on DVD and I have done so, I feel happy and lucky to confirm it as my pick for best film of 2008. Much of the dialogue is tossed offhandly in accent, so that subtitles add another dimension of marvel at the wit and depth of Mike Leigh’s direction and Sally Hawkins’ inhabitation of the character of Poppy, certainly the performance of the year, a lovely and believably quirky woman, who remains happy even when her luck goes bad, in a world of anger and hurt.
Flirting looks even better than when it was made twenty years ago, as our first glimpse of Thandie Newton, Nicole Kidman, and Naomi Watts. Noah Taylor brings his wry grit to the presumably autobiographical protagonist of writer-director John Duigan’s tale of romance and rebellion in a pair of Australian boarding schools that face each other across a moonlit lake. Specific to 1965 yet universal in appeal, this coming of age story is funny and uncommonly true, and I defy you not to enjoy it.
Flirting looks even better than when it was made twenty years ago, as our first glimpse of Thandie Newton, Nicole Kidman, and Naomi Watts. Noah Taylor brings his wry grit to the presumably autobiographical protagonist of writer-director John Duigan’s tale of romance and rebellion in a pair of Australian boarding schools that face each other across a moonlit lake. Specific to 1965 yet universal in appeal, this coming of age story is funny and uncommonly true, and I defy you not to enjoy it.
Let the Right One In
I frequently simulate the moviegoing experience on dvd, by watching previews before the film itself, and I must say the trailers on this disk -- all horror gorefests -- rather put me off the main attraction, to which I was lured by its high ranking (#14) on the IndieWire critics poll for 2008. By the end I was glad to have seen it, despite all the blood, but I’m pretty sure I won’t even look at the forthcoming American remake (and watched this in Swedish with subtitles rather than dubbed in English, which I suspect would have been intolerable). I am neither devotee nor dismisser of vampire films, but this one wasn’t prettified, and was firmly rooted in its Swedish suburban setting. As with Pan’s Labyrinth, I bought into the violence of fantasy for the insight offered into the secret longings of children. The 12-year-olds who play the pale bullied boy and the dark not-a-girl who moves in next door are extremely magnetic and convincingly naturalistic. Tomas Alfredson’s direction is observant and frequently beautiful, with enough wrenching shocks, as well as humor and pathos, to keep one from asking any of the questions that would make the story fall apart. We willingly enter the world of what-if, and care about what happens there, while registering social and psychological realities. (2008, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-82.)
Watching the seasons go by
I am a film guy, not a tv guy, but I find some series (usually on dvd) particularly engaging specimens of long-form cinema. This is obvious with European imports like Bergman’s Scenes from a Marriage, Kieslowski’s Decalogue, the Italian Best of Youth, or British literary adaptations such as Bleak House. But they also appear on American screens. I’ve recently pitched the best one now running, Friday Night Lights -- it’s too late to hop into the third season, but go back and start with season one on dvd. Same goes for Mad Men, the other superb ongoing series, now between its second and third seasons.
For the moment I will be missing the episode-to-episode pleasures of the soap opera format, where you get to know the characters so well you live their lives with them. Everybody’s got to have their stories. Two series that I have watched quite devotedly have just ended.
Battlestar Galactica wrapped up the whole series as well as the fourth season, though it will have multiple afterlives. Not a moment too soon; in fact several too late. The show was always an odd mix of the awesome and the awful, frequently bobbing along on hot air, but it did not truly “jump the shark” till the very last hour, in which everything bad about the series was magnified into ludicrousness and I wound up hooting at the screen, an entertaining experience in its own right but not the way for a program to go into that good night. It made me reconsider the hours I had put into watching it, despite the occasional topical gems like the sequence where the polytheistic humans were insurgents and terrorists against the occupying monotheistic Cylons. The characters and dialogue were frequently flatfooted, but at other times gave you something to think about. Critical acclaim brought me to the series late, but having seen it through to the end, I will not add to the chorus of recommendation.
Big Love ended its third season on a resolving note that certainly implies a fourth, and makes me look forward to it. This is not one of the HBO series I take seriously, but do find continuously entertaining, like Entourage or Six Feet Under or Rome. Well written and acted, if overly sudsy, these are characters I have bonded with and I want to see how their lives work out.
The opposite is true for the new Joss Wheedon series, Dollhouse, on which I gave up after a few episodes, despite its lineage from one of my all-time favorites, Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Buffy now slots at #3 on my life list, behind Freaks and Geeks, whose one truncated season is a must-see on dvd, all the more so when you’ve seen what Judd Apatow and the gang have gone on to subsequently, redefining movie comedy for the 21st century.
What I would call serious HBO shows, like The Sopranos or Deadwood, also count among the best -- but for me The Wire is #1 forever, without a doubt. If you haven’t been convinced to watch it yet, then nothing I can say at this late date will turn the trick. I will, however, offer a plug for the David Simon-Ed Burns follow-up miniseries, Generation Kill, now on dvd. Spend seven hours with Recon Marines at the tip of the spear driving toward Baghdad, and it will indelibly color your understanding of the American fiasco in Iraq.
So queue any of these up on Netflix for guaranteed viewing pleasure (double your money back -- since two times zero is zero). And get on the bandwagon for Mad Men and Friday Night Lights, while keeping an eye out for the next great tv series.
For the moment I will be missing the episode-to-episode pleasures of the soap opera format, where you get to know the characters so well you live their lives with them. Everybody’s got to have their stories. Two series that I have watched quite devotedly have just ended.
Battlestar Galactica wrapped up the whole series as well as the fourth season, though it will have multiple afterlives. Not a moment too soon; in fact several too late. The show was always an odd mix of the awesome and the awful, frequently bobbing along on hot air, but it did not truly “jump the shark” till the very last hour, in which everything bad about the series was magnified into ludicrousness and I wound up hooting at the screen, an entertaining experience in its own right but not the way for a program to go into that good night. It made me reconsider the hours I had put into watching it, despite the occasional topical gems like the sequence where the polytheistic humans were insurgents and terrorists against the occupying monotheistic Cylons. The characters and dialogue were frequently flatfooted, but at other times gave you something to think about. Critical acclaim brought me to the series late, but having seen it through to the end, I will not add to the chorus of recommendation.
Big Love ended its third season on a resolving note that certainly implies a fourth, and makes me look forward to it. This is not one of the HBO series I take seriously, but do find continuously entertaining, like Entourage or Six Feet Under or Rome. Well written and acted, if overly sudsy, these are characters I have bonded with and I want to see how their lives work out.
The opposite is true for the new Joss Wheedon series, Dollhouse, on which I gave up after a few episodes, despite its lineage from one of my all-time favorites, Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Buffy now slots at #3 on my life list, behind Freaks and Geeks, whose one truncated season is a must-see on dvd, all the more so when you’ve seen what Judd Apatow and the gang have gone on to subsequently, redefining movie comedy for the 21st century.
What I would call serious HBO shows, like The Sopranos or Deadwood, also count among the best -- but for me The Wire is #1 forever, without a doubt. If you haven’t been convinced to watch it yet, then nothing I can say at this late date will turn the trick. I will, however, offer a plug for the David Simon-Ed Burns follow-up miniseries, Generation Kill, now on dvd. Spend seven hours with Recon Marines at the tip of the spear driving toward Baghdad, and it will indelibly color your understanding of the American fiasco in Iraq.
So queue any of these up on Netflix for guaranteed viewing pleasure (double your money back -- since two times zero is zero). And get on the bandwagon for Mad Men and Friday Night Lights, while keeping an eye out for the next great tv series.
Saturday, March 21, 2009
Is there a doc in the house?
The protracted conclusion of a book project has left me behind in my movie reviewing, so I will try to catch up with a generalized commentary on the competing virtues of documentary and feature filmmaking.
Two recent films make for a pointed comparison. I watched both with the same companion. After Milk (2008, MC-84), I turned to her and said, “It was okay, but the documentary was better,” referring to the 1984 Oscar-winner The Times of Harvey Milk. After Cadillac Records (2008, MC-65), she said to me, “It was okay, but a documentary would have been better.” Each was based on a true story from the recent past, and one’s view of each was determined by how one weighed the merits of performance vs. authenticity. If you were swept up in Sean Penn’s deservedly celebrated portrayal of Harvey Milk, or smitten by James Franco as his lover, or intrigued by Josh Brolin as his murderer, then you make allowances for the movie-fying of his story. Similarly, if you are mesmerised by Jeffrey Wright as Muddy Waters, or Beyonce as Etta James, or Adrien Brody as Leonard Chess, the mensch in spite of himself who started the eponymous record company, then you go along with the soapy tv machinations of plot, as it perfunctorily checks off its points. It’s all about how much you lose yourself (and your critical, reality-checking faculties) in the portrayal of the characters.
The director (and budget) makes a difference as well. Gus Van Sant is a gay man who alternates mainstream movies with edgy independent films, and here delivers the commercial goods, albeit with a story that definitely engages him. Darnell Martin is a black woman who has mainly directed tv episodes but every decade or so gets to make a movie she has written. So I am prone to pull for -- or make allowances for -- her more than him. Both films are worth seeing, but I enjoyed Cadillac Records a bit more than Milk, though each would benefit from more documentary veracity and less conventional drama.
A film that dispenses with drama but delivers a documentary “you-are-there” quality is The Taking of Power by Louis XIV (1966), probably the best of the historical programs for Italian (and French) television to which Roberto Rossellini devoted the last decade-plus of his career, after declaring that cinema was dead. It certainly was the only one I had seen and retained a favorable impression of, and it’s been given singular treatment by the Criterion Collection, who at the same time released an Eclipse boxed set of other Rossellinis, about which I will write more later. All these films have a stagy, pageant-like quality, with characters spouting lines of exposition that might have been copied from a textbook, but in this particular case that style matches the subject exactly. Pageantry was just what the Sun King was after as he consolidated power in absolute monarchy, forcing the aristocracy to live in the opulence of Versailles and bankrupting themselves to keep up with the fashion of high living. So when we endure a long, long shot of Louis consuming a sixteen course meal by himself at a dais, we are in exactly the position of the aristocrats who are obliged to soak in his majesty. (Sofia Coppola had to have seen this before she had Jason Schwartzman as Louis XVIII dining in Marie Antoinette.) And in this case, the nonprofessional actor who portrays the King is perfect in his inadequacy to the role, with all the overwrought glamor serving only as a cover for his fear. Unable to memorize his lines, he was forced to read them off a blackboard, but that averted gaze perfectly conveys both the king’s inadequacies and the indifference of royalty to its inferiors. The lack of performance contributes to the authenticity of the film, an article of faith with directors like Dreyer and Bresson, but rarely proved as well as here.
For the sake of contrast, I will mention a film that is totally about performance and absolutely not about authenticity, and therefore the only one of these I hesitate to recommend. Nathalie (2003, MC-69) was written and directed by Anne Fontaine, but is all about French star power. Fanny Ardant plays a tony Parisian gynecologist who more than suspects her husband, Gerard Depardieu, of cheating on her, and enlists a bargirl-prostitute, Emmannuel Beart, to seduce him and report back on exactly what he does. But who is seducing whom? The answer is oh so French. But it hardly matters. It’s enough to spend the time in the company of Fanny Ardant, who not only has her own enigmatic beauty but also gives me a last tenuous connection to the life and work of Francois Truffaut. Depardieu always inhabits his roles with bearish comfort, and Beart nicely plays on the ambiguity I always feel toward her, attractive and yet scary, those lips too luscious to be anything but poison. I was reminded of Bibi Andersson in Persona for the erotic charge of just talking about sex. This film is of course not in that class (very few are), just a tease instead of a revelation.
Two recent films make for a pointed comparison. I watched both with the same companion. After Milk (2008, MC-84), I turned to her and said, “It was okay, but the documentary was better,” referring to the 1984 Oscar-winner The Times of Harvey Milk. After Cadillac Records (2008, MC-65), she said to me, “It was okay, but a documentary would have been better.” Each was based on a true story from the recent past, and one’s view of each was determined by how one weighed the merits of performance vs. authenticity. If you were swept up in Sean Penn’s deservedly celebrated portrayal of Harvey Milk, or smitten by James Franco as his lover, or intrigued by Josh Brolin as his murderer, then you make allowances for the movie-fying of his story. Similarly, if you are mesmerised by Jeffrey Wright as Muddy Waters, or Beyonce as Etta James, or Adrien Brody as Leonard Chess, the mensch in spite of himself who started the eponymous record company, then you go along with the soapy tv machinations of plot, as it perfunctorily checks off its points. It’s all about how much you lose yourself (and your critical, reality-checking faculties) in the portrayal of the characters.
The director (and budget) makes a difference as well. Gus Van Sant is a gay man who alternates mainstream movies with edgy independent films, and here delivers the commercial goods, albeit with a story that definitely engages him. Darnell Martin is a black woman who has mainly directed tv episodes but every decade or so gets to make a movie she has written. So I am prone to pull for -- or make allowances for -- her more than him. Both films are worth seeing, but I enjoyed Cadillac Records a bit more than Milk, though each would benefit from more documentary veracity and less conventional drama.
A film that dispenses with drama but delivers a documentary “you-are-there” quality is The Taking of Power by Louis XIV (1966), probably the best of the historical programs for Italian (and French) television to which Roberto Rossellini devoted the last decade-plus of his career, after declaring that cinema was dead. It certainly was the only one I had seen and retained a favorable impression of, and it’s been given singular treatment by the Criterion Collection, who at the same time released an Eclipse boxed set of other Rossellinis, about which I will write more later. All these films have a stagy, pageant-like quality, with characters spouting lines of exposition that might have been copied from a textbook, but in this particular case that style matches the subject exactly. Pageantry was just what the Sun King was after as he consolidated power in absolute monarchy, forcing the aristocracy to live in the opulence of Versailles and bankrupting themselves to keep up with the fashion of high living. So when we endure a long, long shot of Louis consuming a sixteen course meal by himself at a dais, we are in exactly the position of the aristocrats who are obliged to soak in his majesty. (Sofia Coppola had to have seen this before she had Jason Schwartzman as Louis XVIII dining in Marie Antoinette.) And in this case, the nonprofessional actor who portrays the King is perfect in his inadequacy to the role, with all the overwrought glamor serving only as a cover for his fear. Unable to memorize his lines, he was forced to read them off a blackboard, but that averted gaze perfectly conveys both the king’s inadequacies and the indifference of royalty to its inferiors. The lack of performance contributes to the authenticity of the film, an article of faith with directors like Dreyer and Bresson, but rarely proved as well as here.
For the sake of contrast, I will mention a film that is totally about performance and absolutely not about authenticity, and therefore the only one of these I hesitate to recommend. Nathalie (2003, MC-69) was written and directed by Anne Fontaine, but is all about French star power. Fanny Ardant plays a tony Parisian gynecologist who more than suspects her husband, Gerard Depardieu, of cheating on her, and enlists a bargirl-prostitute, Emmannuel Beart, to seduce him and report back on exactly what he does. But who is seducing whom? The answer is oh so French. But it hardly matters. It’s enough to spend the time in the company of Fanny Ardant, who not only has her own enigmatic beauty but also gives me a last tenuous connection to the life and work of Francois Truffaut. Depardieu always inhabits his roles with bearish comfort, and Beart nicely plays on the ambiguity I always feel toward her, attractive and yet scary, those lips too luscious to be anything but poison. I was reminded of Bibi Andersson in Persona for the erotic charge of just talking about sex. This film is of course not in that class (very few are), just a tease instead of a revelation.
Still Life
If you’ve got a thing for Antonioni, you’ll probably fall for Jia Zhang-ke. He expresses feeling -- predominantly of dislocation -- through environment rather than through story or character. The World took place in a Vegas-like Beijing amusement park with reduced-scale models of the world’s great attractions from the Eiffel Tower to the Taj Mahal. Still Life transpires in an old city about to be inundated by the Three Gorges Dam in southern China, largest in the world. Two parallel but unconnected stories detail the quest of a spouse from the North who is searching for the mate that disappeared into this disappearing town. We mutely and slowly follow the searches of the man and woman through a doomed environment of buildings being vacated and demolished by gangs of workmen wielding sledgehammers. Beautifully filmed in HD video, with reference to traditions of Chinese painting and incursions of digital surrealism, this film engages one’s documentary interest in news from the other side of the world, if you have the patience for evocative enigmas without much emotion or event. The amazing landscape of the place and the scope of human displacement overshadow individual involvement with the fate of the characters. Jia is the hottest young Chinese director on the international scene, as evidenced by this film coming in 7th in the IndieWire poll for 2008. (2006, dvd, n.) *6* (MC-81.)
Monday, March 09, 2009
Gomorrah
I’d feel less certain of my reaction to this film if it weren’t shared by the three people I watched it with. What is the fuss all about? Compared to The Wire, Matteo Garrone’s film just does not deliver on its promise of revealing the interconnected truth of the culture of organized crime. Juggling loosely linked stories of the Camorra, the Neopolitan equivalent of the Mafia, the film offers no point of access through character, story, or wit. Some moments stand out, but for the most part it is a punishing slog. Grim reality is all well and good, but why not go all the way and offer a documentary framework, rather than placing the story in context just with explanatory aftertitles. As in The Wire, we see street-corner drug-dealing, life in the projects (here a truly bizarre structure), dubious “waste management” practices, container port smuggling and mass death, crime syndicate incursions upon straight business such as couture, feral kids taking on the color of their environment (even underage drivers of huge vehicles), with people getting blown away as an everyday occurrence. What the film didn’t give me was any reason to pay attention or to care. If you have that going in, maybe you will find the movie up to the awards and acclaim it has achieved. (2009, IFC/OD, n.) *6* (MC-86.)
The Passion of Ayn Rand
I stumbled across this little-noticed Showtime movie because DirecTV is offering several months of the channel for free (I see now it’s also on Netflix). With Helen Mirren as Ayn Rand, Peter Fonda as her husband, Eric Stoltz as her acolyte Nathaniel Branden, and Julie Delpy as his wife, on whose book the docudrama is based, the cast was intriguing enough for me to tune in. And it was indeed watchable, if largely uninformative and unrevealing, insufficiently controversial. Personalities come across -- Mirren as Rand in particular -- but motivations are unplumbed, reducing the story of one of the 20th century’s celebrated wackos to cross-currents of sexual jealousy. (1999, Show/T, n. ) *6*
Saturday, March 07, 2009
I've Loved You So Long
Opinions may differ, but I found this exploration of a difficult but rewarding relationship between sisters even better than Rachel Getting Married. Kristin Scott Thomas gives a finely-tuned performance that was nearly as scandalously overlooked at awards time as Sally Hawkins in Happy-Go-Lucky. I’m not getting into plot points, which are perhaps the weakest element of writer-director Philippe Claudel’s debut film. Certainly a good deal of suspense is generated along the way, but the plot mechanism -- who, what, and why dunnit? -- is the least of the film’s virtues. Moody and painterly, its best aspect is the developing relationship between Kristin Scott Thomas, who has been “away” for fifteen years, after a devastating event that is very gradually revealed, and her estranged but formerly close kid sister, a bright young literature professor played by Elsa Zylberstein. Together they dig out a character who has been buried alive by life and death, and reintroduce her to the world, step by tentative step. It’s all slow, quiet, and beautifully judged. Nothing happens, except a light going back on in the soul of a woman. (2008, dvd, n.) *8* (MC-79.)
It’s a relief to have seen a film I felt like talking about. There’s a wave of interesting new releases next week, and I’m working through the IndieWire critics poll (not as diligently as last year) before making my own pronunciamento on the best of 2008. Their #1 (The Flight of the Red Balloon) I’ve already given a lukewarm review. Their #5 (Happy-Go-Lucky) is my #1 so far, till all the votes are counted. Their #6 (Paranoid Park) earns only a shrug from me -- it was okay for a skateboarding murder mystery with arty pretensions, but the way is wide open for me to consider Milk, when I finally catch up with it, as the best Gus Van Sant movie of 2008.
Paranoid Park (2008, MC-83.) fell in a string of films that I lump together under the rubric, “These Kids Today,” about which I have little to say, except to acknowledge the camera-worthiness of the young leads. Another was Hard Candy (2006, MC-58.). Before Juno, Ellen Page was Hayley, a tough and taunting 14-year-old who does a turnabout on an older man who is stalking her. David Slade’s film was gripping in places, but so manipulative that it evaporated in the mind when it was over, except for the lingering image of a star being born. And in this category I include Friday Night Lights, more the current tv series (MC-84.), which I previewed on DirecTV, than the 2004 movie (MC-70), which I watched again after the fact. The film is much more about Texas high school football, and the true story of one season, than the portrait of community that the tv series has opened into (did I mention that the kids are attractive?). It was amusing to see the few carryovers from movie to tv series, most especially Connie Britton as the coach’s wife, who barely gets a line of dialogue in the film but becomes the central figure of the series, in delicious tandem with Kyle Chandler as the coach (Billy Bob Thornton in movie).
There’s another film I cannot rouse myself to review, but will note that I watched, for its possible inclusion in a Rome-themed film series at the Clark. I had hoped that The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone (1961) might pair nicely with Roman Holiday, but I couldn’t convince myself of the fit. It was certainly interesting to see Vivien Leigh (well past Blanche Dubois, let alone Scarlett O’Hara, but still magnetically attractive, despite having just been dumped by Laurence Olivier) at the end of her career playing off Warren Beatty (almost believable as an Italian gigolo) at the beginning of his. Also interesting was the transparent autobiographical intent of Tennessee Williams’ novella about an aging queen of the stage retiring to Rome and the boys thereof, with Lotte Lenya in a celebrated role as the procuress. But the actual Rome footage was clearly second unit stuff, with all the interiors done on a Hollywood soundstage, accenting the theatricality of the whole production, along with a lame voiceover. I was happy to watch it but can’t push it on other viewers. I look forward to being more pushy in the future.
It’s a relief to have seen a film I felt like talking about. There’s a wave of interesting new releases next week, and I’m working through the IndieWire critics poll (not as diligently as last year) before making my own pronunciamento on the best of 2008. Their #1 (The Flight of the Red Balloon) I’ve already given a lukewarm review. Their #5 (Happy-Go-Lucky) is my #1 so far, till all the votes are counted. Their #6 (Paranoid Park) earns only a shrug from me -- it was okay for a skateboarding murder mystery with arty pretensions, but the way is wide open for me to consider Milk, when I finally catch up with it, as the best Gus Van Sant movie of 2008.
Paranoid Park (2008, MC-83.) fell in a string of films that I lump together under the rubric, “These Kids Today,” about which I have little to say, except to acknowledge the camera-worthiness of the young leads. Another was Hard Candy (2006, MC-58.). Before Juno, Ellen Page was Hayley, a tough and taunting 14-year-old who does a turnabout on an older man who is stalking her. David Slade’s film was gripping in places, but so manipulative that it evaporated in the mind when it was over, except for the lingering image of a star being born. And in this category I include Friday Night Lights, more the current tv series (MC-84.), which I previewed on DirecTV, than the 2004 movie (MC-70), which I watched again after the fact. The film is much more about Texas high school football, and the true story of one season, than the portrait of community that the tv series has opened into (did I mention that the kids are attractive?). It was amusing to see the few carryovers from movie to tv series, most especially Connie Britton as the coach’s wife, who barely gets a line of dialogue in the film but becomes the central figure of the series, in delicious tandem with Kyle Chandler as the coach (Billy Bob Thornton in movie).
There’s another film I cannot rouse myself to review, but will note that I watched, for its possible inclusion in a Rome-themed film series at the Clark. I had hoped that The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone (1961) might pair nicely with Roman Holiday, but I couldn’t convince myself of the fit. It was certainly interesting to see Vivien Leigh (well past Blanche Dubois, let alone Scarlett O’Hara, but still magnetically attractive, despite having just been dumped by Laurence Olivier) at the end of her career playing off Warren Beatty (almost believable as an Italian gigolo) at the beginning of his. Also interesting was the transparent autobiographical intent of Tennessee Williams’ novella about an aging queen of the stage retiring to Rome and the boys thereof, with Lotte Lenya in a celebrated role as the procuress. But the actual Rome footage was clearly second unit stuff, with all the interiors done on a Hollywood soundstage, accenting the theatricality of the whole production, along with a lame voiceover. I was happy to watch it but can’t push it on other viewers. I look forward to being more pushy in the future.
Tuesday, February 17, 2009
W.
Neither the cathartic satire nor the excoriating expose it might have been, Oliver Stone’s film delivers a low-key but fairly honorable attempt to understand what makes Georgie Boy tick. Maybe it should have been a little wilder, but except for a fantasy sequence that is repeated long after we get what little point it has, the film comes across as a fairly straightforward docudrama with elements of sly humor. The big draw is seeing familiar faces impersonating other familiar faces, and they’re all spot on, from Josh Brolin as Bush and Richard Dreyfuss as Dick Cheney on down--wait, isn’t that Rob Corddry as Ari Fleischer?! Jeffrey Wright channels Colin Powell as we hope he was, and Thandie Newton does a wicked caricature of Condi Rice. James Cornwell and Ellen Burstyn are uncanny as the not-so-proud parents, George and Barbara. And suddenly-ubiquitous local gal Elizabeth Banks does a creditable Laura Bush. You’ll spot a bunch more (like Toby Jones, aka Capote, as the ineffable “Turdblossom/Boy Genius” Karl Rove), but Richard as (you-don’t-know-) Dick is the key, making an implausible figure plausible, and his sit-room argument for invading Iraq is speculative and Strangelovian but rings true, as Powell asks “What’s our exit strategy? How do we get out?” and the little Napoleon answers chillingly, “We don’t. We stay.” I could have done with more scenes like that and fewer detailing the familiar tales of Dubya failing upward from fratboy to President, with the not-news flash that 43 was obsessed with earning the respect of and then surpassing 41, his aloof, patrician Poppy. Still, if you’re willing to spend any more time with--say it with me now!--The Worst President Ever, then you could do worse than watching W. (2008, dvd, n.) *7-* (MC-56.)
Slumdog Millionaire
What pleases the crowd often pleases me not, but I was won over by the exuberance of Danny Boyle’s exploration of Mumbai, the clever exposition of a conventional story, and the appeal of Dev Patel as the central character in this gritty urban fairy tale of destined love. Three trios of attractive young actors hurtle the story backward and forward from the death of their mothers in anti-Muslim riots in the Bombay of the early ’80s to Patel’s appearance on the tv gameshow “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?” in the booming Mumbai of the late ’90s. The borrowings from popular culture are unabashed and nonstop, from Boyle’s self-homage to the infamous toilet scene in Trainspotting, to obvious riffs on Dickens and Dumas, to the gameshow itself, and appropriation of stars and scenes from Bollywood movies. Like the characters, the camera and music hurtle through locations pulsing with life. I expected to be put off by a film revolving around a gameshow I never cared to watch, but was rather impressed by the way it triggered flashbacks to fill in the story. It’s impossible to take this film seriously, but equally impossible not to be swept along by its energy. Genial enough in spirit that I didn’t mind having my buttons pushed so insistently, this romantic fantasy is popular entertainment that is entertaining as well as popular. (2008, Images, n.) *8* (MC-86.)
Frozen River
This Sundance fave from Courtney Hunt is perhaps a little too well-made, too crafted for audience appeal. It loses some indie cred in its effective use of thriller-type suspense. But it’s certainly an open-eyed look at a rarely-seen aspect of the American Dream, where the goal is to move up from a trailer to a double-wide. And while illegal immigration is usually the province of the Mexican border, this looks at Asians coming across the frozen St. Lawrence River from Canada, taking advantage of the mixed jurisdiction of a Mohawk reservation that straddles the river. Melissa Leo is justifiably celebrated for her role as the trailer park mother of two boys, trying to get by when her gambling-addict husband absconds with the balloon payment on their about-to-be-delivered double-wide. The wonder of her performance is that she never seems as though she’s acting, but simply inhabiting the hardscrabble life and no-nonsense attitude of the character. The impassivity of the Mohawk woman who recruits her into risky car treks across the ice may be characterization, or perhaps simply nonprofessional acting, but it works for the story. Gunplay and a Christmas miracle take the proceedings over the top, but I still give the film props for honest observation of hidden lives. (2008, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-82.)
Thursday, February 05, 2009
The Duchess
Perhaps I’m a sucker for plausible English Heritage productions, but I liked Saul Dibb’s film more than most. I discerned minor anachronisms in dialogue and attitude, but nothing like Becoming Jane or the most recent Pride and Prejudice. Meanwhile, the costumes and locations were enough to earn my endorsement. But beyond that, I found the film credible in the manner of (if a notch below) Sofia Coppola’s Marie Antoinette, making an 18th-century proto-celebrity intelligible and alive to a modern audience without excessive dumbing-down. As Georgiana, Duchess of Devonshire, Keira Knightley is more appealing to me than she has been since Bend It Like Beckham, and manages to carry off the enormous hair-dos and confining dresses. She is taken in marriage (a most appropriate phrase) by the older Duke, one of the most powerful men in Britain and patron of the Whig Party in the 1780s. Ralph Fiennes gives the imperious cold fish many subtle shadings. The unhappy Duchess becomes the star of the Party and of Society, in a manner that is not too explicitly dependent on the fate of her descendent, Lady Di. Among her attendants are Charles Fox, the playwright Richard Brinsley Sheridan (School for Scandal is inspired by her), and future Prime Minister Charles Gray. Meanwhile, she invites a distressed lady friend into her home, and then has to deal with the divorced woman’s continuing relationship with the Duke, while pursuing her own affair and affairs. This is my idea of adult entertainment. And at just over a hundred minutes, it does not overstay its welcome, a rarity these days. (2008, dvd, n.) *7* (MC-62.)
Watched in passing
For the past month I have been deeply involved with a manuscript that is now on its way to the publisher, so finally I can catch up with what I’ve been watching in passing. Certainly the most significant was another fine Japanese film resurrected by the Criterion Collection, Keisuke Kinoshita’s Twenty Four Eyes (1954). I watched it because I was looking for more of Hideko Takamine. Here she plays a beloved teacher in a village on the Inland Sea, the 24 eyes belonging to 12 students whose lives we follow from 1928 to 1946. Understandably this makes for a long and grim film, comparable to a Western “women’s weepie” and as such very popular in Japan. It’s sad and beautiful, but also slow going, and sometimes frustrating in its reliance on long shots. I mean, if you had Ingrid Bergman in your movie, you wouldn’t want to shoot her as a small figure in the landscape all the time. So just give me more of Hideko Takamine!
Inadvertently on a Japanese theme, I also watched The Cats of Mirikitani (2007, MC-73), a modest but moving personal documentary, about a homeless old Japanese painter that the filmmaker, Linda Hattendorf, discovers living on the streets of Manhattan. After 9/11 she takes him into her small apartment and in a self-effacing manner helps him put his life back together. He had been born in Sacramento but went back to Hiroshima with his mother, to return to the US to avoid being drafted before the war, only to wind up in an internment camp for three years. These are the obsessive subjects of his art, the remnants of his identity, lost along the way. Ms. Hattendorf helps him regain his citizenship and finds him a home, in an impressive act of human resurrection. There is not a false or excess moment in a film that could have been cloying and self-congratulatory.
Then there was the latest from two appealing British comics, both of which were funny enough in parts to be enjoyable, but neither close to being a good film. Steve Coogan plays a hapless high school drama teacher in Tucson in Hamlet 2 (2008, MC-54), which is in effect an understudy to the classic Waiting for Guffman. He has his moments, as does the film, and also supporting players like Catherine Keener, but as a whole it is no better than mildly amusing. (As is frequently the case, Stephanie Zacharek nails it in a way that leaves me with nothing else to say.) The same goes for Simon Pegg in Run, Fat Boy, Run (2008, MC-48), a loser who unaccountably leaves a lovely and pregnant Thandie Newton at the altar, only to try to woo her back years later by entering a London marathon to best her new stockbroker boyfriend (Hank Azaria). Both these films display an effortful wackiness but contain not the slightest surprise, basically just sitcoms on film.
As for TV itself, there’s some good stuff going these days. As a DirecTV subscriber, I’ve already watched the entire third season of Friday Night Lights (MC-84), which is now running on NBC. Recovering from some eye-rolling fumbles in Season 2, this reestablishes the show as a marvelous group portrait of a small rural Texas community where high school football is the only game in town. But it is certainly not the only game in the series, which has multiple soap opera pleasures as well as a delicious portrait of the marriage between Kyle Chandler and Connie Britton. He’s Coach Taylor and she’s now the school principal. All their interaction is a delight to watch. And then of course, there are all the high school hunks and honeys. Though better to watch on dvd, this is the rare broadcast network series worth committing to. DirecTV has used the platform to launch another series created by Peter Berg, and it’s looking pretty good after three episodes. Wonderland explores the world of a NYC mental hospital based on Bellevue, and seems involvingly interwoven and slambang in impact.
Now in progress are the fourth and final season of Battlestar Galactic (MC-85) on the SciFi Channel and the third season of Big Love (MC-79) on HBO. While each has its ludicrous moments, each ultimately is worth the time it takes to get into them. BG modulates its action with thought-provoking parallels to current international issues, and BL takes the premise of modern Mormon polygamy and delves into all sorts of amusing and touching areas of family life. The acting of the latter is more consistently up to snuff than the former, but both offer significant pleasures and provocations of continuity.
Inadvertently on a Japanese theme, I also watched The Cats of Mirikitani (2007, MC-73), a modest but moving personal documentary, about a homeless old Japanese painter that the filmmaker, Linda Hattendorf, discovers living on the streets of Manhattan. After 9/11 she takes him into her small apartment and in a self-effacing manner helps him put his life back together. He had been born in Sacramento but went back to Hiroshima with his mother, to return to the US to avoid being drafted before the war, only to wind up in an internment camp for three years. These are the obsessive subjects of his art, the remnants of his identity, lost along the way. Ms. Hattendorf helps him regain his citizenship and finds him a home, in an impressive act of human resurrection. There is not a false or excess moment in a film that could have been cloying and self-congratulatory.
Then there was the latest from two appealing British comics, both of which were funny enough in parts to be enjoyable, but neither close to being a good film. Steve Coogan plays a hapless high school drama teacher in Tucson in Hamlet 2 (2008, MC-54), which is in effect an understudy to the classic Waiting for Guffman. He has his moments, as does the film, and also supporting players like Catherine Keener, but as a whole it is no better than mildly amusing. (As is frequently the case, Stephanie Zacharek nails it in a way that leaves me with nothing else to say.) The same goes for Simon Pegg in Run, Fat Boy, Run (2008, MC-48), a loser who unaccountably leaves a lovely and pregnant Thandie Newton at the altar, only to try to woo her back years later by entering a London marathon to best her new stockbroker boyfriend (Hank Azaria). Both these films display an effortful wackiness but contain not the slightest surprise, basically just sitcoms on film.
As for TV itself, there’s some good stuff going these days. As a DirecTV subscriber, I’ve already watched the entire third season of Friday Night Lights (MC-84), which is now running on NBC. Recovering from some eye-rolling fumbles in Season 2, this reestablishes the show as a marvelous group portrait of a small rural Texas community where high school football is the only game in town. But it is certainly not the only game in the series, which has multiple soap opera pleasures as well as a delicious portrait of the marriage between Kyle Chandler and Connie Britton. He’s Coach Taylor and she’s now the school principal. All their interaction is a delight to watch. And then of course, there are all the high school hunks and honeys. Though better to watch on dvd, this is the rare broadcast network series worth committing to. DirecTV has used the platform to launch another series created by Peter Berg, and it’s looking pretty good after three episodes. Wonderland explores the world of a NYC mental hospital based on Bellevue, and seems involvingly interwoven and slambang in impact.
Now in progress are the fourth and final season of Battlestar Galactic (MC-85) on the SciFi Channel and the third season of Big Love (MC-79) on HBO. While each has its ludicrous moments, each ultimately is worth the time it takes to get into them. BG modulates its action with thought-provoking parallels to current international issues, and BL takes the premise of modern Mormon polygamy and delves into all sorts of amusing and touching areas of family life. The acting of the latter is more consistently up to snuff than the former, but both offer significant pleasures and provocations of continuity.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)