Amazingly assured -- that description applies to both this film and its subject. Director James Marsh documents the astounding feat (and feet) of aerialist Phillipe Petit -- “The Man Who Walked Between the Towers” (as in the title of Mordicai Gerstein’s superb Caldecott-winning picture book -- as good as this film is, Mordicai’s book is even better, in clarity of story and impact of illustration -- see the movie by all means, but look at the book as well!) Something between a heist film like Oceans 11 and a Maysles documentation of a Christo project, this film is well done in all its various parts -- the retrospective interviews with participants, the stylized but convincing recreations of “Le coup” on August 7, 1974 (with Nixon’s resignation playing on the tv), the vintage footage and stills, the evocative music. Marsh is adept in what he leaves out as well as what he puts in -- when he includes footage of the World Trade Center being built he doesn’t need to reference its destruction, a universal memory triggered every time an airplane appears in the film. The case is convincingly made that Petit’s impish stunt was also an aesthetic statement, an acte gratuite (“There is no why”) of surpassing beauty. One is swept up into his mad passion, as were his accomplices, without blinking at his animating solipsism. It’s fun, it’s exhilarating and inspiring, but it’s no fantasy, rather a willful act that somehow evades its consequences. Phillipe is an Icarus who flies too close to the sun and lives to tell the tale, the man who didn’t fall from the sky. (2008, Images, n.) *8+* (MC-89.)
As part of my continuing retrospective of Hollywood’s second “golden age” in the Seventies, I checked out the recent dvd release of Payday (1972) -- Rip Torn is good as a dissipated country singer on the road, but his act is a little more familiar than it was at the time, and the film is not as snappy or as authentic as it might have been. Since I’m not offering a recommendation, for accurate detail I refer you to the source I find most reliable for short reviews, both online and in its printed annual guide, i.e. Time Out.
So the Olympics end and the party conventions take their place in eating my time and keeping me from movies. I keep up quality viewing with Mad Men on AMC and Generation Kill on HBO, both of which I will write about sometime soon. As for films lately, I seem only to watch what I show, and my “Visions of a Gilded Age” film series at the Clark just concluded. I have to say I was glad to see each film again on the big screen, and each (except The Bostonians) went up in my estimation, especially the final two Edith Wharton adaptations. Age of Innocence was confirmed as a classic for me -- would that Marty Scorsese made more films like that and fewer like The Departed! Among other things, it may use narration as well as any film I’ve seen; Joanne Woodward is the perfect authorial voice, integral to the film’s texture and not something stuck in to cover gaps in the story. Sure, the sets and costumes are something to see, but it’s the characters inside the costumes that rivet the attention, from Daniel Day-Lewis and Michelle Pfieffer on down. And House of Mirth, as unmirthful as it may be and merciless in its portrait of a beautiful woman in distress, comes quite close to the mark as well -- much closer to Dreiser than Jane Austen in its portrayal of society. Terence Davies brings out the emotional brutality of the situation, and a good cast led by Gillian Anderson as Lily Bart delivers the grim reality in convincing fashion. Come to think of it, this series didn’t have much in the way of happy endings. All good to great films, however.
Steve Satullo talks about films, video, and media worth talking about. (Use search box at upper left to find films, directors, or performers.)
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query marsh man wire. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query marsh man wire. Sort by date Show all posts
Wednesday, August 27, 2008
Thursday, April 09, 2015
After the awards
In the weeks after the
Oscars are handed out, new DVD releases are backed up like planes on the runway
at O’Hare, so in this post I’ll be keeping up with the most celebrated films of
last year, as the Blu-Ray disks arrive in my mailbox. In addition to the Metacritic rating for each
film, I’ve listed an overall critical ranking, calculated by averaging
together a variety of annual critics’ polls.
I’ll start with my
biggest beef with the Academy. Really?
-- “Best Picture” of the year was Birdman (MC-88, #5,
NFX)? In a year that was graced by Boyhood? There are definitely aspects
to be enjoyed in the execution of Birdman, but I found myself utterly unmoved. Okay, maybe it would be different if I had
seen Michael Keaton as Batman, but as a protagonist caught between a past of
comic book superhero movies and a present of Broadway theatrics (two genres of
strikingly little interest to me, except All About Eve, which might
count as both), he wins my admiration for his energy, but the character offers
little insight or empathy. I would say
much the same about the admirable cast – Edward Norton, Naomi Watts, Emma
Stone, and the rest – with the exception of Amy Ryan, whom I always find
affecting, as the only person who seems to have a life outside the walls of the
theater. The co-headliner with Keaton is
cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki, whose gliding camera style is instantly
recognizable but still miraculous, as well as sinuous, continuous, and
ubiquitous. Leaving least till last, I
mention “‘Best Director’” Alejandro González Iñárritu, who I don’t really believe has
anything to say to me. I can only assume
that Academy voters filled in feelings for experiences I’ve never had.
Whiplash (MC-88, #9, NFX) built up a year’s worth of acclaim, from multiple Sundance awards to three Academy Awards on top of its Best
Picture nomination, and it’s certainly worth seeing, but apart from the
powerful performances of Miles Teller and Oscar-winner J.K. Simmons, hardly
rates a rave. To me, under-thirty
writer-director Damien Chazelle relies too much on well-worn tropes to tell the
story of an aspiring young drummer and his oh-so-demanding music school
instructor, thereby earning the sobriquet, “Full Metal Julliard.” Besides the drill sergeant veins popping out
of Simmons’ temples, and the horrific abuse that spews with spittle from his
mouth, the film plays out like dozens of sports movies, in overcoming every
manner of adversity just in time for one final rousing all-or-nothing
competition. Despite the over-hyping of
the story, there is enough personal experience in Chazelle’s film to give it an
aura of authenticity, along with its kinetic pleasures.
More engaged with The Theory of Everything (MC-72, NFX) than expected, I credit that largely
to Felicity Jones, who emerges into stardom with this film, even more than
Eddie Redmayne with his Best Actor Oscar.
I’ve always been skeptical about theoretical physicist Stephen Hawking, and
found Errol Morris’ documentary about him, A Brief History of Time,
much more interesting and unsettling than Hawking’s bestseller of the same
name, and indeed more interesting than this Hollywoodization of his life. The source for this new film was Jane
Hawking’s memoir, and maybe Felicity Jones had more material to work with, but
she is definitely the more engaging character in the film, as she commits to
Hawking at Cambridge , despite his disease and his severely limited
prognosis, and cares for him diligently for decades, during which they have
three children. Director James Marsh
showed his chops with the documentaries Man on Wire and Project Nim, but his eclectic try-anything style does not translate so well to
features. Since I am defiantly less
interested in cosmology than in family relations, I found this “theory of
marriage” more satisfying than those who were looking for some exposition of
Hawking’s own pie-in-the-sky theories.
In vein of Oscar-bait
biopics of differently-abled British geniuses, I found The Imitation Game (MC-73, NFX) somewhat less engaging, despite
Benedict Cumberbatch’s impressive impersonation of Alan Turing, the brilliant,
autistic, homosexual mathematician, famous for breaking Germany’s Enigma code
during WWII, meanwhile developing an early digital computer as well as the idea
of artificial intelligence, of which the Turing Test remains the arbiter. Given a lot to pack into a relatively short
running time, this film sacrifices depth for broad coverage. The screenplay seems a bit callow, and the
direction a bit stodgy, but the acting is good across the board, from Keira
Knightley as the one woman on the code-breaking crew at Bletchley Park ,
to the boy who plays Turing during flashbacks to his school days. With all the flashbacks and flashforwards,
plus the montage summations of the war’s progress, the film finally comes
across as overstuffed, if undernourished by genuine human complexity.
Bennett Miller seems to
be one of those well-regarded directors, indeed Oscar-nominated, who simply
isn’t on my wavelength, with a rhythm and focus different from mine. I could see plenty of good things in Foxcatcher (MC-81, #27, NFX), but as in Capote and Moneyball, something kept me from full engagement. It just
seems that he doesn’t tell me what I want to know, show me what I want to
see. There was indeed some fascination
in watching the odd but compelling performances of Steve Carell as the bizarre
duPont heir with the eagle nose; Channing Tatum as an extremely convincing
Olympic wrestler, dim and inarticulate; and Mark Ruffalo as his older brother,
also an Olympic gold medalist, but an engaging coach and family man. I was not aware of the true story behind this
film, so wasn’t sure how it would turn out, but even afterwards I had very little
sense of why. Along the way, there are
sharp observations and some implicit social and political critique, but I
didn’t come away with any particular understanding of the characters.
Sunday, February 19, 2012
Go see a doc
To me documentary is the essence of film art. Even with feature films, I appreciate as they aspire to the condition of documentary, and depreciate as they depart into fabulation, as I call the polar opposite -- Lumière vs. Méliès, actuality vs. theater, from the very beginning of film to this day. Here are some recent documentaries that support my case for aesthetic merit.
It’s safe to assert that you have never seen anything like The Arbor (2011, MC-88, NFX). Don’t be fooled by the pastoral title, this is tough stuff. The Arbor is a street in a council estate (public housing project) in the rough Yorkshire city of Bradford. Clio Barnard’s artful documentary follows the lives of Andrea Dunbar -- who won a playwriting contest at 15, had several plays produced in London, one adapted into a movie, and died in a pub restroom at the age of 29 – and her three children, by three different fathers, who each have a different response to a childhood of abuse and neglect. With levels of artifice and reality in constant flux, the film combines oddly effective lip-synching to actual audio recordings of the subjects by actors in stage-like environments, along with playing out scenes from Dunbar’s play, The Arbor, literally on the eponymous street, and even with footage from a 1989 television documentary about her. If like me you have no familiarity with Dunbar, it will take you a while to figure out what the story is about, until it settles on Dunbar’s grown-up half-Pakistani daughter, mesmerizingly portrayed by Manjinder Virk, who recapitulates her mother’s descent in a frightening collusion of flawed nature and nurture, familial substance abuse and hardscrabble environment. While highly aestheticized, this unflinching documentary is an eye-opener about the culture of poverty, to slot with Ken Loach or Mike Leigh at their grimmest.
Project Nim (2011, MC-83, NFX) investigates the strange habits of higher primates, especially the subspecies of academics and hippies. And oh yes, there’s a chimpanzee involved too. Like a slicker Errol Morris or Werner Herzog, director James Marsh (Oscar winner for Man on Wire) veers from his ostensible subject into the psyches of the strange characters who people his films. The film tells the life story of Nim Chimpsky, who was kidnapped from his mother back in the 70s and raised by an assortment of variously-motivated humans to learn sign language, and whose life takes on the ups and downs, twists and turns, changes of fortune of a Dickensian hero. The film plays as a human comedy but a simian tragedy, so each viewer will have his or her own particular mix of amusement and outrage. Re-enactments and insistent musical cues keep the story moving along, with an illuminating back and forth between archival footage and retrospective interviews, for a rich stew of a story.
Patricio Guzmán makes films that strive obsessively to combat Chile’s amnesia about its recent history, the American-sponsored 1973 coup against Allende that led to Pinochet’s military dictatorship. In Nostalgia for the Light (2011, MC-85, NFX), he goes to the Atacama Desert, the highest and driest place on earth, perfect for astronomical observatories, as well as preservation of corpses. Passages of this film are beautifully reminiscent of the cosmic raptures of Tree of Life, though it wasn’t clear to me which were genuine telescopic images and which were enhanced special effects. Astronomers and archaeologists wax philosophical on the meaning of time, of the signs of the past in the present. Then Guzmán pivots to the women who still search the desert for the bodies of their “disappeared” loved ones, since the Atacama was also the site of a Pinochet concentration camp. His narration is awfully insistent upon the parallels, but this is still an eye-opening film. The DVD includes a number of other short films that amplify and contextualize his impassioned argument about historical memory.
Among the few things I miss since canceling satellite tv service a few months ago are the documentaries on PBS and HBO, but I still manage to catch up with the important films one way or another. Two that I just checked off my watch list, but do not necessarily urge you to watch are Eames: The Architect and the Painter (2011, MC-63, NFX) and Paradise Lost 3 (2012, MC-85, NFX).
The former is a moderately interesting but gossipy look at the marriage and creative partnership between Charles and Ray Eames, which is emblematic of a number of aesthetic and gender issues, and crucial to the whole story of postwar American design, but you’d be better off watching their own films, such as Powers of Ten and The World of Franklin and Jefferson, preferably while sitting in one of their chairs.
The latter completes the story of the “West Memphis 3.” In two previous films, accomplished documentarians Joe Berlinger and Bruce Sinofsky detailed the process by which three heavy-metal Goth teens were convicted of the “satanic” murders of three young boys. Partly due to the exposure of questionable evidence and legal procedures in the first two films, the three were recently released after nearly two decades in prison, by the judicial face-saving bargain of pleading guilty (while still protesting their innocence) and being released after time served. If you’ve seen the first two films, then you’ll appreciate the closure. If you haven’t, and you can stand the grisly details of both the crime and the punishment, the trilogy is worth looking into.
Saturday, October 19, 2013
Recommended with reservations
Completeness
compels me to take note of a large number of new films released in the past
year that I’ve seen but do not urgently recommend that you see. Even the first, which I liked best of all,
requires a willing receptivity by the viewer.
Still, there’s a good chance that you will find something in this bunch
that you might like, if you can triangulate from my taste to yours. (As usual, I include links to Metacritic for more info and Netflix for availability.)
One
has to give Patrick Wang credit for the courage of his convictions with In
the Family (MC-82, NFX). Not
only writing, directing, and starring, he undertook, after many festival
rejections, his own distribution. He
definitely put himself out there, and didn’t compromise with the audience
either, at a length of nearly three hours.
The film plays out with a whispery intimacy in prolonged scenes from
fixed Ozu-like angles. But if you give
it your attention, this anti-polemic ultimately packs a punch. We open very matter-of-factly on a gay couple
with Tennessee
accents and a young son, and we quietly share some of their daily rituals. It’s an ordinary yet idyllic family, until
the unthinkable happens, a death and a custody battle, which ultimately plays
out like a Buddhist parable. This film
may put you to sleep, or it may wake you up, but for me it’s definitely the
pick of this litter.
I
could almost recommend Mud (MC-76, NFX) except for the
literal overkill of its ending. Up till
then, I liked Jeff Nichols’ latest better than his previous Take Shelter, or the highly-praised Beasts
of the Southern Wild, with which it shares a lower Mississippi setting amongst an eccentric
riverside community. The Huck and Tom of
this tale are called Ellis (a wonderful Tye Sheridan) and Neckbone, who go in
search of a boat up a tree on a deserted island in the middle of the river,
where it was tossed by a recent flood.
That magical occurrence heralds others, including first love for the
14-year-old Ellis, but mostly the meeting with the title character, marvelously
embodied by Matthew McConaughey in another of the flavorful performances that
allow one to forgive him for his “sexiest man alive” days. Mud claims to be a lover, and a killer on the
run, and enlists the boys in his quest to retrieve his darling Juniper (Reese
Witherspoon, with not a lot to do) and escape down the river. There are a number of other well-known faces
in Nichols’ good-looking indie-turned-Hollywood, Michael Shannon and Sam
Shepard for two, and it’s enjoyable to watch, until a few formulaic
implausibilities intrude on a thoughtful and attentive portrait of an exotic
subculture, and the immemorial pleasure of a boy’s own adventure.
I’d
like to recommend To the Wonder (MC-58, NFX), but in truth it’s for Terence
Malick fans only, an obsessive sketchbook of his favorite images. If you want to a see beautiful young women
dancing away from you through tall waving grasses while the music soars, then
this is the film for you. No one can deny
the pictorial delight wrought by cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki from Paris or
Mont Saint-Michel, or most remarkably, from a suburban housing development in Oklahoma . Malick has his own visual syntax, which you
get or you don’t, but here he’s mainly repeating himself, beautifully and
eloquently, but not to every taste.
You’ve got to give Ben Affleck credit for balancing the ego-trip of Argo with his submission to Malick here;
he barely gets to utter a line of dialogue and is more likely to be caught making
an inadvertent gesture than “acting.”
Same for Rachel MacAdam as an old rancher girl friend with whom he
reconnects. Javier Bardem gets a good
deal of portentous narration, but not much chance to build his character, a
priest having a crisis of disbelief but retaining his sorrowful sympathy with
humanity and the mysteries of love. But
Olga Kurylenko is the darling of Malick’s eye, dancing before our eyes as she
bewitches, then bewilders Affleck, and us too, with her high-flown
voiceovers. I could tell you the story,
but the story is not the point. The
point is the celebration of the numinous qualities of nature and light. If you’re yawning already, pass this by. If your eyes and your heart are open, then
watch it for its wonder and forgive its pondering ponderousness.
I have to give a “maybe
yes” to No (MC-81, NFX), which is the
opposite of ponderous, taking a surprisingly light-hearted and light-footed
approach to the endgame of the Pinochet dictatorship in Chile . Always a pleasure to watch, Gael Garcia
Bernal is a mostly apolitical ad man commissioned by the opposition in a
plebiscite, which Pinochet offered as thumbs up or down on his tenure in
office. Shot on 1988-vintage video
equipment that meshes seamlessly with news footage from that time, Pablo
Larrain’s film mixes Mad Men antics
with serious political commentary, as the protagonists try to sell
revolutionary change like a new brand of soda.
Can you overthrow a dictator with ad jingles featuring rainbows and sexy
girls singing and romping? According to
this droll film, you can – a pyrrhic victory for freedom and market
values. I might have preferred a good
documentary on the subject, but this Oscar nominee for Best Foreign Film was
worthy, and in its own way informative.
Since
it was also shot on vintage video, this a good spot to mention Andrew
Bujalski’s Computer Chess (MC-74, NFX) a film on which I have to recuse
myself as reviewer, because my daughter’s boyfriend is the producer. This film is set a decade earlier than No, so the video image is even scuzzier,
but if like me you used to cart around a Sony PortaPak, you will get a huge
kick out of watching the flaring and ghosting of grainy black & white
pictures, while within the frame we see some poor suckers lugging around those cumbersome
machines. Sometime around 1980, a
convention of big-time geeks, from Caltech to MIT, is gathering at a
nowheresville motel to pit their refrigerator-sized computers against each
other in a chess tournament. Meanwhile
at the same motel, an encounter group weekend is touching and feeling its way
to release, while the nerds remain attached to their machines. In its witty, low-key manner, this film
offers a neat retrospective prophecy of Facebook, Internet hook-ups, and a host
of other human interactions with technology.
Don’t take my word for it, take that of A.O. Scott in the New YorkTimes.
[Click
through for a score of recent films, not without merit, but for which my
reservations exceed my recommendation.]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)